E-Sylum Feature Writer and American Numismatic Biographies author Pete Smith submitted this follow-up on a recent 1792 Half Disme offering.
-Editor
Two Stories
The November 8 issue of The E-Sylum mentioned the upcoming sale of a 1792 half disme by Stack's Bowers on November 17. Here are two stories that are not mentioned in the Auction catalog.
My description of the coin took a full page in 1792: Birth of a Nation's Coinage. I thought the sale history was particularly interesting. This is what I wrote:
"The coin provides an interesting case study for pedigree research, certification and gradeflation. An observer who does not have the complete story may form an incorrect opinion of value.
Superior 1989:891 "The handsome specimen from Bowers & Ruddy's renowned Garrett Saleā¦"
And seven months later, Superior 1990:3550 "Although the present coin does not come with a pedigree attached to it, because it is in such marvelous condition, chances are good it was one of those early pieces given out by Jefferson."
In later sales the Garrett pedigree was also not mentioned.
-
When sold at auction in 1914, it was described as extremely fine.
-
When sold in the 1981 Garrett sale, the coin was uncertified and described as Choice AU.
-
When sold by Superior in 1989 with the Garrett pedigree, the coin was described as AU-55.
-
When sold in 1990 without the Garrett pedigree, the coin was in a PCGS MS-63 holder and
realized $60,500. Four months earlier Superior sold a PCGS MS-65 coin for $137,500.
-
In 1997 the coin was reported to be in a PCGS MS-64 holder.
-
When offered for sale by Bowers and Ruddy in 2004 as lot 1383, it was certified by NGC as
MS-66.
-
For the Heritage sale of April 27, 2006, the catalog listed the highest graded 1792 half
dismes. This listing stated that the Garrett coin was now in an NGC MS-66 holder. This
information has subsequently been repeated in other catalogs.
-
The Garrett coin was downgraded by NGC to MS-65 in 2009. The NGC MS-66 coin was
deleted from the census.
-
On 5/14/2015 it was recertified NGC MS-65 3319274-001.
-
The coin that brought $137,500 in 1990, sold for $528,750 in 2014, still in an MS-65 holder.
The Garrett coin, in an MS-63 holder that brought $60,500 in 1990, brought $552,000 in
2009, in an MS-65 holder."
* * * * * * *
The Garrett 1792 half disme made an appearance on the Pawn Stars TV show on January 29, 2018. Walt Husak brought it into the shop and offered it to host Rick Harrison. He declined to buy it.
Husak did not own the coin. At the time it was owned by Steve Contursi and Rare Coin Wholesalers. It was offered several years from 2011 to 2014 at the ANA WFOM.
This is an example of a contrived story on the show that was arranged in advance.
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|