|
Welcome to The E-Sylum: Volume 11, Number 12, March 23, 2008: an electronic publication of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society. Copyright (c) 2008, The Numismatic Bibliomania Society. WAYNE'S WORDS: THE E-SYLUM MARCH 23, 2008 Among our recent subscribers is Richard Burdick, courtesy of Alan Weinberg. Welcome aboard! We now have 1,134 subscribers. This week we open with information on several Whitman Publishing products, including new features appearing in the next edition of the classic Redbook, and a report on upcoming books on tokens and medals, U.S. gold, American coinage and ancient coins. Next, Ray Williams reports on the recent sale of duplicate books at the ANS. Several items provide follow-ups to earlier discussions, including courtesy signatures, deaccessioning of coins from the Garrett collection at Johns Hopkins, and the filming of 'Public Enemies' at banks around the country. My numismatic diary this week covers a brief visit to Brookgreen Gardens and other semi-numismatic sights. In the news, Queen Elizabeth distributes Maundy Coinage in a venue passed over for 700 years, a rare 1878 London medal turns up in a New Zealand backyard, and a Czech bank note designer's artwork is displayed in New York. To learn who the Devil leads into hell on a medal, read on. Have a great week, everyone. Wayne Homren Numismatic Bibliomania Society NEW EDITION: A GUIDE BOOK OF U.S COINS, 62ND EDITION (2009) [Dennis Tucker forwarded the press release for the newest edition of the classic Red Book, "A Guide Book of United States Coins" by R.S. Yeoman and edited by Kenneth Bressett. Whitman Publishing is accepting preorders for the book. Here are some excerpts from the press release highlighting some new and recently added features. -Editor] For the 62nd edition, more than 130 professional coin dealers, scholars, and other numismatic experts contributed their knowledge under the direction of editor Kenneth Bressett, valuations editor Jeff Garrett, and research editor Q. David Bowers. The 62nd edition includes 16 more pages than last year’s, with no increase in retail price. New sections cover Puerto Rican coins, American Arts gold medals, California souvenir fractional gold pieces, the 2009 Lincoln cent redesign, the upcoming Native American dollars, and the Blue Book as a collectible. The book also features expanded coverage of pre-federal / colonial coins, California gold, Hawaiian plantation tokens, Special Mint Sets, pattern coins, and the Libertas Americana medal. In addition to nearly 30,000 individual coin prices in up to nine grades per series, the 62nd-edition Red Book showcases the Top 250 Auction Prices for U.S. coins. "We’ve tracked auctions up through the March 2008 Baltimore Coin and Currency Convention," said Whitman publisher Dennis Tucker. He noted an increase of $34,000 compared to the 61st-edition list. "Last year’s 250-ranked coin sold for $276,000," Tucker said. "To make it onto this year’s list, the 250-ranked coin, an 1873-CC No Arrows quarter, sold for $310,000." Continuing a popular format introduced last year, the Red Book is available in a spiralbound hardcover format. "Sitting on your bookshelf, it’s an attractive and durable hardcover Red Book," said Whitman president Mary Counts. "With the hidden- spiral binding, you can lay the open book flat while you study your collection." Traditional hardcover and spiralbound books are also available, and a leather-bound Limited Edition (3,000 copies) will be available later in the spring. The 62nd edition of the Red Book will debut April 8, 2008. It will be available online and at bookstores and hobby shops nationwide. In addition to the regular edition, Whitman Publishing is also taking pre-orders for the leather-bound Limited Edition of this year’s Red Book, to be released later in the spring. $14.95 spiralbound $16.95 hardcover $19.95 spiralbound hardcover $69.95 leather-bound Limited Edition [For more information, see the Whitman web site. Below is a link to the page for the spiralbound hardcover version, a new feature introduced last year. -Editor] Red Book 62nd Edition NEW ZEALAND ERROR SPOTTED IN 'MODERN WORLD COINS' 14TH EDITION Martin Purdy of New Zealand writes: "I've just spotted an error in Appendix C to the 14th edition of the Yeoman/Friedberg catalogue of Modern World Coins ("Mints, Central Banks and Agencies"). "Under New Zealand they have listed the 'New Zealand Mint' which, as has previously been discussed on the E-Sylum, is a private entity and not this country's national mint, although one could easily be misled by the name. The correct issuing authority for current New Zealand collector issues is: New Zealand Post Collectables and Solutions Centre Private Bag 3001 Wanganui 4540 "I hope they are able to correct this for the 15th edition." [I forwarded Martin's note to Dennis Tucker of Whitman Publishing, who writes: "Thanks to Martin Purdy for catching the wrong listing of the 'New Zealand Mint' in the appendix of MWC. This will be corrected in the 15th edition." -Editor] REVIEW: 'A CATALOG OF MODERN WORLD COINS, 1850–1964', 14TH EDITION esylum_v11n07a07.html NEW ZEALAND MINT A PRIVATE COMPANY esylum_v09n19a17.html PREVIEW OF UPCOMING WHITMAN NUMISMATIC BOOKS Dennis Tucker of Whitman Publishing writes: "Here's a quick update on some of the books we're currently working on: "Katherine Jaeger's Guide Book of United States Tokens and Medals is in the final stages of production and scheduled to go to press in a couple weeks. This book has been a lot of fun to work on. Its scope is amazing --- Jaeger has pulled together resources on exonumic Americana spanning four centuries: colonial tokens, die-struck merchant good-fors, art medals, presidential commemoratives, Civil War tokens, fair and exposition souvenirs, space-flown medals, transportation tokens, prison chits, arras tokens, etc., etc.! (If ever a numismatic book deserved TWO et ceteras, it's this one.) She also covers engraved, tooled, and otherwise altered coins (hobo nickels, love tokens, capped coins, and others). Most of the book's photographs, numbering in the thousands, came from a special arrangement with the American Numismatic Society. It will debut later this spring. 304 pages, 6 x 9, full color, softcover; foreword by Q. David Bowers; valuations editors Steven Tanenbaum and Steve Hayden, with assistance from Anthony Terranova, Paul Cunningham, and others. [So what are "Arras Tokens"? That's a term I'm wholly unfamiliar with. Can someone fill us in? -Editor] "The second edition of the Encyclopedia of U.S. Gold Coins, 1795-1933 (by Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth), produced in conjunction with the Smithsonian Institution, will be out in about ten weeks. The second edition is being updated with recent auction results, new third-party grading population reports, valuations, and recent research. The first edition won the 2006 'Best Specialized Book, U.S. Coins' award from the Numismatic Literary Guild, and has been a best-seller. With gold making headlines in the mainstream press, and gold coins seeing strong market activity, I anticipate the new edition will be another popular hit. "Another volume on U.S. gold coinage is Q. David Bowers' Guide Book of United States Gold Dollars, the latest in the Bowers Series. Readers can expect a hearty dish of everything they love about Dave's writing: colorful history, carefully researched data, and a detailed date-by-date study of every coin in the series. 304 pages, 6 x 9, full color, softcover; foreword by David Akers; valuations editors Larry Stack. "We're working on an updated second edition of Dr. Richard Doty's America's Money, America's Story. Doty explores the USA's national identity as seen through the coins, tokens, paper, and other money we've developed and used through the centuries, going back to colonial times. This is a grand book --- the perfect volume for everyone who wonders, "Is there a book that covers the whole scope of American money?" Many of the illustrations come from the Smithsonian's National Numismatic Collection (where Doty is curator). "Most E-Sylum readers are familiar with Doty's work, and know of his expertise in Latin American and world history, in addition to that of the United States. That expertise guarantees his readers a solid education in our money's connections to Spanish America, Europe, and other regions outside our boundaries. Our money didn't magically start in 1792 with a little half disme! This has been another wonderful book to work on. It will come out in advance of the Smithsonian's unveiling of the newly restored Fort McHenry "Stars and Stripes" this summer. 256 pages, 8.5 x 11, full color; hardcover; foreword by Q. David Bowers. "This is just a quick sampling of some of the books we have scheduled for a busy spring and summer season. "In other news, I just received in our Atlanta office an advance copy of Harlan J. Berk's 100 Greatest Ancient Coins. It's always a pleasure to finally get the finished book in hand, after months of manuscript development, editorial work, image gathering, layout design, typesetting, proofing, etc. It's a double pleasure when the book is as beautiful as this one---another fine addition to the "100 Greatest" library. (This advance copy is one of about a dozen currently in our possession; the rest are sales samples and one reserved for author Berk. The main shipment from the printer will be rriving shortly, and the book will be on shelves nationwide next month.)" [Many thanks to Dennis for the preview of books in the Whitman pipeline. Wow! So many books, so little time. But keep 'em coming! -Editor] ANS DUPLICATE LITERATURE SALE REPORT Last week we published some photos taken by Mike Paradis in New York at the American Numismatic Society's duplicate literature sale. Ray Williams writes: "I had the pleasure of attending the Groves Forum at the ANS last week. These have always been educational and fun events - this one was also! Making the trek to NYC by train, I decided to go in early and check out what books the ANS was offering in their Book Sale. I'm sure that many bargains were had on the previous Saturday, but there was much still available on Wednesday. "I needed to be selective about how much I bought - everything would need to be carried to the PATH Train to accompany me home. Looking through the shelves, I was kicking myself for not driving my car! Here's what I purchased: "Krause Standard Catalog of World Coins 1701-1800 ($5), Krause Standard Catalog of World Coins for a 7 year old friend ($5), Circulating Counterfeits of the Americas (1998 COAC)($10), Copper Coinage of the State of NJ (Trudgen) ($10), AJN vol 13, 14 & 15 ($5 each), ANS Museum Notes 33 (5 copies) and 1, ($5 each). There were stacks of postcards and I spotted an attractive card with a Noe 1 Pine Tree on it. These were free, but I made a donation because I took about 30, which I plan to use. "The main room on the first floor had book shelves around the perimeter, all categorized by topic, country or time period. On the floor were stacks by year of the numismatist and other periodicals. At the time I was shopping, there was a young man handling sales who was fascinating to talk to... although he is not a numismatist, he is an underwater archeologist - a profession that seems exciting and adventurous. "A friend asked me why I still add to my library - there are so many books I have already and I won't read them all... I replied that although I surely won't read them all, it's comforting to know they are there to refer to at a moment's notice." ANS DUPLICATE LITERATURE SALE PHOTOS Full Story NUMISMATIC BIBLIOPHILES AND THE REDISCOVERY OF NUMISMATIC TREASURES Roger Siboni writes: "It was a busy week and I am a little late in getting through last week's E-Sylum which I am now doing with a leisurely cup of coffee. But I enjoyed reading the follow-up on the Washington Born Virginia piece from Alan Weinberg's previous post about the Baltimore Show. It struck me in reading the description how much fun it is to be a bibliophile as you can watch certain numismatic treasures be discovered and re-discovered again and again over time. When the same item is received with the same amazement and awe over decades and sometimes centuries, you really do appreciate what a special treasure it is. "So while I am not sure that the catalogers of the October 24, 1984 Stack's Picker sale (which contained many of the pieces that George Fuld talked about in the previous week's issue of the E-Sylum regarding Picker's private acquisition from Johns Hopkins University) viewed the piece as a special presentation proof, they did choose to feature it on the cover of the catalog along with a New Jersey Copper Date Under Plow Beam, a Higley Copper, a New England Shilling, and an extremely scarce Continental Dollar....august company. It was further described in the catalog as a coin with out equal, needle- sharp strike, flawless surfaces and the most important Washington piece in the sale. It was previously owned by Newcomer and Green. "Anyway, one of the great enjoyments of having a library is to see how particular coins stand the test of time. This one did quite well." WASHINGTON BORN VIRGINIA 'MAGNIFI-CENT' VIEWED AT BALTIMORE SHOW esylum_v11n11a19.html ALAN WEINBERG ON ULTRA-RARITIES SPOTTED AT THE BALTIMORE SHOW esylum_v11n10a11.html MORE ON THE DEACCESSIONING OF COINS FROM THE GARRETT COLLECTION Alan V. Weinberg writes: "George Fuld's account of Dick Picker's Garrett/Johns Hopkins University private acquisitions at "Redbook price" (Gad!) was fascinating - certainly the first time this has been in print. It goes to show how one person's story in print can trigger the memory of another who, in turn, can write an absolutely entrancing account. "It is my understanding that significant early large cents - mostly 1794's - were also acquired privately by Dick Picker out of Garrett/JHU on behalf of another serious early copper collector. "I may well have ended up with a few Garrett/JHU colonials in the early 70's via Dick Picker. In one instance, I recall distinctly that I had a superb Maris 73aa overstruck New Jersey cent that Dick wanted badly for his collection. I told him I wanted a superb Massachusetts Pine Tree shilling in partial trade. Dick promptly mailed me a Gem Uncirculated shilling. But the Noe 8 shilling was slightly irregular on the rim and I returned it. 'I want something better'. Right back in the mail came a superb Uncirculated Noe 6 Pine Tree shilling, full planchet. Yup, this'll do - you bet! "At the time I wondered where in the world was Dick getting such magnificent shillings? Later I guessed the source and now I know. The Maris 73aa Jersey overstrike appeared in Picker's collection auctioned by Stack's in 1984. I still have the Pine Tree shilling." [The E-Sylum is like a weekly cocktail party of some of the greatest numismatic researchers and collectors in the world. One overheard mention (such as Alan's original question about the Garrett collection) often triggers some wonderful accounts from others. This exchange is a fine example. Although I'd like to think that by now I have a sixth sense about what topics will generate a response, I'm right at best only half the time. Some topics I think would be sure-fire turn out to be duds, and other thoughts mentioned almost in passing turn out to yield fascinating follow-up discussions. But that's all part of the fun of numismatics. So, at the risk of firing another dud I'd like to ask if anyone can fill us in on other early deacquisitions from the famed Garrett collection. Do any of our readers have or know of 1794 cents or other Federal coins coming from the Garrett collection through Richard Picker or other dealers prior to the landmark Bowers sales? -Editor] THE FIRST DEACCESSIONING OF COINS FROM THE GARRETT COLLECTION esylum_v11n10a08.html MORE ON FEDERAL RESERVE NOTES AUTOGRAPHED BY SIGNERS Jeff Kelley writes: "George Cuhaj provided an excellent explanation of autopen signatures as they might appear on notes sent to the Secretary of the Treasury or the Treasurer for autographing. His assessment of the likelihood of a signature’s authenticity was as follows: "My general thoughts are that if you have a Secretary of the Treasury signature, and it was not signed in person, then it is very probably autopen. If you have a Treasurer of the U.S. and it was not signed in person, it could be either." "I would agree with his assessment, but only as it relates to sitting Treasury officials. If collectors are writing to former officials, the chances of getting a genuine signature increase dramatically. While a few business leaders employ the autopen, it is very likely that if a note comes back in the mail signed by a former Treasury official it would be a genuine signature." MORE ON FEDERAL RESERVE NOTES AUTOGRAPHED BY SIGNERS esylum_v11n11a13.html MORE ON 'PUBLIC ENEMIES' FILMING [Last week Jeff Reichenberger mentioned the new movie "Public Enemies" which is currently filming at a number of locations around the country. The old First National Bank building in Jeff's town of Oshkosh, WI will be one of those locations. David Kranz of Numismatic News discussed the film in his blog Tuesday. Here are some excerpts. -Editor] Big news in Wisconsin, home to the Bank Note Reporter offices, is that the film Public Enemies is currently shooting at locations all around the state. The film is about John Dillinger, Pretty Boy Floyd, Baby Face Nelson and others who were part of the crime wave of 1933-1934. The film is based on the book by Bryan Burrough titled Public Enemies: America's Greatest Crime Wave and the Birth of the FBI, 1933-34. Tomorrow filming reportedly continues in my old hometown of Darlington, Wis. How is this numismatic? Well, I've been known to acquire a National Bank Note or two from Darlington... And, like many National Bank Note collectors, I've always hoped Mark Hotz would swing through the town on one of his national bank tours for his Bank Note Reporter columns. I may have to revamp my 1999 article on Darlington NBNs for use when the film comes out. Maybe I see the root of a neat exhibit here: Nationals from the towns where the film was shot. To read the complete article, see: Full Story [Dave also asked about prop money. There's certain to be a need for stage money in filming; hopefully what the producers come up with will closely resemble the circulating cash of the day. Mark Hotz has been writing a long-running series of articles in Bank Note Reporter featuring pictures and stories of national Banks around the country. I hope someone compiles them into a book someday. -Editor] MORE COIN-INSPIRED DECORATIONS IN ARCHITECTURE Last week Jeff Reichenberger told us about a bank building in Oshkosh, WI which has interesting bas-relief medallions depicting the obverse and reverse of the Standing Liberty Quarter and Walking Liberty Half Dollar. Dave Lange writes: "When my family visited the Crayola Factory in Easton, PA a few years ago I spotted a bank building with a bas relief Standing Liberty Quarter above the entryway. I believe it was a 1917 Type 1, but I didn't have a camera with me to record it, so that may be in error." [I was able to document two examples of such numismatic decorative elements on Pittsburgh, PA bank buildings. I'm aware of similar decorations on the former B. Max Mehl building in Ft. Worth, TX, and recall a circa 1930 pamphlet somewhere in my ephemera files about the Chase Architrave, the entrance to the Chase Manhattan Bank building in New York. If memory serves, this was written by Stewart Mosher. Can anyone confirm this? Can any of our New York readers confirm that the building exists (or better yet, provide photos? -Editor] QUERY: INFORMATION ON HOGGSON BROTHERS AND BANK ARCHITECTURE esylum_v11n11a17.html MARCH 2008 STACK'S COIN GALLERIES SALE [The March 2008 Stack's Coin Galleries sale catalog features a number of interesting items - here are a few. The sale includes the Naval Historical Foundation Collection of Admiral Vernon medals from the collection of cataloguer Leander McCormick-Goodheart (Stack's Numismatic Review, 1945) as well as a great collection of U.S. inaugural medals. -Editor] LOT 4598: ADMIRAL VERNON MEDAL, DEVIL LEADS SIR ROBERT WALPOLE INTO HELL Admiral Vernon Medal. McCormick-Goodhart 18. Vernon, Brown, Devil and Sir Robert Medal, n.d. 37.5mm. About Uncirculated. Obv. Crown above standing figures of Admiral Vernon and Commodore Brown clasping hands. Rev. Devil leads Sir Robert Walpole into hell, NO EXCISE. Splendid strike, wealth of bold detail. To view the lot description, see: Lot Descriptions LOT 4789: HK 835. BICKFORD DOLLAR, 18. THIS COMBINATION COIN WILL WHEN ADOPTED BW GOOD IN ALL NATIONS / HEAL ALL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN GOLD & SILVER MEN / AND FULLY SETTLE ALL FINANCIAL QUESTIONS / APPROVED BY ALL GOOD BUSINESS MEN; beaded border. Rv. Same center inscription; between outer circle and beaded border HERE IS SHOWN THE VALUE OF OUR DOLLAR IN THE COIN OF DIFFERENT NATIONS OF THE WORLD; between outer and inner circles, eight links contain Sterling 4.2 Francs 5.2 Kronen 3.8 Gulden 2.8 Marken 4.16 Guilder 2.5 Rouble 9.65 Yen 1.1; between inner circle and center, INVENTED AND PROTECTED BY DANA BICKFORD. Very rare. Very Fine. To view the lot description, see: View Lots LOT 4798: MEDALLIC HISTORY OF KING LOUIS XIV Académie Royale des Médailles et des Inscriptions. Médailles sur les Principaux Evénements do Regne de Louis le Grand avec des Explications Historiques. Paris, Imprimerie Royale, 1702. Octavo, 292 numbered pages. Very Fine. Each medal in the Histoire metallique receives a page to itself, topped by an engraving of each reverse, the opposite side being blank. This is a sumptuous presentation of the great medallic history of "Sun King" Louis XIV, whose meticulously organized Academy assured a remarkable uniformity of classically oriented designs. Octavo, 11¼ x8¼ inches. Spine and cover are elaborately gold-stamped with traces of book plate removal on the inside cover, a few calligraphic notes in minute script appear on several pages from an unknown early owner. To view the lot description, see: Lot Descriptions WAYNE'S NUMISMATIC DIARY MARCH 23, 2008 This week I was on vacation with my family - we drove over 1,000 miles, visiting Wilmington, NC, Myrtle Beach and Charleston SC and points in between. Our overnight in Wilmington was memorable. We had decided to wing our first night (last Saturday) without making reservations in advance. We ended up having dinner near Wilmington and stopped at three nearby hotels looking for rooms. We settled on a place and checked in just as a near-tornado-force rainstorm rolled through. I don't think I've ever seen so much rain coming down so hard. We kept our children away from the windows until it passed. Luckily, there was no major damage or flooding nearby, but I'm sure glad we weren't still out on the road. Later I fired up my laptop computer and we viewed photos of tornado damage the day before in Atlanta. No numismatic activity to report from this trip, however. The closest was when our horse-drawn carriage tour driver in Charleston pointed out three firemarks on homes we passed. I remembered first learning about firemarks from a presentation given by Armor Murdoch at the Western Pennsylvania Numismatic Society when I was a new member in the late 1980s. Firemarks are plaques placed on the outside of buildings to designate that fire insurance had been purchased from a local fire brigade. They typically have the insignia or initials of the fire company. I have some books in my library on these, but I've never collected them. Armor passed around his copy of Footprints of Assurance, one of the best works on firemarks. Do any of our readers collect or research firemarks? Another near-miss numismatically took place Monday morning. We drove 15 miles south from Myrtle Beach to Brookgreen Gardens, a place we've discussed before in The E-Sylum. Created by Archer Huntington and his wife, Brookgreen is a sculpture garden showcasing magnificent works by America's top sculptors, including many who also designed coins. But after visiting the welcome center my wife decided that the kids weren't going to like it. Our oldest (9-year-old Christopher) wanted to stay. My wife offered (or was it threatened?) to leave the two of us there for the day, but wishing to keep the family intact I gave in. It was embarrassing, but I had to ask if they'd let us have our money back and leave. A supervisor came out to talk with us. He was quite gracious. He spoke with my wife but she still wanted to leave. So we got our money and left. The Most Tranquil Place on Earth was no match for my wife and kids. The phrase "pearls before swine" came to mind, but to keep peace I bit my tongue. In the end we had a fine day of family fun together even though the finest piece of sculpture we saw was the T-Rex in the Jurassic Golf miniature golf course. In my mind I quoted The Terminator: "I'll be back". Someday, I hope to get the chance. While I was gone a package arrived from Stack's. It contained the final three hardbound volumes of the John J. Ford sale catalogs. It's a real treat to finally have the complete 21-volume hardbound set on my shelves. I'm still disappointed that Ford's unaccounted-for Nova Constellatio silver pattern set wasn't documented in the sales (If anyone knows where it is, they aren’t talking, at least not to me). Still, it's a magnificent set that I'll refer to often. As I've said before, an American numismatic library is incomplete without a set of these landmark sales. Does anyone know approximately how many of each were bound by Stack's? Were the same number of each hardbound? How many complete sets are out there now? Over the holiday weekend my wife's sister's family visited us from Pittsburgh. Yesterday we went to the Smithsonian's National Air and Space Museum center near Dulles Airport. Only minutes from our home, I hadn't been there yet. I had been looking forward to visiting there ever since seeing the Imperial War Museum at the former Duxford air field near Cambridge while on assignment in London last year. Ensconced at the center are an Air France Concorde and the Space Shuttle Enterprise. What really stopped me in my tracks though, was the Enola Gay, the B-29 bomber which dropped the atomic bomb that destroyed Hiroshima. Numismatically, I noted several displays of medals, including groups of Apollo-11 medals and Soviet/Russian space medals. These exhibits were not well lighted, however, and unfortunately I didn't have time to linger and review the display text. Another case displaying a pilot uniform also showcased a set of four medals, but there was no accompanying text to explain what the medals were. Although medals were decidedly second and third-class citizens in this museum, I was nevertheless pleased to see them there and in the public eye. The museum also featured a couple of elongated cent machines. It cost a dollar (four quarters) plus a cent to make a "squished penny" with one of several available designs. Not having enough pocket change between us, our kids had to go without. Installing a change machine nearby would probably lead to a tripling of elongated cent sales. WORKS BY NUMISMATIC SCULPTORS AT BROOKGREEN GARDENS esylum_v09n17a21.html JOHNSON: PLAN TO VISIT BROOKGREEN GARDENS FOUR TIMES esylum_v09n18a13.html WAYNE'S LONDON DIARY 1-2 SEPTEMBER, 2007 esylum_v10n35a14.html COUNTERPOINT: STEEL CENTS COULD WORK Jeff Kelley writes: "I must respectfully disagree with some aspects of Dick Johnson’s latest commentary about eliminating the cent. He asserted that the introduction of steel cents would drive all existing copper and zinc cents out of circulation (and into Chinese melting pots) and that the Treasury would then have to replace the 100 billion cents that he estimates are currently in circulation. "While I agree with that it is possible that the Chinese or another rapidly industrializing nation (perhaps India) might be inclined to melt down our cents for their metal content, there are a few things to think about. First, replacing copper cents with zinc cents did not lead to a wholesale smelting of the older copper cents – they both circulated side by side quite seamlessly despite the fact that the copper cents were worth more than one cent and more than their zinc successor. Second, the current prohibition on melting one cent coins includes a prohibition against a person exporting more than a certain amount of cents (and the limits are quite low – somewhere in the hundreds, if I recall correctly.). Lastly, if all one cent coins disappeared tomorrow, the Mint would not have to replace all those currently "in circulation" simply because most do not actually circulate. The vast majority of cents sit in jars, cups, trays, piggy banks, etc. For many people, cents are essentially a single use coin – they are issued as change at the store, and it may be years before they re-enter the retail or banking system. "As for suggestions that rounding odd amounts at the register would make the cent obsolete, we don’t need legislation to implement that process. If people want, they can ask cashiers right now to round up their bill to the nearest nickel and say "keep the change", or they can simply refuse to take the odd pennies in change. "As to the advisability of eliminating the cent, I am not so sure the theory that makes it appear innocuous would become reality for the consumer. Eliminating the cent would require that some rounding be done, and I have some first hand experience with that. I was living in Germany when the euro replaced the mark, if there was any rounding to be done (and there always was), the price was ALWAYS rounded upward. I had friends who actually bought into the idea that it would somehow all even out for the consumer, that some prices would be rounded up and some down, but that was predictably not what happened. It was foolish, after all, to expect that the butcher would round his prices down in order to compensate for the fact that the baker next door rounded his prices up. I experienced exactly one instance where the Euro price reflected an amount that was lower than the equivalent of the former price in marks; that was a newspaper that had raised its price in the months before the conversion so that it could round down afterward. "There is one important thing to think about when comparing the United States to other countries, and that regards pricing methodology. While retailers in many other countries may make use of certain familiar price points (.99, 1.99, etc.), it is probably not as prevalent as it is in the US. There is also the critical issue of taxation – many other countries impost a "VAT" (Value Added Tax) which is included in the stated price of an item, not a sales tax that is added at the register on top of the total. Therefore, most items are priced such that the price is a round number of some kind. Retailers and restaurants in many foreign countries have done this for years as a way to simplify the payment process and reduce the need for handling minor coins. This approach would be problematic, however, in any US jurisdiction that imposes a sales tax at the register. "Whether or not the cent has outlived its usefulness is certainly a subject for serious debate, but it is important to consider all of the ramifications to eliminating it." Jeff adds: "There is one reason I can think of why replacing copper and zinc cents with steel cents would create havoc: the problem of expanding the tolerances for accepting cents and other coins in stamp vending machines at the Post office and coin counting machines at banks. Currently, these devices can be set to automatically reject any coin that has the magnetic properties of steel (at my bank, Canadian quarters don’t even make it down into the counting mechanism area – they stick to the magnets built into the coin tray). Once we introduce steel into our coinage, it will dramatically complicate the automated validation process for coins. (Of course, at current exchange rates, Canadian coins don’t represent a loss!)." Martin Purdy of New Zealand writes: "I've heard of lots of countries that have abolished their lowest denomination but never any that have actually revalued their one-cent coins to circulate as fives - if any country has, I'd love to have the details since it would make a great quiz question. "It certainly didn't happen here or in Australia, which simply set a deadline beyond which 1c and 2c coins would no longer be accepted in trade or given out as change. The same was done with our 5c coins in 2006 - they were simply called in, not revalued. "Velde's notion of revaluing all existing 1-cent coins to 5 cents sounds crazy - does he really want $1 billion (or thereabouts) worth of "pennies" suddenly given a face value of $5 billion by fiat?" [Dick wrote that Australia and New Zealand had eliminated their lowest denominations, but did not mention any country which had actually rebased their low denomination coins. There are many examples in history where countries have rebased circulating coins, usually by counterstamping them with a higher value. -Editor] DICK JOHNSON: STEEL CENTS WON'T WORK! esylum_v11n11a20.html QUEEN ELIZABETH DISTRIBUTES MAUNDY COINS IN IRELAND Dick Johnson writes: "For the first time in 700 years Maundy coins were distributed in Ireland instead of England or Wales. Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth handed out 82 pence in special 1p, 2p, 3p and 4p sterling silver coins – a penny for each year of her life – to 164 pensioners from across the Province. [Thanks to Dick for pointing out this interesting fact. Maundy coins are an interesting topic. I have a 1910 Maundy set that once belonged to my step-grandfather. Below are excerpts from the news article Dick forwarded. It's worth reading for its interesting detail of the pagenantry of the event, as well as photos taken at the ceremony. -Editor] The leaders of the four main Churches joined together in St Patrick's Church of Ireland Cathedral in Armagh for the event - the first time it has been held outside England and Wales in 700 years. Her gifts, in red and white purses with ribbons, were carried on a silver platter by the Queen's yeomen, who bore ceremonial swords and wore red uniforms, hats with ribbons and traditional oversized white collars. Pensioners who were being recognised for community work were selected to be handed the specially minted Maundy money during a cross-community service in St Patrick's Cathedral in Armagh. The term "Maundy" comes from the Latin word mandatum, which means commandment, and is derived from the new commandment Jesus gave his disciples before his crucifixion, that they they were to love one another as he had loved them. There are records of the Royal tradition on Maundy Thursday in Holy Week dating back to the 12th century. During the service the Queen handed out coins to 82 men and 82 women, all retired, who had been selected by the four main denominations in Northern Ireland for service to the community. She also presented them with a separate bag containing a 50 pence piece and a £5 coin to commemorate Prince Charles's birthday. Four children, one each from Church of Ireland, controlled, Roman Catholic and integrated schools in Armagh, were selected to play a symbolic part in the service, wearing linen towels in remembrance of times when the monarch washed the feet of the congregation. The massive dimensions of the cathedral inside combined with elegant choreography, traditional costumes and majestic choirs and musicians blended in a grandeur worthy of a monarch. To read the complete article, see: Full Story RARE 1878 LONDON TEMPLE BAR MEDAL UNEARTHED IN NEW ZEALAND BACKYARD A rare English medal uncovered in the backyard of an Upper Hutt house will soon be on its way to the Museum of London. Kevin Homan discovered the dirt-encrusted Temple Bar Medal while working with his father on foundations for the family's garage. "At first I thought it was an old jar lid, then I washed it off with a hose. Around the edges it said that in 1672 the Temple Bar was erected and then removed in 1878." The one-kilogram medal was made in 1878 from the lead roof of Temple Bar, which historically marked the western boundary of the City of London. The gateway, made of Portland stone and dating from 1672, was reputedly designed by Sir Christopher Wren, architect of nearby St Paul's Cathedral. Only one other of the historic medals is known to exist, a mint example with an original glass-covered face valued at 500 (NZ$1247). It is unknown how the buried treasure ended up in Upper Hutt, but Kevin Homan's father, Stewart, has a theory. "My father bought this house [in 1952] after receiving an inheritance from two quite wealthy aunts who lived in London. He might have been given it and then buried it with other rubbish." The Temple Bar Medal is from a collection called the City of London Medals, struck by the Corporation of the City of London. Most in the series had runs of up to 450, but a notable exception is the Temple Bar Medal, considered extremely rare by experts. To read the complete article, see: Full Story SAINT-GAUDENS NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE HOPES MINT PRODUCT FUELS INTEREST [The Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle design is getting another workout. The Union Leader of Cornish, NH published an article interviewing Henry Duffy, curator at the Saint-Gaudens National Historic Site, about the new version of the artists' coin design being prepared by the U.S. Mint. -Editor] The United States Mint has announced it will recreate a $20 gold coin designed by Augustus Saint-Gaudens in 1907, and a curator hopes the new version of the coin will attract more visitors to the famed American sculptor's former estate in Cornish. Considered by many to be the most beautiful coin ever made in the United States, the high-relief Liberty Gold Piece, also known as the Double Eagle, bear the image of a woman holding a branch and a torch on one side. "Liberty's torch represents knowledge, and the branch represents victory," said Henry Duffy, curator at the Saint- Gaudens National Historic Site on Route 12A in Cornish. "Of course, the knowledge she's spreading is democracy. She's spreading democracy to the world." The back of the coin features an eagle flying under the sun. On the re-issued coin, the inscription "In God We Trust" will appear above the sun, as it did on a 1908 version of the same coin. The design will be featured on a collectible 24-karat coin intended for sale to the public in 2009. Duffy said the mint originally planned to release the coin in 2007, its 100th anniversary, but original molds had been destroyed, which delayed the process. Duffy said visitors to the historic site often ask how they can acquire one of Saint-Gaudens' coins. "They're usually disappointed when they found out how much they are," he said. "This will be helpful to us to be able to recommend this to people, so I'm sure people are going to like that." Duffy said he thinks the new coins will be a hit among seasoned and new coin collectors and may even draw more visitors to the historic site in Cornish. "There's a lot of interesting intrigue and mystery around these coins right now," he said. To read the complete article, see: Full Story [Numismatic News commented on the planned pieforts, basically a revival of the ultra-high-relief Saint-Gaudens $20 design. I've never been a fan of dusting off old designs for new coins, but in this case it sounds like a winning concept, assuming the Mint indeed remains faithful to the artist's original conception. -Editor] The dream of President Theodore Roosevelt and artist Augustus Saint-Gaudens to restore the artistry of ancient Greece to American coinage may be realized in 2009 when the Mint plans to strike ultra-high-relief Saint-Gaudens $20 gold pieces for collectors. Now without the constraints of commerce, the Mint will attempt a 27mm coin with a thick planchet... The French have a term for a double thickness planchet. It is called piefort and collectors in Europe and elsewhere find coins struck on these planchets appealing. The new pieces will be 24 karat, or .999 fine, eliminating some of the hardness of a gold coin, which in 1907 was struck with a .900 fine gold alloyed with copper. They will also contain an even troy ounce of gold, making them conform to the demands of 21st century collectors and bullion coin buyers. To read the complete article, see: Full Story CZECH BANKNOTE DESIGNER HAS ART ON EXHIBIT IN NEW YORK [An E-Sylum reader forwarded this article about a New York art exhibit featuring the work of a Czech bank note designer. -Editor] Works by renowned Czech graphic artist Oldrich Kulhanek, author of Czech banknotes' design, are displayed in the Czech Centre in New York until April 7, the organisers have told CTK. The exhibition shows Kulhanek's works inspired by biblical motives from the past ten years. His display in Chicago within the Prague Days cultural festival, where his drafts of the current Czech banknotes were presented, scored a great success last year. Kulhanek has also designed postage stamps, among others, with a portrait of Czech President Vaclav Klaus, who was re-elected for another five-year term in February. Kulhanek's works are included in the collections of the Library of Congress in Washington, Chicago's Art Institute, the Arts Museum in Cincinnati and Houston University, as well as in galleries in Prague, Paris, Vienna and other European cities. To read the complete article, see: Full Story JAPANESE CASH HOARD UNCOVERED In Japan, cash is truly king. Credit cards are regarded with suspicion; fat wallets are the norm. Banknotes are used even for big transactions. Yet even the Japanese were taken aback by this week's announcement of a massive bust by the tax authorities. Investigators arrested two sisters in the city of Osaka on charges of evading taxes by hoarding the equivalent of $56.4 million in cash. Hatsue Shimizu, 64, and Yoshiko Ishii, 55, were said to have hidden the money away in Shimizu's garage. Last fall, when tax inspectors first raided the property, they were stunned to find stacks of cardboard boxes (50 in all) stuffed with yen banknotes. The stash is said to have weighed in at around 1,300 pounds. Many of the wads of bills still had the original bank bands around them; some were moldy with age. It took the tax bureau days to count out all of the money. Prohibitive inheritance-tax rates are certainly the main reason, but other factors might be at fault as well. In the late 1990s, widespread fears about bank stability thanks to a nationwide financial crisis triggered a rush to convert assets to tansu yokin ("drawer deposits"). To read the complete article, see: Full Story COINS VS. COMICS: DICK JOHNSON ON THE GREAT COMIC BOOK SCARE Dick Johnson writes: "Be glad you collect coins instead of comic books. For one thing, you can't pick up a copy on newsprint without damaging the corners and bending the pages forever. For another, your mother may have cleaned out your room and threw out all your old copies (now worth four and five figures). "A recently published book, 'The Ten-Cent Plaque: The Great Comic-Book Scare and How it Changed America' by David Hajdu, was reviewed this week on the blog HOUstone. It documents all the travails of comic books. It seems a self-appointed do-gooder, Dr. Frederic Wertham, a sort of Dr. Phil of his day who, as a physician and not a social scientist, firmly saw a clear and unbreakable link between comic books and juvenile delinquency. "Wertham’s treatise, 'Seduction of the Innocent,' quickly stoked an existing fire that had parent and civic groups in arms, leading to mass burnings of comics (which would be worth a fortune today), banning, and most memorably, Congressional hearings. "Thank goodness Congressional hearings of numismatic interest these days are aimed at what more coins can the U.S. Mint produce for the burgeoning coin market. Thank goodness your mother wouldn't think of throwing out your old coin collection -- after all it was money! Pity the poor comic book enthusiast." To read the complete article, see: Full Story FEATURED WEB SITE: AMERICAN BANK NOTE COMPANY AND ITS PREDECESSOR COMPANIES This week's featured web site is suggested by John and Nancy Wilson of Ocala, FL, who write: "While researching the American Bank Note Company we came across this excellent site that has a history of Engraving and Banknote Companies that would be invaluable to collectors, dealers and of course researchers. The site is owned by Terry Cox. We think it is informative and helpful. Featured Web Site Wayne Homren Numismatic Bibliomania Society Content presented in The E-Sylum is not necessarily researched or independently fact-checked, and views expressed do not necessarily represent those of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society. The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. For more information please see our web site at http://www.coinbooks.org/ There is a membership application available on the web site. To join, print the application and return it with your check to the address printed on the application. Visit the Membership page. Those wishing to become new E-Sylum subscribers (or wishing to Unsubscribe) can go to the following web page link. |
|