I've always been enamored by 18th century British tokens. I once collected U.S. civil war tokens for many of the same reasons; these (initially) were a real response to a shortage of coinage, and include a vast array of interesting designs and issuers, each with a unique story.
As collectors got involved, makers dreamed up a number of offbeat metal and die marriage varieties for the collector market. I could never get much interested in these concoctions, but for collectors today it can be difficult to sort the "real" tokens from the pseudo-tokens.
The Introduction to the catalogue of Baldwin's Auction 92 of 18th century British tokens (written by Gary Groll) discusses the complexity of the series and the firm's decision on the arrangement of the catalog. Here's an excerpt.
-Editor
The provincial tokens issued in the late 18th Century in England, Wales, Scotland and Ireland form a complex series, essentially composed of a variety of types (as circulating coinage, store cards, political and social commentary, private tokens, and those made for collectors) and for a variety of purposes. There are genuine issues, counterfeits, medley tokens (mules and edge varieties), specious fabrications, restrikes, off metal trials and presentation pieces, odd concoctions, as well as surviving artist's proofs and die trials. As a result, they may be organised, arranged, catalogued or collected in any one of a number of ways.
The tokens in this auction have been arranged alphabetically by issuer. This was a choice made early on in the cataloguing process and was done to place a greater emphasis on the individuals responsible, instead of their assigned geographic location. This arrangement provides for a different sense of the quantity and variety of tokens issued by a specific individual, or individuals, or a company as the case may be, as well as facilitating the tracing of die links and states. Clearly there may be some concerns and for this, we can only hope that you will take the time to explore a path less travelled.
Citations are listed, where available, for Conder Pye, The Virtuoso's Companion and Atkins, as well as Dalton & Hamer. There is reason for this. While Dalton & Hamer seemed to have had access to part of Cokayne's collection prior to their publications, there is evidence that that may not have been the case with others. Nor were their efforts universally accepted. As late as 1936, Glendining's Sale of Frederick Lincoln's Collection was listed only according to Atkins and not Dalton & Hamer's Provincial Token Coinage, although the latter had been completed and in print for nearly two decades. I was fortunate to have had access to Baldwin's extensive library that included not only annotated reference volumes and auction catalogues, but also Cokayne's personal notes that were invaluable in bridging
the gap between James Atkins' Tradesmen's Tokens and Dalton & Hamer, as well as confirming provenance and dates of acquisition.
I think the arrangement alphabetically by issuer is a good one, and will make this catalog a useful reference, even if only as an index to the other references the pieces appear in. The Introduction includes an extensive bibliography of references cited. I've selected several of the more comprehensive ones below, which were published as early as 1795 (and make a fine collection themselves).
-Editor
Atkins, James. The Tradesmen's Tokens of the Eighteenth Century, London 1892
Bell, Robert C.
-
Commercial Coins. 1787-1804, Newcastle upon Tyne, 1963
-
Tradesmen's Tickets and Private Tokens 1785-1819, Newcastle upon Tyne, 1966
-
Specious Tokens and Those Struck for General Circulation, Newcastle upon Tyne, 1968
-
The Building Medalets of Kempson and Skidmore 1796-1797, Newcastle upon Tyne, 1978
-
Political and Commemorative Pieces Simulating Tradesmen's Tokens 1770-1802, Felixstowe, 1987
Conder, James. An Arrangement of Provincial Coins, Tokens and Medalets, London 1798
Dalton, R. and Hamer, S. The Provincial Token-Coinage of the 18th Century, 1910-1918, reprinted by Allan Davisson with additions and notes 2004
Denton, M., and Prattent, T. The Virtuoso's Companion, London 1795-1798
Dykes, David. Coinage and Currency in Eighteenth Century Britain, London 2011
Longman, W. Tokens of the Eighteenth Century Connected With Booksellers & Bookmakers, London 1916
Lusk, Jon. British and Irish Tradesmen and their Copper Tokens of 1787 - 1804, Ypsilanti, Michigan, USA, 2014
Pye, Charles. Provincial Copper Coins, Birmingham, 1801
Samuel, Richard T. ‘Provincial Copper Coins and Tokens', The Bazaar, Exchange and Mart and Journal of the Household, 1880-1889
Sharp, Thomas ‘A Catalogue of Provincial Copper Coins, Tokens, Tickets, and Medalets' in the collection of Sir George Chetwynd, London, 1834
Spence, Thomas. The Coin Collector's Companion, London, 1795
To read the complete catalog, see:
www.baldwin.co.uk/auction-92/
THE BOOK BAZARRE
THE KENNEDY WORLD IN MEDALLIC ART.
Available this month: William Rice's massive new history and illustrated catalog of John F. Kennedy in medals, coins, tokens, and other collectibles. Hardcover, 304 pages, 8.5 x 11 inches, full color, $19.95. Order your copy
at
Whitman.com or call 1-800-546-2995.
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: https://my.binhost.com/lists/listinfo/esylum
Copyright © 1998 - 2024 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|