Is it too rare to be real? Numismatic experts squared off in the English county of Norfolk over the authenticity of a unique gold Anglo-Saxon thrymsa submitted by a metal detectorist. Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online.
-Editor
The object was found at an undisclosed location and reported the Norfolk coroner to adjudicate whether it be declared treasure.
But at a remarkable hearing, a disagreement saw one expert suggest it could be a potentially unique discovery while two others questioned if it was even genuine.
The unusual proceedings attracted a packed courtroom at Norfolk County Hall, where metal detectorist Ray Jenkins was joined by friends and family to hear the fate of his discovery.
Even staff at County Hall had filled the public gallery, drawn by a fascinating archaeological mystery which was about to expose a fundamental disagreement between experts.
On one side was Dr Adrian Marsden, a specialist in historic coins, who insisted the gold coin, known as a thrymsa, was genuine.
On the other were Dr John Naylor, National Finds Adviser for the Portable Antiquities Scheme at the Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford, and Dr Wendy Scott, a curator at Norwich Castle Museum, who both challenged its authenticity.
Dr Marsden attended the hearing in person alongside the finder, while Dr Naylor and Dr Scott gave their evidence by live video link.
At the centre of the dispute was a coin believed to date from around AD 625, the period of the famous Sutton Hoo burial, but featuring designs which experts said were unlike those ordinarily associated with the period.
For Dr Marsden, that was precisely what made the discovery so exciting.
He argued that experts needed to recognise the significance of the Norfolk findspot, drawing comparisons with Rendlesham in Suffolk, an important Anglo-Saxon royal settlement.
His frustration centred on what he regarded as a circular argument: that an object potentially representing the first known example of its type was being doubted precisely because no other examples existed.
If every previously unknown object was dismissed because it differed from established examples, his argument suggested, how could archaeology ever recognise something genuinely new?
The competing interpretations left the court confronting an intriguing archaeological dilemma.
Were the unusual details evidence that the coin could not have been made in the seventh century, or were they the very characteristics which made it an extraordinary discovery?
The court has not yet issued a verdict. Interesting case, which reminds me of Eric Newman's investigation of the Good Samaritan Shilling. Are readers aware of similar numismatic disputes over ancient or medeival coinage?
-Editor
To read the complete article, see:
Too rare to be real? Questions asked over gold coin
(https://www.wymondhamandattleboroughmercury.co.uk/ news/26719821.rare-real-questions-asked-gold-coin/)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|