|
Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 7, Number 24, June 13, 2004: an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society. Copyright (c) 2004, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society. UPCOMING ASYLUM ISSUES E. Tomlinson Fort, Editor of our print publication, The Asylum writes: "Lots of good news. The Spring 2004 issue of The Asylum is now being proofed and should be on its way to the printer within a week. The contents are: "The Quest to Build the Set," by Stephen Pradier. In which the author discusses the problems of putting together a complete set of The Numismatist. "Mendacity Rears Its Ugly Head," by Myron Xenos. In which the author combs through the evidence to reveal the identity of the greatest prankster in the history of numismatic literature. "Numismatic Sidelights: Perry W. Fuller," by Leonard Augsburger. An overview of the career of the man who catalogued the famous Baltimore hoard. If you have not joined the NBS yet, shame on you. We are presently hard at work on our special Summer 2004 issue. The contents will be as follows: "Jean Foy-Vaillant: The King's Antiquary (1632 - 1706)," by Christian E. Dekesel. A massive study of the life and works of a numismatic writer at the court of Louis XIV. This work has a full bibliographic listing of all Foy-Vallant's works, including those which will appear in the author's forthcoming multi-volume bibliography of 18th century numismatic books. 'William Frederick Mayers: A Flashing Star,' by Pete Smith. A short overview of the career of the man who wrote the first essay on numismatic literature to be published in the United States. "An Annotated Bibliography of the Published Numismatic Writings of Walter H. Breen" by David F. Fanning. A huge listing of every numismatic work published by Breen (excluding auction catalogues, those will be featured in a later work) along with comments about the contents of each. "Blunders, Hoaxes, and Lost Masterpieces from the Numismatic Literature of the Renaissance," by John Cunnally. A well-illustrated study of ancient coins which did not exist but were imagined and illustrated in 16th century numismatic works. "Some Reminiscences," by Q. David Bowers. One of the country's leading coin dealers provides us with a number of priceless anecdotes of his experiences in the world of numismatic literature. "Creating The E-Sylum, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society's Weekly Electronic Newsletter," by Wayne K. Homren. The early history of the award winning newsletter of this society. "American Numismatic Pioneers: An Index to Sources," by Pete Smith. A lengthy annotated reference to the material dealing with persons prominent in US numismatics before 1876. "Recollections of 34 Years at Spink, 1969-2003," by Douglas Saville. A great essay recalling the experiences of the leading numismatic literature dealer in Europe. (Fortunately, he does not recall the pesky American who first blundered into his office in 1986.) The issue will be heavily illustrated and over 200 pages in length and only available to those NBS members who have either joined or renewed their membership by July 1. In addition to our regular issue, we will also be producing a special limited edition hardcover copy. No more than 25 copies will be produced. The cost is $100 and payment must be received by the treasurer by July 15th. Copies cannot be reserved without full payment. David Perkins needs your cheque and you must be an NBS member to get one. The names of the subscribers to this hard cover will appear on a special page that will be bound inside. This limited edition will be distributed (I hope) at the NBS general meeting at the ANA convention in Pittsburgh on Friday August 20th. We will mail copies to those who cannot make the meeting. At the NBS general meeting we will be auctioning off the signed manuscripts of many of our contributors to the anniversary issue as well as the corrected proofs, back up CDs and other material related to the production of this important publication. Attendees will have the chance to own a piece of numismatic literary history. All proceeds will help defray our production costs. Finally, let us not forget that after the NBS meeting on Friday there will be the Great Numismatic Libraries of Pittsburgh Tour. Open only to NBS members, at a cost of $20 per person, you can have a chance to see the numismatic wonders of Wayne's and my library (not to mention my complete set of Doc Savage books). All the money concerning the above should be sent to our esteemed treasurer: W. David Perkins, PO Box 212, Mequon, WI 53092." JOHN J. FORD LIBRARY SALE NOTES Phil Carrigan writes: "George Kolbe and staff conducted a magnificent sale including the warm hospitality provided at lot viewing. I found a bounty of information looking at lots I did not intend to buy! No one I've spoken to bought as much as they intended to buy at the sale. This includes bidders present, mail bidders and particularly, me!" [The sale realized $1.66 million. A front-page article by Dan Friedus in the June 21st issue of Coin World includes a nice photo of the auction room. Some more photos are available on the Kolbe web site: Auction Photo's -Editor] Ray Williams writes: "I don't know if it's been the experience of others on this newsletter, but I find that when I generally place a mail bid on numismatic items, and I'm the successful bidder, I usually pay the maximum amount that I bid. That was not the case with the Stack's/George Kolbe Ford Library Sale! I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised when I found out that I was successful in purchasing one lot that was important to me, and I received it for $1000 less than the maximum I had bid. There's enough complaining in the hobby - I just wanted to share something positive that happened to me." REAGAN NUMISMATIC TRIBUTES SOUGHT With the death of former President Ronald Reagan, movements by his supporters to honor him with numismatic tributes are gaining momentum. On June 8th an article in the New York Times was headlined "Have You Got Two Reagans For a Twenty?" "Forget, for a moment, Ronald Reagan's place in the history books. What about his place in the nation's pocketbooks? Should he displace Franklin D. Roosevelt on the dime? How easily could Alexander Hamilton, never a president, be pushed off the $10 bill? How strongly is the Andrew Jackson lobby committed to the $20 bill? Could the John F. Kennedy constituency be coaxed to give up the half dollar? Mr. Reagan's death has set off a flurry of debate among Republicans about honoring him on the nation's currency or coins. Representative Jeff Miller of Florida introduced legislation on Tuesday to put Mr. Reagan on the 50-cent coin. But he found himself bumping up against a rival contingent that is pushing the $20 bill. The Ronald Reagan Legacy Project has spent three years studying the currency question. The clear choice is the $10 bill, the organization concluded, because Hamilton was not a president. Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the No. 2 Republican in the Senate, favors the $10 bill. But that idea is just one of many, he said, emphasizing that his view is that "some appropriate gesture of significance" should be made to commemorate Mr. Reagan. As for the Treasury Department's position, a spokeswoman, Anne Womack Kolton, said in an interview on Tuesday, "We think it's premature at this point to discuss any changes to currency." To read the full article (registration required) see: Full Article [The Times had a typo in another article in the same issue, which noted that "The nation's first state funeral paid tribute to Abraham Lincoln, the nation's 16th president, who was assassinated on April 14, 1965." U.S. bibliophiles know that date (in 1865) because the famous J.N.T. Levick sale by Edward Cogan, originally scheduled for April 27-29, 1865, was postponed due to the assassination of President Lincoln on April 14th, 1865. Lincoln was shot while attending a performance at Ford's Theatre in Washington, D.C. -Editor] REAGAN'S BIRTHPLACE: ABOVE A BANK One piece of numismatically-related Reagan trivia is the fact that he was born in an apartment above a bank in Tampico, IL. Is the name of the bank known? It would be interesting to know if the bank issued currency in 1911. REAGAN'S MEDALLIC ART COMPANY VISIT Dick Johnson writes: "The year was 1969. Medallic Art Company, then on 45th Street in midtown Manhattan, was striking the California Bicentennial Medal. The call came midweek: the governor from California was in town on business, he has a free hour tomorrow at midday. "Could he come visit your plant to see their Bicentennial Medal being struck"? "Could he"? W-e-l-l Y-e-s! We couldn't wait. My chore was to get publicity photographs taken. But by the end of the day, however, I hadn't lined up a photographer yet. My usual photographers were all busy. We were in the center of the photographic industry on the East Side of Manhattan, amid photo studios and film processing plants, but I couldn't find a last-minute photographer until an hour before the governor's intended arrival. His entourage was not that large, four men as I recall. MAco President Bill Louth did the honors in the usual VIP tour, from a start in the showroom and oval gallery to his office and the firm's collection of fine art statues. We had a small statue of a bear. The Governor walked over to that statue and caressed it. The California bear was the symbol on the state's Bicentennial Medal. Reagan passed the glass wall with all the office girls watching his every move. He smiled and waved at them. Was this the governor, the movie star, or the man? Either way he charmed the ladies. In the plant be became fascinated with the die-engraving pantograph, standing in the crowded room watching the artist's original model being engraved into a die to strike the medals. When it was over, he left. My photographer handed me the roll of film, I rushed to the processing plant the next block over. Later that day, I got the negatives and contact print. A quick order of prints, then I did something unusual. Who in California, I wondered, could use these to best advantage? Jim Miller's Coinage came to mind. And Lee Martin was my contact there. I express mailed that contact sheet to Lee. (The events that day happened so fast I forgot to eat lunch!) Lee used it immediately in an NLG Newsletter. I had intended for him to make a full page of that contact sheet. Blow it up a little to fit a 8 ½ x 11-inch page. Instead he cut up the tiny prints and ran those exact size in an issue of NLG News. [My file of those newsletters has long since disappeared. Any E-Sylum reader have a copy of that 1969 issue in their files? Drop me an email: dick.johnson at snet.net] Later, we turned the tables. Medallic Art visited Reagan! Reagan was elected president in November 1980 and Medallic Art was commissioned to make his official Inaugural Medal. Reagan chose the artist, Ed Fraughton from Utah. Fraughton wanted to model Reagan live in person at his California ranch. We had to move fast. I contacted a PR firm in NYC, Ruder & Finn [Dave Finn was very active in the sculpture world]. They hired a photographer in California. The prints of Fraughton modeling Reagan were so good I later included them in Joe Levine's book on Collecting Inaugural Medals. Reagan's memory will live on -- certainly numismatically -- not only in that book, but also for a long time in his presidential inaugural medals. But for me, Ronald Reagan will be remembered by the day he visited Medallic Art." OSCAR SCHILKE MEHL CATALOGUES SOUGHT Bob Leonard writes: "I'm still chasing pedigrees of a very few small California gold coins, and am looking for certain B. Max Mehl auction catalogs that can be identified as having belonged to Oscar G. Schilke. Mr. Schilke died May 23, 1965, and Hank Spangenberger bought his library, including "a few" auction catalogs, that year. He integrated the Schilke library with his own, and later sold most of his (Spangenberger's) B. Max Mehl catalogs to Armand Champa. Champa did a similar weeding out, so a Champa pedigree is no assurance that a Mehl catalog came from Schilke (though it is a start); they could be anywhere. Specifically, I am interested in the following Mehl sales: Beldon E. Roach, Feb. 8, 1944; A Royal Sale (Renz), March 23, 1948; and Rovensky-Hoffecker, Nov. 30, 1954. I'd like to know if any of these catalogs can somehow be tied to Schilke (name present, copy of Mehl's invoice, etc.) And I'm interested in any of these catalogs with notations or invoices indicating that the following lots were purchased or bid on: Roach lot 1255; Royal/Renz lot 3987; and Rovensky-Hoffecker lot 1940. Can any E-Sylum reader help?" THE AITNA TETRADRACHM Jan Moens of Dilbeek, Belgium writes: "The famous Aitna tetradrachme is part of the de Hirsch collection that was acquired by the Belgian Coin Cabinet in the 19th century. More information (in French) and a picture can be found at the the following web page: Picture Kerry Wetterstrom, Editor/Publisher of The Celator, writes: "The Aitna tetradrachm is "the" coin in the ancient coin collecting world. As for the claim that it's the world's most valuable coin, we will probably never know unless the Brussels cabinet decides to purge their collection, or some of the other rumored specimens finally come to light!" Daniel Kurt Ackermann of Heritage Rare Coin Galleries writes: "Proving that the internet has many treasures if you dig deeply: I believe this is an image of the Aitna Tetradrachm:Picture And another image of the obverse with an article by the Israel Museum: Picture NEWARK MUSEUM HAS COINS, SPRINGSTEEN From the June 11, 2004 Newark (NJ) Star-Ledger: "The Newark Museum hopes it will lure a new audience with the upcoming photo retrospective of Bruce Springsteen's career, since it will be the only East Coast museum hosting "Springsteen: Troubadour of the Highway." "The Newark Museum, however, is much more than a showcase for the photographic album of Bruce Springsteen's career. Founded in 1909 on the top floor of the Newark Public Library and moved to its present location on Washington Street in 1929, the museum has grown to be one of the largest publicly held art collections in the state, as well as an educational institution that reaches out to well over 150,000 students each year through special programs, lending exhibits, Junior Gallery exhibitions, the Mini Zoo, Fire Museum and the 1784 Lyons Farms Schoolhouse on the grounds." "The museum also boasts impressive collections of Asian, Pacific, African and classical art, as well as coin and currency collections and the premier collection of New Jersey decorative and industrial arts." To read the full article, see: Full Article Do we have any readers from the Garden State who can tell us about the coins and currency on display? EARLY COINS OF AMERICA REPRINTS Ray Williams writes: "I was wondering if any E-Sylum subscribers know of exactly how many different reprints of Sylvester S. Crosby's "Early Coins of America" have been printed, by whom and the dates." [I know of four reprints offhand - the 1945 Ruth Green reprint, the 1965 Token and Medal Society reprint, the 1970 Burt Franklin reprint, and the 1974 (and 1983) Quarterman reprints. There may be a Sanford Durst reprint out there somewhere, but I wouldn't clutter my library with one. Has The Colonial Newsletter reprinted Crosby in whole or in part at some point? Can any of our readers supply references to other reprints? -Editor] SINGLE-ZERO SLOTS NOT SO RARE Regarding the mention of single-zero slots in last week's item about the Nevada "Fitzgerald Hoard, Ron Haller- Williams writes: "Last I knew, most European countries would not allow the double-zero, figuring that the house should be happy with almost 2.703% (1/37 of the total staked, on average), and that 2/38 or 5.263% was too greedy. So a wheel with a single zero slot is not exactly rare this side of the pond!" WORLD COINS MAGAZINE John Isles of Hanover, MI writes: "I recently acquired some bound volumes of World Coins magazine apparently from the library of the late Herb Melnick. (Three volumes have H. I. MELNICK in gold lettering on the front cover.) They run from Vol. 2 (1965) through Vol. 13, Nos. 1-3 (January - March, 1976), but Vol. 5 is missing. I wanted to learn about the history of the magazine and discovered the following, which I thought might me of interest to our readers. The magazine World Coins was published monthly from January 1964 to March 1976. It was a successor to World Coins Bulletin, whose last issue was in March 1963, and which was purchased by Sidney Printing and Publishing Co. in Sidney, Ohio. World Coins was edited by Russell Rulau until May 1974, and then by Courtney Coffing. From April 1976 it was merged with the weekly Coin World. (This information is from an editorial in the last issue of World Coins.) Melnick's obituary appeared in Numismatic News Vol. 30, No. 30 (July 24, 1982), p. 13, and in Coin World Vol. 23, No. 1163 (July 28, 1982), p. 3 ("Death claims Herb Melnick at home")." [Would anyone care to add to our history of this publication? I have a bound set as well. And would anyone happen to know the whereabouts of the missing Melnick volumes 1 and 5? -Editor] HERB MELNICK ANECDOTES John Isles adds: "I found some interesting anecdotes about Melnick on the web. I'm not sure I'd have liked to meet him. Can anybody point me to an obituary notice? Here's an account from the PCGS web site of rather questionable proceedings at a coin auction: "I recall one instance in which a well-known specialist desired to purchase a rare early American coin, but was afraid that if others in the audience saw him bid on it, they would bid slightly more and take it away from him - knowing that he had the best idea of anyone as to what it was truly worth. No comparable specimen had appeared on the market for years. And yet he did want to bid obviously, for he would be in the audience and others would expect him to bid. "He set up this arrangement: Taking a prominent seat in the audience, he told the auctioneer that he would put his hand in the air and would be bidding up to a certain level. If the competing bidders forced him to exceed that level, then his hand would come down, but Herbert Melnick, a well-known dealer (since deceased), would be bidding on his behalf, but no one would know this. If Melnick bought the lot it was to be charged to our client's account. The coin opened at a modest figure, and my client put his hand in the air, at the same time looking around to see who else was bidding. Five or six other hands were in the air at the same time. The bidding progressed, level by level, until our client and just two or three others were bidding, when at which time the client lowered his hand. Everyone except the auctioneer thought he had dropped out. Then Herbert Melnick raised his hand, and our client, not being a shy type of person, said so that all in the audience could hear: "The price is getting ridiculous - it's not worth that!" He was endeavoring to dissuade anyone from bidding much more. However, the competition continued, and finally Melnick bought the lot for a world's record price." Full Article [You could call this arrangement with Melnick "interesting" or "creative", but I think "questionable" is too harsh a word. From time immemorial prominent bidders have sought to avoid showing all their cards at public auction for just the reasons stated. The bidder's theatrics were designed to distract the audience; although it may be seen as tacky, rude, childish or even pathetic by others, it's perfectly legal, and the special arrangements with Melnick and the auctioneer are not unusual - deep-pocketed clients can command such special treatment. What other auction tales can E-Sylum readers share with us? Is it true that once there was a bidder who took the opposite tack, taping his bidder paddle to the back wall of the auction room and walking out? Apparently the idea was to discourage anyone from even THINKING of outbidding him on the lot. -Editor] The next Melnick anecdote is found in an interview with John J. Ford, Jr. on the Heritage was site: "LEGACY: You were also privy to some of the goings-on at NASCA [Numismatic and Antiquarian Service Corporation of America] in the early years with Herb Melnick. FORD: I guess the play was named "Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter?" Well, in this case, "Success Spoiled Herb Melnick." Melnick changed from a fellow you could talk to, to someone who became increasingly aggressive, increasingly hostile. Even to the people who were trying to help him, he became hostile. Talk about arguments between me and Wormser, those were patty-cake sessions compared to the arguments between Melnick and Ball. Douglas Ball is a mild-mannered, good- hearted, give-you-the-shirt-off-his-back type, and Melnick was the type that would go for your throat. When Herb still worked for Stanley Apfelbaum, I suggested to Doug Ball that he go in business with Melnick. I said, "He is a wolf, but he will protect you from the other wolves:" or something to that effect. But Melnick got out of hand. He became enamored with his own success. When their business hit ten million a year, he started to think he could walk on water. He started to take auction consignments with free buybacks and 90 percent advances. In a declining market or on material you don't know anything about, that can be very dangerous. He insisted on making all the decisions, and he started to run the company into the ground. In the process, he alienated me by telling me I didn't know what the hell I was talking about. And he started to alienate Ball. One day, Ball just got fed up, changed the locks on the doors, and threw Melnick out. It was Ball's father's money that kept the whole thing going. Then Melnick went into business for himself, and, as you know, it lasted about a year and a half before he died at the age of 39-which is rather young to die of a heart attack. I think that means he had a rather vociferous personality. But he was a guy with a lot of talent. If it had been channeled in the right direction, he could have been a very successful fellow." Full Article AMERICAN MEDALLIC SCULPTURE EXHIBIT Tom Sheehan forwarded the following press release regarding a new exhibit by the American Medallic Sculpture Association: "32 members of the American Medallic Sculpture Association, AMSA, will have their medals on display at the Nordic Heritage Museum in Seattle from June 18th to August 1st, 2004. 80 medals from all over the USA as well as Ireland, Canada, Israel, Australia and also medals by an invited artist from the Norwegian Mint are assembled at the Nordic Heritage Museum for this exhibit. This exhibit was made possible by the efforts of Anne-Lise Deering, AMSA secretary and newsletter editor. Ms. Deering has a special connection with the Nordic community as a native Norwegian and a member of the Nordic Heritage Museum. The purpose of the American Medallic Sculpture Association, AMSA is to encourage the creation and study of medallic sculpture in North America. All who are interested are welcome as members. By having exhibitions like this we hope to share this wonderful art form with everyone. The medals in this exhibit were chosen by AMSA artists members: Jim Licaretz, Eugene Daub, Heidi Wastweet, Anne-Lise Deering and Woodinville sculptor, Lisa Sheets. There will be a preview reception on June 17th and the exhibit will be open to the public until August 1. The Museum is located at 3014 NW 67th Street, Seattle and is open: 10 am to 4 pm Tues - Sat and 12 noon to 4 pm Sun. Check their website: "Nordic Heritage Museum". In addition to the Nordic Heritage Museum exhibit Ms. Deering continues to display AMSA members' medals at libraries throughout the greater Seattle area. At the moment there is a display in the Bothell library until June 15th and then to the Anderson library in Edmonds in July before it goes to the Redmond library in August. For more information about AMSA visit our website "AMSA" or contact AMSA secretary Anne-Lise Deering, e-mail: AMSAnews at aol.com or call 206-542-0608" UNCUT SHEET PRANKS Hal V. Dunn writes: "I don't know any stories of collectors cutting notes out of sheets to amuse themselves at the expense of shocked waiters and shopkeepers. However, there are stories about Walter Scott, the legendary Death Valley Scotty, cutting notes from uncut sheets. One account, documented in Death Valley Scotty Told Me, by Eleanor Jordan Houston, the wife of a National Park Service Ranger stationed at Death Valley during the late 1940s, centers on a trip Scotty made many years before by train from Barstow, California to Los Angeles. He had $4,800 in uncut sheets. He purchased two bottles of wine, borrowed a pair of manicure scissors from a young lady and cut a bill off. He told the couple he was with that the notes were counterfeit, but so good it was easy to pass them. He even offered to sell the roll of bills for $4,000. The husband of the young lady got off the train briefly at San Bernardino and notified the police. In Los Angeles Treasury agents were waiting when the train arrived. Frank J. Belcher, Jr., the assistant cashier for the Los Angeles bank was called in to settle the problem - Scotty indeed had received uncut sheets from the bank. (pp. 36-39, appendix note #2; original copyright 1954, copyright 1985 by the Death Valley Natural History Association). As I recall there is another published reference to Death Valley Scotty cutting notes from sheets. However, I am unable to locate it at the moment. That story involved sheets from a national bank in Nevada. He cut them off in front of numerous persons in Tonopah, Goldfield, or Rhyolite, Nevada, communities he frequented regularly." Tom DeLorey writes: "At the 1983 ANA convention in San Diego, I went out to dinner with then-fellow ANA employee Nancy Green and her husband Ron and their infant son, Andrew. Before we left the bourse area, I bought a four-subject sheet of deuces from the BEP booth, rolled it up and stuck it in my jacket. As we left, I handed Nancy a pair of scissors and told her to stick them in her purse. Dinner came to just under $40, and by prior arrangement I took the check and gave the waiter a $50. He naturally came back with ten singles so that he could get most of them back as his tip, but I just stuffed them into another jacket pocket and casually asked Nancy for the scissors. She did so with an absolutely straight face, and I took out the sheet of four deuces, carefully cut off one, and handed the waiter the conjoined "$6 bill." As we calmly gathered up our belongings and the baby, the guy just stood there holding it out with a stunned look on his face. As we started to head towards the door, he finally said "Do you print your own?", to which I smiled and said "Doesn't everybody?" Ed Snible writes: "My favorite uncut sheet story comes from Steve Wozniak (inventor and founder of Apple Computer): "I take the sheets of 4 bills and have a printer, located through friends, gum them into pads, like stationery pads. The printer then perforates them between the bills, so that I can tear a bill or two away. The bills that I'd tipped the waitress came from such a pad." Story Myron Xenos writes; "Of some humorous interest might be a case where a client of mine turned an uncut sheet of one-dollar notes sideways, and then cut the paper into some very odd-looking pieces of currency. It surprised me at first until I realized what he had done. A good bar trick for numismatists who like to fool their drinking buddies & probably good for a few drinks. But then I would get the heck out before they caught on." FEATURED WEB PAGE This week's featured web page is from the Russ Logan collection site. It pictures an 1829 U.S. Bust Half Dollar with a "Houck's Panacea Baltimore" counterstamp. "According to Gregory Brunk in American and Canadian Countermarked Coins, Jacob Houck operated his business at the corner of German and Hanover streets in Baltimore, and advertised in the 1842 Matchett's Baltimore City Directory. His product, Houck's Panacea, was prepared from vegetable matter and cured a variety of ailments." FEATURED WEB PAGE Wayne Homren Numismatic Bibliomania Society Content presented in The E-Sylum is not necessarily researched or independently fact-checked, and views expressed do not necessarily represent those of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society. The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. For more information please see our web site at http://www.coinbooks.org/ There is a membership application available on the web site. To join, print the application and return it with your check to the address printed on the application. Visit the Membership page. Those wishing to become new E-Sylum subscribers (or wishing to Unsubscribe) can go to the following web page link. |
|