The Numismatic Bibliomania Society

PREV ARTICLE       NEXT ARTICLE       FULL ISSUE       PREV FULL ISSUE      

V29 2026 INDEX       E-SYLUM ARCHIVE

The E-Sylum: Volume 29, Number 46, 2026, Article 9

MORE ON XRF COIN COMPOSITION ANALYSIS

Traces of Gold?
Dick Hanscom writes:

"Might I suggest that the presence of gold in these CN coins could be due to trace gold in the copper that could not be removed, or perhaps was not worth removing? I seem to recall reading that the Siberian copper kopeks were at a different standard from the Russian coppers because they had traces of gold that could not be refined out."

Check the Machine
Jonathan Brecher writes:

"Regarding the XRF article in last week's E-Sylum, I'm struck by the comment, "All three coins share an absolutely identical, non-standard trace element profile."

"Whenever I see odd results that are consistently odd, my first thought would always be to look at the source of the results, in this case the machine doing the reading. That article implies that all of the coins were analyzed by the same machine. If that's the case, one possible explanation is that the machine is slightly miscalibrated.

"One way to test that would be to see if a second machine gives the same results. That of course needs a second machine, which might not be easily available.

"Another way to test would be to look at more examples. If many more coins give the same odd readings — especially when looking at "fresh from the mint" recent strikes — that would be a a good sign that the machine is reporting trace elements that aren't actually there."

Trace Elements Are Normal
Pete Smith writes:

Some ten years ago I did some experiments with XRF testing. I had access to a table top model at a local refiner. I brought in several Spanish colonial eight real coins from the 1790's.

I was looking for some correlation between the Spanish "dollars" and the United States 1792 half dismes. I did not find any significant correlation.

We put one coin in the machine and tested five different locations on the coin. The results were different each time.

I was told that XRF testing was qualitative but not quantitative. In other words, we could see what was there but not how much was there.

Silver coins begin with a silver bar poured from molten medal. As the metal cools, the elements may solidify at different rates. Trace elements may migrate to the outer edges of the bar and show up as distorted results during testing.

Back in the eighteenth century, it was impossible for refiners to produce pure silver and copper. The results always include trace elements and these can help distinguish old coins from modern copies.

The recent article in The E-Sylum stated, "To my astonishment, both coins share an absolutely identical trace element profile that does not match their official recipes." The USSR 10 Kopecks piece is 80 percent copper and 20 percent nickel. The U. S. Buffalo nickel is 75 percent copper and 25 percent nickel. The trace elements show different amount of the same metals.

I don't believe that testing one coin can prove the composition of any larger class of coins. If ten coins were tested, the range of results might show a significant pattern. In short, the appearance of trace elements is entirely normal and not significant.

John Lorenzo's Thoughts
John Lorenzo writes:

"Winston Zack's interpretation is the more scientifically conservative and defensible conclusion. While the reported trace elements may initially appear similar, the data do not demonstrate an identical metallurgical fingerprint. The Soviet 10 Kopecks and Buffalo nickel differ in their copper, nickel, manganese, iron, cobalt, and reported gold concentrations, and the same variability is present among the Swiss, Danish, and Kuwaiti coins. Trace amounts of iron, manganese, and cobalt are commonly encountered in copper-nickel alloys because these elements occur naturally in ore deposits, refining streams, alloying materials, industrial equipment, and recycled metal feedstocks. Their presence alone is therefore insufficient evidence for a common source of metal or a shared technological program.

A second issue is the limitation of handheld XRF technology when evaluating trace constituents. Portable XRF instruments are excellent for determining major alloy components such as copper and nickel, but measurement uncertainty increases substantially as concentrations approach the lower detection limits of the instrument. Surface contamination, corrosion products, dirt, handling residues, wear patterns, calibration algorithms, and spectral interferences can all influence reported trace-element values. The reported gold concentrations are particularly problematic because gold is not an expected constituent of these coinage alloys. At levels of only a few hundredths of a percent, such readings should be treated cautiously until confirmed by more sensitive laboratory techniques. Many experienced XRF users have observed occasional trace precious-metal or platinum-group-element identifications that are difficult to reconcile with known metallurgy and are more likely related to instrumental limitations than genuine alloy composition.

For these reasons, XRF data alone cannot establish provenance. Even if every trace element reported by the instrument were genuine, similar elemental compositions can arise from numerous unrelated ore bodies, refining operations, recycling streams, and manufacturing processes. Two mints on opposite sides of the world can independently produce alloys with comparable trace impurities simply because they are drawing upon broadly similar industrial metal supplies. Provenance studies therefore require much more than a comparison of a few trace elements. Researchers typically seek converging lines of evidence from elemental chemistry, metallurgical structure, production records, historical documentation, and large comparative datasets before proposing a common source of metal.

When provenance is the objective, isotope analysis is generally far more powerful than XRF elemental screening. In particular, lead isotope analysis measures the relative abundances of naturally occurring lead isotopes such as ^204Pb, ^206Pb, ^207Pb, and ^208Pb. Because ore deposits formed under different geological conditions and at different times, they often possess distinctive isotopic signatures that survive mining, smelting, and alloy manufacture. As a result, two coins can exhibit nearly identical elemental compositions yet originate from completely different sources of metal, while metals from the same ore body may retain comparable isotopic characteristics despite later processing. For this reason, modern provenance research in archaeology and archaeometallurgy frequently relies on isotopic studies in combination with elemental analysis. XRF can help identify what elements are present, but isotopic techniques provide a much stronger basis for determining where a metal originated and whether a true metallurgical connection exists between otherwise unrelated objects."

Numismatic Research using XRF
Kavan Ratnatunga writes:

"I am currently doing numismatic research on the metallurgy of ancient Lankan coins. My goal is to trace the geographical origin of their precious metals (gold and silver) and study ancient minting technologies by measuring trace impurities. In 2026 February, I obtained an ElvaX Jewelry Lab benchtop XRF spectrometer equipped with an SDD detector with 0.127 keV FWHM at Mn Ka. ( https://elvatech.com/products/elvax-jewelry-lab/ )

"I am a retired Astrophysicist who developed automated image analysis software for the NASA Hubble Space Telescope. Using this experience, I am currently developing statistical digital spectral analysis software to improve on the ElvaX software given with the instrument for use in the jewelry trade. I would like to get in contact with those doing Numismatic Research using XRF. WhatsApp: +94712537551 email: kavanr@gmail.com"

Thanks, everyone. -Editor

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
QUERY: XRF COIN COMPOSITION ANALYSIS (https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n45a16.html)

MSNS E-Sylum ad 2026-11 Show



Wayne Homren, Editor

Google
 
NBS (coinbooks.org) Web

The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.

To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address: whomren@gmail.com

To subscribe go to: Subscribe

PREV ARTICLE       NEXT ARTICLE       FULL ISSUE       PREV FULL ISSUE      

V29 2026 INDEX       E-SYLUM ARCHIVE

Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.

NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
coin