E-Sylum Feature Writer and
and Coryphaeus American Numismatic Biographies, Pete Smith
submitted this article on the "Father of Numismatic Science." Thanks!
-Editor
This week I step out of my comfortable rut, writing about American numismatics personalities,
and into the broad area of world numismatics. My topic is the man called the father of
numismatic science.
Joseph Hilarius Eckhel (1737-1798)
In about 1960, my father bought a set of the 1911 Encyclopedia Brittanica from a neighbor. The
set is now in my library. It is not often that I get the opportunity to quote it. This listing has not
improved since 1911.
"ECKHEL. JOSEPH HILARIUS (1737-1798). Austrian numismatist. Was born at Enzersfeld
in lower Austria, 1737. His father was the farm-steward to Count Zinzendorf, and he received his
early education at the Jesuits' College, Vienna, where at the age of fourteen he was admitted to
the order. He devoted himself to antiquities and numismatics. After being engaged as professor
of poetry and rhetoric, first at Steyer and afterwards at Vienna, he was appointed in 1772 keeper
of the cabinet of coins at the Jesuits' College, and in the same year he was sent to Italy for the
purpose of personal inspection and studies of antiquities and coins. At Florence he was employed
to arrange the collection of the grand duke of Tuscany; and the first-fruits of his study of this and
other collections appeared in his Numi veteres anecdoti, published in 1773. On the dissolution of
the order of Jesuits in 1773, Eckhel was appointed by the empress Maria Theresa professor of
antiquities and numismatics at the university of Vienna, and this post he held for twenty-four
years. He was in the following year made keeper of the imperial cabinet of coins, and in 1779
appeared his Catalogus Vindobonensis numorum veterum. Eckhel's great work is the Doctrina
numorum veterum in 8 vols., the first of which was published in 1792. The author's rich learning,
comprehensive grasp of his subject, admirable order, and precision of statement, in this
masterpiece drew from Heyne enthusiastic praise, and the acknowledgement that Eckhel, as the
Coryphaeus of numismatists, had, out of the mass of previously loose and confused facts,
constructed a true science. A volume of Addenda, was published in 1826. Among his other
works are Choix de pierres gravees du Cabinet Imperial des Antiques (1788), a useful school-book on coins entitled Kurzgefasste Anfangsgrunde zur alten Numismatik (1787), of which a
French version enlarged by Jacob appeared in 1823, &c. Eckhel died at Vienna on the 16th of
May 1798."
My father did not acquire the 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia which provides additional information
on Eckhel. His father was Johann Anton Eckhel. After transcribing the above, I did not feel like
transcribing the entire listing from The Catholic Encyclopedia. I will include a few quotes.
"His delivery is described as being simple, clear, instructive, inspiring, and often abounding in
humour. He was highly regarded by his pupils. That he also enjoyed high repute among his
colleagues is attested by his appointment as dean of the philosophical faculty in 1789. However,
he soon resigned this position."
This includes a later quote from Friederich Kenner:
"Misguided dilettantism had produced most mischievous results in the field of Numismatics.
Lack of system, want of critical judgement, and the disorderly arrangement of the literature had
begotten confusion and distrust, which prevented numismatists from taking the place among
other sciences to which it was entitled. … Numismatics, hitherto despised, he changed into a
kind of encyclopedia of classical antiquities, which includes extensive and much-used sources
for other branches of archaeology."
Prior to Eckhel's work, coin collections were generally described in alphabetical order and with
little historical context. Eckhel organized coins according to the cities, other than Rome, where
they were issued. He organized Roman coins based on chronology.
The Eckhel system is now called "Eckhelsche Ordnung." In addition to the organization, Eckhel
corrected previous misattributions and identified spurious coins.
As with many first attempts, Eckhel made some errors in attribution. Numismatic science allows
for corrections to be made as new information is developed.
If you wish to read Doctrina numorum veterum in Latin, it is available on Internet Archive. I
suspect that few readers of The E-Sylum will take the opportunity. I also suspect there were few
readers of coin books in Latin when this was published in 1792. The series may have
revolutionized the organization of scholarly works, but they failed to popularize the hobby.
For their tenth anniversary in 1880, The Numismatic Society of Vienna commissioned a medal in
honor of Eckhel, The metal for the medal came from melted ancient coins. How many ancient
coins were sacrificed to make the medals?
In 1972, a side street was named for him in Vienna.
In 2015, from May 27 to 30, a conference was held at the Austrian Academy of Sciences,
organized by Bernard Woytek and Daniela Williams. The conference featured 21 speakers.
Just two years ago in 2022, a book on Eckhel was published. Ars critica numaria, Joseph Eckhel
(1737-1798) and the development of numismatic method. The book was compiled by Bernard
Woytek and Daniela Williams from the papers presented at the 2015 conference on Eckhel. A
PDF version of the book my be found at
https://austriaca.at/0xc1aa5576_0x003da939.pdf
To read the earlier E-Sylum articles, see:
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON JOSEPH ECKHEL A SUCCESS
(https://www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v18n30a23.html)
NEW BOOK: ARS CRITICA NUMARIA
(https://www.coinbooks.org/v25/esylum_v25n38a03.html)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: https://my.binhost.com/lists/listinfo/esylum
Copyright © 1998 - 2023 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|