PREV ARTICLE
NEXT ARTICLE
FULL ISSUE
PREV FULL ISSUE
V11 2008 INDEX
E-SYLUM ARCHIVE
The E-Sylum: Volume 11, Number 13, March 30, 2008, Article 14 HISPANIC SOCIETY SUES ANS OVER CONTROL OF COLLECTION On February 12, 2008 the Hispanic Society of America filed a suit against the American Numismatic Society over control of a collection of some 37,000 Spanish coins formed by Archer Huntington, who was a major benefactor of both the Hispanic Society and ANS. It was Huntington's largesse that enabled the construction of Audubon Terrance at 155th and Broadway in New York, where the two societies resided for decades until the ANS's recent move to lower Manhattan. I checked the ANS web site description of its Latin American coin cabinet, which it says numbers only 20,000 pieces in total. In addition to acquisitions from the Greenwood, Guttag, Echenique and Herz collections made possible by Henry Grunthal, Harry Bass and other donors, the site says that "In the 1950s, the Hispanic Society of America agreed to place on permanent loan its unsurpassed collection of coins of Spain and all Spanish dominions." I was aware that the ANS had the Hispanic Society collection but am not aware of the loan conditions. These cases can be complicated to settle – since half a century has passed, the original parties to the transaction are gone and the contracts and paperwork may be missing or incomplete, enabling both sides to plausibly interpret the situation in their favor. The HSA's argument will likely be "what part of the word LOAN don't you understand?" The ANS's likely response will be, "What part of PERMANENT don't YOU understand?" Having been down this road before when the Carnegie Museum of Pittsburgh decided to deaccession its extensive collection in the late 1970s, I can guess what this is really about: raising money. The Hispanic Society will make all sorts of public noise about how the coins don't fit with their core mission, but suggestions that the coins be donated to a more appropriate venue will fall on deaf ears. In Pittsburgh the Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania came forward with a plan to take over the collection and display significant parts of it, but in the end, of course, the Carnegie sold the collection in a series of sales in London, New York and Zurich. Instead of handing clear title to the ANS and walking away, the HSA is trying to regain control of the collection so it can sell it. Auctioneers worldwide have likely already been contacted. I can also guess what the reaction of the collecting community will be - "Stop the sale! Protect the collection!" Editorials will be written and petitions may be circulated. But petitions unaccompanied by a passing of a big hat to raise funds are often a lesson in futility. I learned that, too, having gone door to door collecting hundreds of signatures on a petition to stop the Carnegie sale. Oh, to be young and idealistic again. But still, I hope and pray for the sake of numismatic scholarship that the collection will somehow remain with the ANS. So what are the facts? First, I consulted the best information source I know - the "The American Numismatic Society 1858-1958" (Edited by Howard Adelson, 1958). The book, scheduled for an updated edition this year, is a very detailed history of the organization, its collections, and benefactors. The Hispanic Society collection is discussed on p278-279. By far the most outstanding collection to come to the Society was that of the Hispanic Society of America, brought together originally by Archer M. Huntington. It consisted of 30,355 pieces when first placed into the custody of the American Numismatic Society but has since been materially increased by about 7,000 pieces. The actual ownership remained in the hands of the Hispanic Society but the study and publication was to be carried out under joint auspices. Dr. Herbert E. Ives, President of the American Numismatic Society in 1946, had carried on the negotiations with Mr. Huntington regarding the deposit of these coins and the provision for their publication... Once all these arrangements had been reduced to writing by Mr. Huntington they were sent in the form of a letter to President Ives, and all the members of the council signed a copy of that letter at the meeting of June 21, 1946, as a token of acceptance. The ANS has taken on a considerable amount of expense over the years caring for, studying and documenting the collection. Would those expenses have to be reimbursed by the Hispanic Society? Do the documents specifically state that the transfer was a PERMANENT loan? Does the Hispanic Society have a case? Next, I naturally checked with ANS Executive Director Ute Wartenberg Kagan. Here's what the ANS is able to say at this point: "The Huntington collection is probably the most comprehensive collection of Iberian and Iberian-related coinage outside Spain. In some areas, such as the Visigothic gold, it may be the finest anywhere. The ANS is committed to trying to trying to preserve this collection in so far as it can. It is a highly important scholarly tool and educational resource, of obvious relevance to many Americans. It is clear to us from his correspondence that Archer Huntington, the most generous benefactor in the history of the ANS, intended this collection to remain whole and in the hands of the ANS. He regarded the formation of the collection and its deposit alongside the foremost numismatic collection in the US as a service he had performed for his country. For the past 60 years the ANS has been cataloguing and researching the collection itself, and has been facilitating the work of others on the collection. Like other parts of our collection, Huntington’s coins are an important resource in our educational program, including the annual Summer Seminar. While the ANS may not have clear title to the coins, we are negotiating as strenuously as we can with the HSA to try to preserve the most important areas of the collection for future generations of students and scholars." Regarding the web site's Latin American item count, Ute writes: "The 20,000 figure on the ANS site doesn't refer to the HSA collection, which is primarily ancient, medieval, Islamic, with some Latin American pieces." Andrew Meadows of the ANS adds: "On the question of the date, although the portion that Huntington personally transferred to us came in the 1940s, after his death in 1955 a further portion of his collection was discovered in the basement at HSA and transferred to us under the same conditions as the first batch. So technically it is only since 1957 that we have had the whole collection. I believe that’s what the website text refers to." An article about the suit appeared in a Spanish publication. I used Altavisa.com's Babelfish translator to get a crude English version. One excerpt reads: The Hispanic Society has indicated that 'we want to recover the pieces because the American Numismatic failed to fulfill the loan agreement'. And it is that the Hispanic knew that the Numismatic was going to change its location a year ago without to have requested the pertinent permission I read this to mean that the Hispanic society is using the ANS' move from Audubon Terrace as a reason to nullify the permanent loan agreement. The case is before the Supreme Court of the State of New York (case index number 600423-2008, Justice Charles E. Ramos). The documents are public records, available on the court's web site. The ANS' move is relevant to the lawsuit, if only as a pretext for the suit. In their complaint, the Hispanic Society states that when the ANS moved from Audubon Terrace in 2004 a new one-year agreement was made with the ANS to enable the transfer of the collection to the new location at 96 Fulton Street. The agreement was to be renewable yearly. When the ANS announced its latest move from Fulton Street to Hudson Square, the Hispanic Society declined to renew its agreement. On March 4th, the ANS was given 20 days to respond to the suit. As of today a response has not been posted to the court's web site. To read a newspaper article about the suit (in Spanish) see: Full Story To access the New York Supreme Court web site, see: New York Supreme Court For a description of the ANS Latin American collection, see: ANS Latin American collection For more information on the American Numismatic Society, see: American Numismatic Society For more information on the Hispanic Society of America, see: Hispanic Society of America [There is an informative article about the ANS in the April 2008 issue of COINage magazine. "An Enduring Society" by Dom Yaunchunas explores the organization's 150-year history and plans for the future. The article also notes the planned publication later this year of a book titled "The 150 Greatest Treasures of the ANS." Wayne Homren, Editor The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org. To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address: whomren@coinlibrary.com To subscribe go to: https://my.binhost.com/lists/listinfo/esylum | |
PREV ARTICLE
NEXT ARTICLE
FULL ISSUE
PREV FULL ISSUE
V11 2008 INDEX
E-SYLUM ARCHIVE
Copyright © 1998 - 2024
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster