KÜNKER AUCTION SALES 249-252 RESULTS

PREV ARTICLE NEXT ARTICLE FULL ISSUE PREV FULL ISSUE

V17 2014 INDEX E-SYLUM ARCHIVE

The E-Sylum: Volume 17, Number 31, July 27, 2014, Article 21

Björn Schöpe of CoinsWeekly submitted this article on the results of the recent Künker auction sales. Thanks! -Editor

Hammer prices amounting to more than 9.3 million, markedly more than 50 % above the estimate of 6.15 million, individual prices ranging between 20 euros and 170,000 euros: Künker proved that virtually every collector can find its piece in the Künker auction sales.

It was a gorgeous celebration that took place on the occasion of Künker auction #250 in Osnabrück on 2 July, 2014. More than 300 guests gathered to join in and embrace the opportunity to examine the new business premises in Nobbenburger Straße 4a first-hand. Naturally, all these guests were keen bidders as well during the auction week over the course of which 5,000 lots changed hands in four auction sales. The total hammer price of 9.3 million euros, hence more than 50 % above the estimate of 6.15 million euros, testified to the market being quite healthy.

Jubilee auction sale 250 – Coins of the Kingdom of Prussia: The Masuren Collection

A magnificent event was the 250th Künker auction sale during which the Masuren Collection was sold. In the morning, Oliver Köpp compared it with the most important collection of Prussia that was ever auctioned, i.e. the one of Otto Killisch von Horn in Berlin that came on the market in 1904. The baron, however, would have been amazed to see what prices the rarities in finest grades are able to realize!

65,000 euros was the sum for which the splendid first strike of the speciesthaler 1755 of Frederick II, which was never actually issued, changed hands. There are only 16 specimens of this speciesthaler, only three of which had been available on the market since WW II.

The levantethaler of the very king 1767 cost 30,000 euros. And a pattern of the reichsthaler 1714 for Neuenburg under the Soldier King Frederick William I realized 40,000 euros. The surprise of the day was a reichthaler from Cleve from 1752 that stood out due to its fantastic condition. Having been estimated rather modestly, at 4,000 euros, the exceptional coin rose to the incredible sum of 34,000 euros!

We could go on talking about results in the five-figure regions. Like, for example, the Williams dor from 1740 in very fine to extremely fine that started with an estimate of 3,500 euros only to arrive at 24,000 euros in the end! Or the very rare reichsthaler of Frederick William I that obtained not the expected 8,000 euros but 22,000 euros instead. Yet all these six-figure results would only hide the fact that collectors with less money to spend had a decent chance to acquire an interesting piece as well. Just like any true collection, the Masuren Collection comprised not only an A-list but a B-list as well. Bids as low as 20 euros were accepted, and one bidder actually was lucky at that sum. Most of the lots were sold for prices ranging in the lower three-figure regions.

Auction sale 249 – Coins and Medals from Medieval to Modern Times / Münster and Westphalia, The Dieter Braun Collection It goes without saying that the Masuren Collection was not the only highlight of this auction week. It had already started with a bombshell, albeit a bombshell that was to be expected. Künker had offered in previous auctions patterns of Chinese coins that had been produced by the Prägeanstalt Otto Beh in Esslingen in 1897. Every time so far the result has exceeded the estimate by far. This auction sale included four examples – all coming with a pre-sale price tag of 5,000 euros. There were huge differences regarding the results achieved. While the 10 cash piece from the Huan Province increased to ‘mere’ 11,000 euros and a 20 cent piece from the Fentien Province to 20,000 euros, the patterns for the Heilongjiang Province, adjacent to Russia, obtained 24,000 and 75,000 euros, respectively!

That a coin collection that was assembled with love, interest and expertise not only brings a great deal of joy but might become an interesting investment as well was proven by Dieter Braun who, over the course of decades, had put together a collection that was special in the literal sense of the word: Münster and Westphalia in the Context of the European Monetary History.

Absolutely every collector of this field had shown up, and so the great rarities realized the appropriate prices, and this goes not just for the eye-catching gems. This is just one telling example: you had to really know the subject to recognize the pfennig of Burchard von Holte (1098-1118), bearing lot no. 1674, as being something special. The potential customers were well aware and made the piece increase from 250 euros to 2,800 euros. Much more obvious was the case of the goldgulden of Heinrich von Schwarzburg (1466-1496) that sold for 17,000 euros (estimate: 10,000 euros). The three most expensive coins had all been struck by order of Bernhard von Galen: a 6 ducat piece 1661 realized 28,000 euros, a double ducat n. d. 34,000 euros and a 1.5 ducat klippe from 1652 likewise 34,000 euros.

Auction sale 251 – Gold Coins / Russian Coins and Medals These, however, were by no means the highest prices the auction week witnessed. It was left for the gold coinage in auction 251 to win that title. The most expensive coin of the auction week became a Polish 5 ducat piece 1623 from Bromberg of which only three examples are known to exist. The bidding fight for the perfectly preserved item only stopped at 170,000 euros! That makes about 210,000 euros for the proud new owner to pay.

The other results likewise were nothing to sneeze at, though. The 5 pound piece 1839 of the “Una and the Lion” type had been estimated at 50,000 euros although the end result was not less than 65,000 euros. A rare 10 ducat piece from Czechoslovakia from Kremnitz from 1951 with a mintage of just 56 specimens brought 50,000 euros, and a Hungarian 10 ducate piece of Michael Apafi, minted in Klausenburg in 1671, 38,000 euros.

Germany saw some marvelous results, too. A 10 thaler piece of Charles I of Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel, minted in Brunswick in 1779, cost 20,000 euros (estimate: 10,000 euros), an extremely fine 5 thaler of the duke of Mecklenburg-Schwerin from 1754 realized 16,000 euros (estimate: 5,000 euros), and an extraordinarily preserved 6 ducat piece 1698 from Nuremberg on the anniversary celebration of the Treaty of Ryswick 44,000 euros (estimate: 7,500 euros).

Naturally, the Russian coins sprang many a surprise as well. A rouble of Ivan III from St. Petersburg from 1741 rose to 52,500 euros (estimate: 30,000 euros), a rouble of Nicholas I 1841 on the wedding of his son realized 40,000 euros (estimate: 15,000 euros), while a gold medal of Alexander II from 1859 on the erection of the monument for Nicholas I even brought 100,000 euros (estimate: 75,000 euros).

A real surprise was the modest, but extremely rare silver badge from Fabergé as numismatic documentation of the beginning of the construction of Russian submarines in 1914. Having been estimated at just 1,000 euros, the impressive hammer price was 22,000 euros in the end.

Auction sale 252 – German Coins since 1871 Let us conclude this review with some remarkable results from the section of Imperial Coinage. The Saxon 3 mark piece “Frederick the Wise” in proof changed hands for 67,000 euros. The 20 mark piece 1873 from Mecklenburg-Strelitz in extremely fine to proof-like increased from 10,000 euros to 21,000 euros, and the same denomination from Saxe-Coburg-Gotha from 1872 in good very fine to 52,500 euros, while the hammer fell at 30,000 euros (estimate: 20,000 euros) for a 20 mark piece 1895 for German New Guinea in about proof-like.

By the way, the unique pattern of the Saxon “Frederick the Wise” likewise rose a bit higher compared to its pre-sale estimate. It increased from 5,000 to 15,000 euros. If the new owner wanted this pattern as substitute or rather as supplement for the same piece in silver, we cannot say for sure.

You may find all results on the Künker website at www.kuenker.de. Our autumn auction sales are scheduled for 6 to 10 October, 2014. The catalogs can be requested at Künker, Gutenbergstraße 23, D-49 076 Osnabrück; phone: +49 (0)541 / 96 20 20; fax: +49 (0)541 / 96 20 222; or by email: service@kuenker.de.

Lot 460: CHINA. Prägeanstalt Otto Beh, Esslingen. Heilongjiang Province. Pattern of 20 cents (1 mace, 4.4 candareens) n. d. (1897) in brass. Unpublished. About proof-like. Estimate: 5,000,- euros. Hammer price: 75,000,- euros

Lot 1674: MÜNSTER. Burchard von Holte (1098-1118). Pfennig, Münster. Ilisch IV, 3var. Very rare. Good very fine. Estimate: 250,- euros. Hammer price: 2,800,- euros

Lot 1714: MÜNSTER. Konrad von Rietberg (1497-1508). 1/2 goldgulden n. d., Münster. Fb. 1757. Extremely rare. Very fine. Estimate: 7,500,- euros. Hammer price: 17,000,- euros

Lot 1729: MÜNSTER. Christoph Bernhard von Galen (1650-1678). 2 ducats n. d. (1661-1678), Münster. Fb. 1768. Extremely rare. Extremely fine. Estimate: 10,000,- euros. Hammer price: 34,000,- euros

Lot 1824: MÜNSTER. Gold pattern struck by dies of the copper pfennig 1790.Weinrich 75 note. Extremely rare. Extremely fine. Estimate: 2,500,- euros. Hammer price: 12,000,- euros

Lot 2560: PRUSSIA. Frederick William I (1713-1740). Williams dor 1740 EGN, Berlin. Fb. 2363. Rare. Very fine to extremely fine. Estimate: 3,500,- euros. Hammer price: 24,000,- euros

Lot 2599: PRUSSIA. Frederick William I (1713-1740). Reichsthaler 1714, Neuenburg. Dav. 1777. Very rare. About extremely fine. Estimate: 15,000,- euros. Hammer price: 40,000,- euros

Lot 2738: PRUSSIA. Frederick II (1740-1786). Prussian reichsthaler 1752 C, Cleve. Dav. 2584. Extremely rare in this grade. About proof-like. Estimate: 4,000,- euros. Hammer price: 34,000,- euros

Lot 2753: PRUSSIA. Frederick II (1740-1786). Speciesthaler 1755, Berlin. Dav. 2592. One of 16 specimens struck by the original dies posthumously in 1787. First strike. About proof-like. Estimate: 30,000,- euros. Hammer price: 65,000,- euros

Lot 2757: PRUSSIA. Frederick II. (1740-1786). Levantethaler 1767, Berlin or Magdeburg. Dav. 2596. Old. 372. Extremely rare. Extremely fine. Estimate: 10,000,- euros. Hammer price: 30,000,- euros

Lot 3078: GREAT BRITAIN. Victoria (1837-1901). 5 pounds 1839, London. “Una and the Lion”. Seaby 3851. Very rare. Proof. Estimate: 50,000,- euros. Hammer price: 65,000,- euros

Lot 3145: POLAND. Sigismund III (1587-1632). 5 ducats 1623, Bromberg. Fb. 78. Only three specimens known to exist. Extremely fine to proof-like. Estimate: 125,000,- euros. Hammer price: 170,000,- euros

Lot 3202: CZECHOSLOVAKIA. Republic. 10 ducats 1951, Kremnitz. Fb. 4. Mintage only 56 specimens. About proof-like. Estimate: 15,000,- euros. Hammer price: 50,000,- euros

Lot 3295: MAROCCO. Hassan II (1962-1999). 5 Dirhams 1965 / 1384 AH. pattern. Very rare. About proof-like. Estimate: 1,000,- euros. Hammer price: 11,000,- euros

Lot 3489: BRUNSWICK-WOLFENBÜTTEL. Charles I (1735-1780). 10 thaler 1779, Brunswick. Fb. – (see 713). Probably unique specimen. About proof-like. Estimate: 10,000,- euros. Hammer price: 20,000,- euros

Lot 3521: HESSE-KASSEL. William (IX) I (1785-1803-1821). 5 thaler 1820, Kassel. Fb. 1292. Probably the only specimen available on the market. Extremely fine. Estimate: 30,000,- euros. Hammer price: 34,000,- euros

Lot 3561: NUREMBERG. 6 ducats 1698 on the anniversary of the Treaty of Ryswick. Fb. 1872. Very rare. Extremely fine to proof-like. Estimate: 7,500,- euros. Hammer price: 44,000,- euros

Lot 3783: RUSSIA. Ivan III (1740-1741). Rouble 1741, St. Petersburg. Dav. 1676. Extremely rare. Very fine. Estimate: 30,000,- euros. Hammer price: 52,500,- euros

Lot 3953: RUSSIA. Alexander I (1801-1825). Rouble 180_, St. Petersburg. Pattern Bitkin 666. Very rare. Extremely fine to proof-like. Estimate: 30,000,- euros. Hammer price: 48,000,- euros

Lot 4064: RUSSIA. Nicholas I (1825-1855). 1 1/2 rouble (10 zlotych) 1836 (minted in 1836/7), St. Petersburg. Family rouble. Dav. 286B. Mintage only 15 specimens. About proof-like. Estimate: 50,000,- euros. Hammer price: 85,000,- euros

Lot 4151: RUSSIA. Alexander II (1855-1881). Gold medal 1859 by P. Brusnitsyn on the erection of the monument for Nicholas I in St. Petersburg. Diakov 681.1. Very rare. Extremely fine to proof-like. Estimate: 75,000,- euros. Hammer price: 100,000,- euros

Lot 4283: RUSSIA. Nicholas II (1894-1917). Silber badge 1914 by K. Fabergé on the initial plans for the construction of a submarine boat by Noblessner. In original green casket. Extremely fine. Estimate: 1,000,- euros. Hammer price: 22,000,- euros

Lot 4520: IMPERIAL COINAGE. 1/2 mark 1908 AB. J. 16. Extremely rare. Proof. Estimate: 6,000,- euros. Hammer price: 10,000,- euros

Lot 4705: IMPERIAL COINAGE. Saxony. Frederick August III (1904-1918). 3 mark 1917 E. On the 400th Jubilee of the Reformation. J. 141. Very rare. Proof. Estimate: 60,000,- euros. Hammer price: 67,000,- euros

Lot 5063: IMPERIAL COINAGE. Saxe-Coburg-Gotha. Ernst II, 1844-1893. 20 mark 1872. J. 270. Rarest type of all imperial gold coins. Good very fine. Estimate: 40,000,- euros. Hammer price: 52,500,- euros

Lot 5128: GERMAN NEW GUINEA. 20 New Guinea mark 1895 A. J. 709. Very rare. About proof-like. Estimate: 20,000,- euros. Hammer price: 30,000,- euros

Lot 5509: IMPERIAL COINAGE. Saxony. Frederick August III (1904-1918). 3 mark 1917 E in aluminium. Schaaf -. Beckenbauer Coll. -. See J. 141. Unique specimen. Extremely fine. Estimate: 5,000,- euros. Hammer price: 15,000,- euros