I stumbled onto your website doing a search on Google. I saw an article about CIA medals. In answer to your question, yes, they do pop up on eBay. I have a collection of about eight different CIA medals. As for giving the medal back, I don't believe that to be true. I know a couple of people that got awarded medals for certain acts of "heroism" and they display them proudly in their home, with the certificate that accompanies it.