Visit our NBS Sponsors

About Us The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit association devoted to the study and enjoyment of numismatic literature. For more information please see our web site at coinbooks.org Subscriptions Those wishing to become new E-Sylum subscribers (or wishing to Unsubscribe) can go to the following web page link Membership There is a membership application available on the web site Membership Application To join, print the application and return it with your check to the address printed on the application. Print/Digital membership is $40 to addresses in the U.S., and $60 elsewhere. A digital-only membership is available for $25. For those without web access, write to: Jeff Dickerson, Treasurer Numismatic Bibliomania Society P. O. Box 578, Weatherford, TX 76086 Asylum For Asylum mailing address changes and other membership questions, contact Jeff at this email address: treasurer@coinbooks.org Submissions To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address: whomren@gmail.com BUY THE BOOK BEFORE THE COIN Sale Calendar Watch here for updates!

 

Content presented in The E-Sylum is not necessarily researched or independently fact-checked, and views expressed do not necessarily represent those of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.

WAYNE'S WORDS: THE E-SYLUM AUGUST 11, 2024

New subscribers this week include: Mark Wieclaw. Welcome aboard! We now have 7,249 subscribers.

Thank you for reading The E-Sylum. If you enjoy it, please send me the email addresses of friends you think may enjoy it as well and I'll send them a subscription. Contact me at whomren@gmail.com anytime regarding your subscription, or questions, comments or suggestions about our content.

This week we open with one new book, updates from the Newman Numismatic Portal, notes from readers, and more.

Other topics this week include medal designer Eugene Daub, chopmarks on paper money, the ANA's honorary Doctor of Numismatics, shipwreck coins, Olympic medals, counterfeiters old and new, and the Maritime Silk Road.

To learn more about relics from the USS Merrimack, prison money, the 1781 North American Token, collectors Lucius S. Ruder and Dr. Philip Holmes, books with embossed and colored plates, the New England Threepence and Olympics Handover Medallions, read on. Have a great week, everyone!

Wayne Homren
Editor, The E-Sylum

NEW BOOK: PORTRAITS, METALS, AND MONUMENTS

A group of dedicated San Pedro collaborators are raising money to publish the first comprehensive book dedicated to the work of renowned sculptor and San Pedro resident, Eugene Daub. Titled, Portraits, Metals, and Monuments, this book documents Daub's career, his dedication to capturing the profound humanity of historical figures, and his significant contributions to public art.

The Foreword of this 120-page book is authored by American Art critic Wolfgang Marby and it features more than 100 photographs of Daub's public art work and is edited by Andrea Serna.

Read more here

SCHENKMAN PRESENTS USS MERRIMACK RELICS

David Schenkman Presents Relics from the USS Merrimack

The USS Merrimack represents a well-known bit of Civil War naval history. Born as the USS Merrimack in 1855 and later sunk by the Union to avoid capture, the Confederacy raised the vessel and recommissioned her as the newly ironclad CSS Virginia in 1862. The CSS Virginia faced off against the USS Monitor in the 1862 Battle of Hampton Roads, an attempt to overcome the Union blockade that isolated Norfolk and Richmond. Neither side could claim victory, but the Union maintained the advantage as the blockade held.

Over time various relic pieces have been created from Merrimack scrapped iron. Dave Schenkman prepared a slide presentation on this topic, c. 1980, which has lately been digitized by Newman Portal. In 1979, the Virginia Numismatic Association published Schenkman's monograph, Tokens and Medals Commemorating the Battle Between the Monitor and the Merrimac. Newman Portal acknowledges Schenkman for sharing his slide set and accompanying speaker notes.

Read more here

VIDEO: US PRISON SYSTEM MONEY

Read more here

MORE CHOP MARKS ON PAPER MONEY

Peter Aa of Bridgewater, NJ writes:

Read more here

NOTES FROM E-SYLUM READERS: AUGUST 11, 2024

On the Cash Coins in Bound Book
R. Jones writes:

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
ARCHIVES INTERNATIONAL SALE #96 SELECTIONS : Lot 69: Japanese Wad_kaichin Cash Coins in Bound Book (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n31a21.html)

Read more here

 

VOCABULARY TERM: PRESERVATION

Preservation. Preventing deterioration or destruction. Curators are charged with the preservation of specimens in their control. But this does not exist only at museums and public collections, but also by private collectors in the preservation of items in their collections. It includes the housing, storing, proper shipping and protection during any exhibition. It attempts to eliminate any damage as nicks or scratches from mishandling, deterioration of surface condition and protection from chemical and physical deterioration. In effect, we are beholden to every collector and curator in the past who has had custody of every item currently in existence in both public and private collections. Likewise, every collector and curator has an inherent obligation to preserve specimens in their own collections today for the generations of collectors of the future.

Read more here

MORE ON THE DOCTOR OF NUMISMATICS

One of my goals for the ANA WFOM was to learn the selection process for the people who are awarded honorary doctor of numismatics. I talked with several ANA staff members, Most said they did not know, including the director of education. One answer I got was that the winners were determined by the ANA executive director in consultation with the ANA board.

I found a moment to talk with ANA executive director Kim Kiick during the exhibit awards presentation. She said that Susan McMillan made the selection when she was responsible for the Summer Seminar. She was replaced by Amber Bradish for 2017-2018 and Brianna Victor for 2019-2021. In recent years the selection has been made by Kim and Jennifer Ackerman.

Read more here

STAN KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART EIGHT

GREG BENNICK: So, any other stories, funny or otherwise, you've got about anybody else before we go?

STANLEY KESSELMAN: There was a collector in New York. His name was Milton Kaufman and he collected gold coins and he was a builder. And in the basement of his building, maybe four-story building, he built a bank vault with a real bank vault door. And he put his coins in there on the wall because you like to look at them every day. And he had the best set of New Orleans twenties in the world. He had a set of CC twenties, Carson City twenties. And he just loved and he had them all in plastic holders. All in as a set. Max Humber from Paramount sold him the 1870 CC twenty, for $6,000. Nice, very fine. Anybody would have paid $6,000 for it at that point in time. But I guess he wanted to make the first coin, you know, affordable.

Max had somebody in Europe who went through all the banks and sent him all the coins. And they got the dates for free because the banks again didn't care what date it was. So, everything was fine. And we traveled, Milton and I, to Denver for the coin show. And I introduced him to Abe Kosoff. I said, Abe, this is my friend, Milton Kaufman. His checks are good. You know. So, Abe says, I would have taken this check at any time, except now you told me about it, I don't know if I'm going to take it anymore because of the reference. That's what he told him. Everybody laughed. It's just funny.

GREG BENNICK: It's great.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: So, Milton came back home. And one day, they tried to break into his building. They had jackhammers. They had a police scanner to scan the police radio. And they caught him. But he was so scared for his family. And everybody knew he had coins. They are valuable. He called me up and said he had to get rid of these coins within a week. And I called up Jerry Cohn again and Abner Kreisberg. Jerry Cohn bought the coins. And I charged Milton Kaufman $500 for the service. And Jerry Cohn said he paid me $500. And he came and picked up all the coins. But again, this was a time when the coin market was very bad. Yeah. And Jerry Cohn could not sell the coins at all. Milton Kaufman gave me the $500 immediately. Jerry Cohn never paid me the $500.

GREG BENNICK: Really?

STANLEY KESSELMAN: He said he lost money on the deal. And I never pressed it. You lose money, I don't want his $500.

GREG BENNICK: Sure.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: But the coins ended up going through very, very famous collections. I'm trying to remember. The guy from Virginia Beach, the dealer, what's his name?

GREG BENNICK: Del Loy Hanson.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: Yes. Yes, that's who it is. He ended up, there you go. He ended up with the coins.

GREG BENNICK: Yeah, Del Loy Hanson.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: And yeah, he ended up. And I have never met him, but I'm sure he has an unbelievable collection.

GREG BENNICK: Oh, it's incredible.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: Yeah. And Del Loy also was condition conscious. He improved coin by coin for a lot of times. And now they're selling his duplicates and all his other coins, which are also beautiful coins. His duplicates are fantastic.

GREG BENNICK: For sure.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: So, I guess that's about it that I can come up with.

GREG BENNICK: Well, this has been amazing. I appreciate you and your time and your story so much.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: I don't think I have any more, but that's it. It was a fun time. And the greatest part of the hobby was not the money, but meeting people from different places who were older than I was. And they educated me in different fields because they had better knowledge and they were older. And that was the fun. They spoke differently, had different values. Come from different places. But everybody was friendly with everybody else. It was wonderful relationships just to have.

GREG BENNICK: I love it.

STANLEY KESSELMAN: And every week I was on an airplane someplace else, either Beverly Hills or Dallas, Texas, meeting people. And it was a fun life. It's a wonderful hobby. And it's also a pleasure to have met you, you know, to do this.

GREG BENNICK: Absolutely. I appreciate you so much. I'm so glad we did.

For everybody listening. This has been an amazing interview with Stanley Kesselman. And I just really appreciate the time you've spent today. And a lot of people are really going to appreciate the stories you've told.

About the Interviewer
Greg Bennick (www.gregbennick.com) is a keynote speaker and long time coin collector with a focus on major mint error coins. Have ideas for other interviewees? Contact him anytime on the web or via instagram @minterrors.

To watch the complete video, see:
Stanley Kesselman Interviewed for the NNP by Greg Bennick (https://nnp.wustl.edu/library/book/638521)

To read the complete transcript, see:
Stanley Kesselman Interviewed for the NNP by Greg Bennick (Transcript) (https://nnp.wustl.edu/library/book/638520)

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART ONE (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n25a06.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART TWO (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n26a13.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART THREE (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n27a11.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART FOUR (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n28a17.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART FIVE (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n29a18.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART SIX (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n30a19.html)
STANLEY KESSELMAN INTERVIEW, PART SEVEN (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n31a13.html)

 

ERIC SCHENA INTERVIEW, PART FIVE

ERIC SCHENA: Yeah ancient and medieval central Asian, which is very important.

GREG BENNICK: Well, because when we met and I remember asking you that day. You mentioned ancient coins at the time and I have an interest in them as well. And I asked you what specifically? Well you started listing dynasties that I had never heard of. I didn't do poorly in school. I didn't do great all the time. But the dynasties that you mentioned had a lot of syllables and I didn't recognize any of them. Have at it and explain to us your collecting areas of interest in ancients and whatnot and mention a couple dynasties and impress us.

ERIC SCHENA: Sure. My specialty in fact my degree is in Greek and Roman archaeology. That's actually how I met my wife. She has the exact same degree. I do like Greek and Roman and Byzantine coins. But what's really interesting about some of the ancients are the ones that come out of Central Asia, and I'm talking about the Greco-Bactrian, the Indo-Greek, the Indo Scythian coinage and similar dynasties. The Hephthalites for instance, the Kushans, those dynasties out there. In many cases the names of the kings are only known from the coins. That is certainly the case with the later Indo-Greek coins. In fact, there was a Kushan king. He was only known as Soter Megas, which is great savior in Greek.

Because most of the coins, the only title that was on them was Soter Megas. It was only through an inscription that was found in an archaeological site in the 1990s tied to a couple of bronze coins that the man's name was actually identified as Vima Takto. But the fact is, it was years and years and years, no idea who that man was. This king, we knew who he was, we can now put a name to him. And some of the other Indo-Greek kings, the order and the dating is entirely done by numismatics, because there's no archaeological evidence otherwise. So a lot of that is important and that translates to a different degree. Same discipline, but a different field with the tokens and store tokens.

With the ancients, finding those little pieces and knowing that you're holding a coin that is really the only written record of this particular king having ever ruled is fascinating. And this is especially important with the Islamic dynasties from that area as well. A lot of that stuff is not necessarily as well understood. In particular the Qarakhanids, the actual name that they called themselves is not known. Most people refer to them as the Ilaq Khans or Qarakhanid dynasty and they spanned a period of about two or three hundred years. This was around 1100, 1200, 1300 or so, probably a little on the earlier side of that. I know them mostly from the Hijri dating rather than the modern dating.

But hundreds upon hundreds upon hundreds of various little rulers, sub-rulers and other khans and sub-khanates and they're all over the place and how they all tie to each other and it's a science. It's an absolute science and a lot of that is not well understood anywhere. So, numismatics has an awful lot to contribute in places like that. It contributes here in the United States in preserving our history with tokens and also abroad with ancient coins and things like that.

GREG BENNICK: It's so cool.

ERIC SCHENA: Yeah, one of the things that I think Europe does, pretty interestingly enough is they treat numismatics as a scientific discipline and they actually have courses and you can get professorships in numismatics in several schools in Europe. I think that's very valuable. To them, it is exactly like a pottery specialist on an archaeological site. Because you have to have a specialist in that thing. Is this Samian redware or is it some other type of pottery? Because that might date the site and coins are very valuable for that, as well as pottery. And so, there is an importance with these little things that we use every day.

GREG BENNICK: Immensely so and you've expressed that so clearly and even just listening to you share these ideas, it becomes evident, that coins are not just tools that are made to pay for things. But there are tools for us archaeologically, historically in order to understand elements of the future or elements of the past which would not have lasted into the future had it not been for the coins themselves.

ERIC SCHENA: Exactly and there are an awful lot of institutions out there that don't have the manpower to do an awful lot of research that serious collectors of ancients and medieval coins or coins in general do on a regular basis. I mean a lot of the great collections of coins have been formed by private individuals. Who, through their generosity have made those collections publicly available for study and that has helped a lot of people and thankfully they get published in books like the Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum series, things like that. That's spreading that knowledge and that's very important and very crucial and something that I'm a very strong believer in.

I'm not particularly keen on withholding information, because I'm interested in something being worth more money than if I hold on to it and just hoard it. There's a lot of this stuff that has valuable information and that information deserves to be out there and shared. So I do like to share that information when I can find good things like that. And I have an open library policy with my friends who collect. They have anything that they want research in, let me know and they can go to my library at any time.

I have a fairly extensive library, mostly on tokens and other oddball stuff but I also have business directories. I don't know if you can see in the background, that is a microfiche reader. Yeah, I know! I have a microfiche reader. And right below it is a set of microfiche of business directories from 1800 to 1861 in the United States.

GREG BENNICK: Wow.

ERIC SCHENA: I know that's a blast from the 1980s.

GREG BENNICK: It's awesome. And I love it. And I'm going to utilize your offer for information requests, because there's going to be some point where I'm going to find a counterstamp and I'm going to wonder who was around and a merchant in Indiana in 1847. And you're the person I'm going to call.

ERIC SCHENA: If there's a business directory between 1800 and 1861, there's probably a good bet that I can get to it. But the thing is again, those things, that's all on microfiche. And this kind of goes with a lot of the technology and making sure this stuff doesn't get forgotten. Microfiche is not something that you see every day anymore. I'm a Gen X'er and any time I went to the library, I had to use those machines, both in high school and in college, but they all got supplanted with the internet. Don't need them anymore. It's all computerized. Now that technology is an obsolete technology and the knowledge of learning how to use those things is just going to disappear, because an awful lot of microfiche got thrown out. And so that's knowledge that just gets tossed, mainly because nobody has a reader, because where are you going to get a microfiche reader?

GREG BENNICK: That's true. But we also rely on the fact that that information is placed on the internet, meaning there might be tablets with cuneiform that exist in the world that have information on them that's just not yet on the internet. And there might be business directories from 1827 in your collection that aren't on the internet anywhere.

ERIC SCHENA: Exactly. That's exactly right. The digitization of early documents, something that the Newman Numismatic Portal has done fantastically, I might add, is a very important addition to scholarship. I know I've donated a few of my works for digitization, and I'm a firm believer in that. But you're exactly right. Those aren't going to be necessarily complete because who knows? There's probably some weird guy in Virginia who's got a stack of microfiche of these directories from Philadelphia from 1811, but they're all in microfiche. So, yeah.

GREG BENNICK: It's pretty amazing. I know that I've had interactions with the Newman Portal myself about this, because my dad wrote a compendium. I've mentioned this, I think in another interview. I can't recall. But my dad wrote a compendium of railroad and railroad-related metals and tokens. I think that's the exact title. A Compendium of U.S. and Canadian Railroad and Railroad-related Medals and Tokens, Including Bridge Medals and Tokens. Brevity of title selection was not his forte, but he wrote this compendium. And he sold copies of it. He printed it himself, and sold copies for years. And when he decided to sell his token and medal collection, he sold the collection. He got rid of all the books, sold them, gave them away, whatnot, and then deleted the computer files.

And I only found this out recently. I was asking him. I said, What happened to you? I've got a copy of the fourth issue of your compendium here. Where are the rest of them? To make a long story short, another story for another time, he told me. He said he got rid of the files, not out of malice. He just thought, I don't need these anymore. And I was like, well, then that information is lost. So, I've put it upon myself to find editions of each of the editions of his book. I've found now each of the extant editions of his book. And I'm going to be digitizing them for the Newman Numismatic Portal. And then sending physical copies to libraries because I've met people who have used this book and rely on it for information.

And the fact of the matter is, without the digitization, without the saving of the history, whether on microfiche or on Dave Bennick's printouts…my dad's work, it would be gone. It'd be lost. So, who knows what's in that microfiche collection of yours that doesn't exist anywhere else? I'm kind of fascinated by that.

About the Interviewer
Greg Bennick (www.gregbennick.com) is a keynote speaker and long time coin collector with a focus on major mint error coins. Have ideas for other interviewees? Contact him anytime on the web or via instagram @minterrors.

To watch the complete video, see:
Eric Schena Interviewed for the NNP by Greg Bennick (https://nnp.wustl.edu/library/book/639081)

To read the complete transcript, see:
Eric Schena Interviewed for the NNP by Greg Bennick (Transcript) (https://nnp.wustl.edu/library/book/639095)

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
ERIC SCHENA INTERVIEW, PART ONE (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n28a18.html)
ERIC SCHENA INTERVIEW, PART TWO (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n29a19.html)
ERIC SCHENA INTERVIEW, PART THREE (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n30a20.html)
ERIC SCHENA INTERVIEW, PART FOUR (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n31a14.html)

SUMMER 2024 ROSA AMERICANA SELECTIONS

17. 1773 Virginia Halfpenny. Newman 27-J, W-1585. Period After GEORGIVS, 7 Harp Strings. Rarity-2 as a variety, Rarity-7 with obverse counterstamped R.P.S. About Uncirculated, a lovely coin with just light wear at the highpoints of either side, and exceptionally nice color and surface quality. While an AU Virginia is nothing too special, even one without the heavy spotting seen on many of the higher-grade examples from the famous Cohen Hoard, this coin is made far more special by the initials R.P.S. counterstamped at the center obverse. This counterstamp was done with a logotype punch, not individual letters, and is not found on any coin other than Virginia coppers. In the December 2012 issue of The Colonial Newsletter (now available for free on the Newman Numismatic Portal), Roger Moore and Dennis Wierzba illustrate 9 examples (including this, which is Illustration F on Plate 2), and note the existence of a couple more that they were not able to have photographed. With a dozen or so known to the authors, the existence of a few more pieces is certain, so there are perhaps 15 or so examples of this counterstamp known. All examples seen are in high grade (EF at the minimum), and all have the R.P.S, counterstamp centered on the obverse, punched vertically (a few show more than one punch, and one has the counterstamp rotated so that the R is at the bottom of the coin and the S at the top). There was clearly some care given to the placement of the counterstamp, and that care may have gone into the selection of the host coins as well, as all 9 examples illustrated in the CNL article are high grade, with clean, smooth surfaces, including one that was later holed. The authors discount the possibility of this being a merchant or tradesman's counterstamp and instead propose that these were actually done for use as communion tokens, possibly by the Reformed Presbyterian Synod – R.P.S. – of Pennsylvania. Some of the churches that splintered from that group were in an area that later became West Virginia, and the printed history of those churches mention the use of communion tokens but does not describe them, which certainly adds credence to the theory. Communion tokens were in wide use at the time, and several types are known for North America, the most famous being the Albany Church Pennies. The Virginia halfpennies with the R.P.S. countermark are known on just four varieties – Newman 23-Q. 25-M, 26-Y, and 27-J. The authors also suggest the counterstamps were applied in the 1775-1810 period, on coins pulled from circulation, with the light wear on known specimens from their gentle use within the church. A fascinating and rare issue, we note none were in the Syd Martin collection of Virginia halfpennies.

$900

49. 1787 Excelsior Copper. W-5795. Rarity-6+. Indian / New York Arms. PCGS Graded EF Details--Environmental Damage, an accurate grade. This is the Ted Craige example of this rarity, a coin that was off the market for nearly a half century between the time Craige purchased it as a dealer and when it was offered in the Stack's Bowers March 2013 sale of his collection, as Lot 314, where it was described as:

100.31 grains. Charcoal-gray and brown with fine surface granularity akin to burial patina or fire scale. Some raised metal specks on the obverse are consistent with heat exposure, mostly scattered around the lower half of the obverse. The sharpness is excellent on both sides; centering is typical with a few denticles visible in the upper right obverse. One of the classic rarities of the Confederation era, with the distinctive Standing Indian design and his accompanying motto LIBER NATUS LIBERTATEM DEFENDO or "Born free, I defend freedom." This issue is thought to have been coined as a pattern in one of the efforts to land a state coinage contract from New York; no state contract was ever awarded. John Ford extensively researched this issue and kept a careful census of it; he counted a dozen specimens, though it is difficult to tell which of his entries (if any) matches up with this one. Ford did note that Mrs. Norweb owned a "VG, corroded" specimen, but no such coin ever turned up in the Norweb sales. Did Mrs. Norweb spin it off to Ted Craige via their mutual favorite dealer Richard Picker in the hopes of getting a better one someday? Or did Ford simply see one somewhere and misremember where he saw it? Ford's own piece sold for just $63,250 in 2004, a seeming bargain considering Garrett's brought $21,000 hammer in 1979. Either Garrett's or Ford's would be a six-figure coin today. This one represents a somewhat different price point that should be very attractive to most collectors who seek an example of this famous rarity. Mr. Craige priced this example at $2,500 circa 1970.

Provenance: From the Ted L. Craige Collection. Paper envelope included.

The coin sold for a strong $55,812.50 in spirited bidding – understandable perhaps, as it had been some time since a higher-grade example had come up for auction, though in the decade since this one sold more examples crossed the auction block than in the previous half century combined, the result of major collections coming onto the market.

Previous census lists have been woefully incomplete, and we have spent several days updating it. There are 15 examples of this issue now known, with the present coin right in the middle of the census;

1. MS64. Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. (Bowers and Merena, 5/1996), lot 58 at $143,000. Sold as MS65 in the Eliasberg sale, NGC graded MS64 when sold in the Don Partrick collection (Heritage, 1/2021), lot 3932 for an amazing $204,000. This is likely the J.N.T. Levick coin (Woodward 10/1864), lot 1543 described as uncirculated, portions of the copper still bright, without a doubt the finest existing specimen of this very rare coin. It brought $73 to Putnam.
2. Choice AU. Sarah Sophia Banks (1818); British Museum. Listed as Banks-59 in this author's exploration of the colonial coins in her collection, Journal of Early American Numismatics, June 2020 (Vol. 3, No. 1), p. 105. It was noted there that Miss Banks was aware that this was a pattern issue when she acquired the coin, likely in the 1790s.
3. Choice AU. Lorin G. Parmelee (New York Coin & Stamp Co., 6/1890), lot 457; H.P. Smith (Chapman Brothers, 6/1906), lot 124; Col. James W. Ellsworth; John Work Garrett; Johns Hopkins University (Bowers and Ruddy, 11/1979), lot 601. Graded EF40 in the Garrett sale, we note that Ford called this one VF!
4. AU50 PCGS, lightly cleaned. Eric P. Newman (Heritage, 11/2014), lot 3028, realized $88,125; (Heritage 1/16), lot 1231 at $73,437.50; (Heritage 8/16), lot 3932 at $64,625.
5. AU53 NGC, some notable roughness at top half of the obverse. Harlan P. Smith (S.H. & H. Chapman, 5/1906, lot 124, graded EF, at a strong $130; William Sumner Appleton; Massachusetts Historical Society; ANA Sale (Stack's, 8/1976), lot 72; Baltimore Auction (Stack's Bowers, 10/2018) at $48,000, lot 7090; Dickson (Heritage 8/21), lot 3293, selling for $50,400. Yes, the slab grade is a bit higher than the Newman and Garrett coins above, but those are nicer in every respect, and do not have the rough obverse surfaces that this AU53 has.
6. XF. F.C.C. Boyd Estate; John J. Ford, Jr. (Stack's, 5/2004), lot 312, at $60,500. Oddly, Ford was able to find no previous provenance for this coin.
7. XF. Joseph Mickley (Woodward, 10/1867) at $90; Charles Ira Bushnell (S.H. & H. Chapman, 6/1882), lot 888, described as purple brown color and bringing $105 to Allison W. Jackman, but not included in the H. Chapman sale of that collection 6/1918; possibly traded away: we note that Jackman purchased the George Clinton cent the lot before this in the Bushnell sale as well, but the one sold in his collection was a private sale from Dr. Hall. Later in the Brand Collection. Only the obverse was photographed on the Bushnell auction plates, and the centering does not appear to match any of the above coins.
8. XF Details PCGS, the present coin, ex Ted Craige collection. Likely not the piece thought to be ex Norweb (see number 13 and 14 below). One can debate where in the census it ranks due to the details vs. straight grade. Sold in the Craige sale for $55,812.50.
9. VF30 PCGS. Alexander Bache (Woodward, 3/1865) described as very fine indeed, but little circulated, selling for $77.50; Heman Ely (Woodward, 1/1884), lot 1013 selling for $75. Peter Gschwend (collection purchased intact by William H. Woodin, then consigned for auction to Elder 6/1908), lot 87; F.C.C. Boyd Collection; Boyd Estate to New Netherlands Coin Company on April 25, 1958; John L. Roper (Stack's 12/83), lot 275; Americana sale (Stack's 1/98), lot 198; (Stack's 5/07), lot 521 (at $103,500!); Syd Martin (Stack's 3/23), lot 1083, at $36,000. The Ely plate shows only the obverse, but the centering and strike match.
10. VF20 PCGS John G. Mills Collection (Chapman Brothers, 4/1904), lot 348; John Story Jenks Collection (Henry Chapman, 12/1921), lot 5493; Donald Groves (Partrick) Sale (Stack's, 11/1974), lot 336; Henry P. Kendall Foundation (Stack's, 3/2015), lot 2511, at $58,750; Willis (Heritage 8/17), lot 3828, sold for $47,000. Earlier census listings erroneously called the Mills and Jenks listings different coins, but they are in fact the same.
11. VF details, very flawed planchet. Charles Clay (William Strobridge, 12/1871), lot 89, realizing $27. James Ten Eyck (B. Max Mehl, 5/1922), lot 816. Described as Struck on an imperfect planchet, obliterating LIBER NATUS on obverse, and part of Figure on reverse, otherwise Fine. Ford graded it Good, and said the coin was filed, not weakly struck on a flawed planchet; the surviving detail would likely grade VF today, and it appears the weakness is as struck; it brought $21 in 1922, but has not been seen since.
12. Fine, holed. Matthew Stickney (Henry Chapman, 6/1907), lot 240. Called Good. Bad hole below Indian's feet, it realized $10. The plate shows a coin of near VF detail, the hole quite large and near the lower rim, causing a bulge there. Later W. B. Guy (Henry Chapman, 11/1911), lot 75, realizing $7.50. The coin was later plugged, the bulging edge filed down, and tooled, strengthening some of the lettering at the left obverse; later in New Netherlands Coins 44th Sale (6/54, lot 71), graded VG, with the plug noted. In previous censuses this was called two different coins, but is indeed the same specimen.
13. VG. Henry Dittmer, lightly rough (Heritage 5/11), lot 3687, selling for $20,400. This or the following coin, is likely the piece that Ford said was part of the Norweb collection (called VG corroded), and not the Craige piece offered here, as was surmised in that catalogue – not even Ford would have called the Craige piece a VG!
14. VG8 PCGS (Heritage 8/22), lot 3861, sold for $25,200, later (Heritage 1/24), lot 4001, sold for $22,800 – no prior provenance noted, but could also be the ex-Norweb piece mentioned above.
15. Likely Good or so. Thomas Warner (S.H. & H., 6/1884, though erroneously listed in previous censuses as the Mrs. Warner sale of 7/1891), lot 2094. Graded Poor, word NATUS not visible. While a couple of the pieces listed above have NATUS weak, it is visible on all of them, so this likely represents an example that has not been seen in over a century.

There are also a couple coins that have not been firmly traced, but which are likely examples listed above, with these early links of their provenance chains now lost.

X1. Likely EF or better. McCoy (Woodward 5/1864), lot 1763, described as of extreme fineness, realizing $82.50, selling to Dunbar. Given the grade this may be the Mickley coin or any of the ones listed above it, save for Miss Banks's specimen.
X2. Unknown Grade. Jeremiah Colburn (W. Elliot Woodward, 5/1863), lot 2053. Described as not in fine condition, but good for so rare a colonial. It brought $30, just $5 less than what a decent Higley copper realized. This is probably the same coin that was offered in Woodward's sale of his own collection five months later (10/1863), lot 2627, where it was described as in ordinary or rather poor condition and realized $22. Likely offered again by Woodward (12/1865), lot 1732 where it was described as from the Haines collection; not in fine condition, but still a desirable piece), where it only brought $12; this is likely Ferguson Haines who may have purchased it at the second auction noted. Haines conducted a sale of his own collection in 1877, and consigned to other auctioneers in the 1880s and 1890s; he was married in June 1865 and one wonders if he needed to sell some coins to please his new bride, consigning the piece back to Woodward, but getting barely half what he paid for it two years earlier. This is likely one of the final three pieces listed above, though as it was unplated in any of these Woodward auctions, it is unknown which one.

A very rare coin in any condition, and one that is always in demand by advanced collectors – and, a perusal of the above detailed census list will show that many famous collectors of the past lacked it in any grade whatsoever. Amazingly, nine of the fifteen known examples have crossed the auction block in the last 20 years, a quantity coming up for sale in a short period of time that has not been matched since the 1865-1885 era. Rarities like this tend to get locked up in major collections, and are off the market for decades – and when one appears after a long dry spell, the bidding can be furious! Such was the case for this example, which brought under 10% less than the much nicer Ford coin, sold just nine years earlier – but it was also the only example offered at auction in that time, and that created great collector interest. Prices fell as a few more came out, but it will likely be some time before another example is offered – and if there is a long wait before that happens, the bidding will be furious. With more recent auction records of much lower-grade and rough specimens at over $20,000 (see coins 13 and 14 above), and a straight- graded VF at nearly $60,000 (coin 10), and a previous prices realized of over $55,000 for this exact coin, some lucky collector may get the bargain of the year at our price of only……

$20,000

In the PCGS slab as pictured.

59. "1781" (ca. 1820) North American Token. W-13980. Rarity-2. PCGS Graded AU-53, though really any grade up to MS63 would have been warranted. This is Syd Martin's example, the nicest that he was ever able to find = and he considered it a full Uncirculated pieces, as noted on his envelope which accompanies the coin. When sold as Lot 1272 of the 2023 C4 sale, this was catalogued by Stack's Bowers as:

Though dated 1781, the North American token is thought to actually date to the 1810-1820 period, as evidenced by ca.1820 Canadian tokens of similar design and fabric as well as punch linkage (discovered by Doug Winter, now known as a U.S. gold coin specialist) to Irish tokens from the second decade of the 19th century. Winter also theorized that the 1781 date commemorated Cornwallis' surrender at Yorktown, though we find this strange for a token whose chief circulation was in Canada, the land to which loyalists escaped the Revolution! This is a superior example of the type, with luster and golden-brown patina, and though graded AU-53, it compares favorably to examples in the AU-55 to AU-58 range.

Provenance: From the Sydney F. Martin Collection. Earlier ex the Lawrence R. Stack Collection, November 2006.

A common token, in decidedly uncommon condition. While neither grading service has certified a fully Uncirculated one, this and a few others known that have been graded AU do not show any actual wear, just a bit flatness of strike on the seated figure's head – detail which is never found fully struck up. The highest grade example slabbed is a PCGS AU58 that brought nearly $4,500 in a 2017 Heritage sale – and that piece was distinctly weaker than this one, which shows more detail in the seated figure's gown, and the hull and sails of the ship – certainly a candidate for regrading! An AU58 in brass, in the same firm's July 2006 auction brought a similar price and it too was far weaker than this specimen. The fact that Syd considered this a full Unc., and had the resources to upgrade if he saw a nicer one, speaks volumes. This is the finest North American token we have ever seen, and would comfortably fit into the finest colonial collection

$1,750

In the special Syd Martin PCGS holder as pictured, accompanied by Syd's original handwritten envelope where he calls this Unc., and the original round ticket from Larry Stack.

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
SUMMER 2024 ROSA AMERICANA FIXED PRICE LIST (https://www.coinbooks.org/v27/esylum_v27n30a21.html)

 

HERITAGE SHIPWRECK & TREASURE COINS SALE

Our August 19 Spotlight: Shipwreck & Treasure World Coins Showcase Auction is a captivating auction dedicated to the treasures salvaged from the depths of history. This showcase features an array of gold "Finger" bars and Rincón 2 and 4 Reales from the famed "Golden Fleece" shipwreck. Additionally, you will find various gold and silver issues recovered from the historic 1715 Fleet, along with a remarkable Tumbaga bar, detailed below. The auction also includes fascinating examples from Spanish and Dutch shipwrecks, offering collectors and enthusiasts a unique glimpse into the nautical past.

The Tumbaga bar referenced above is a quite curious example and one of a few extant lacking original assayer markers. At 3.88 lbs, it measures 236x62x15mm. It was salvaged from the "Tumbaga wreck" (c. 1528 off Grand Bahama Island), nicknamed after the vast amount of Tumbaga pieces recovered. The Tumbaga, a term learnt by Conquistadors in their first expeditions, were low-fineness, gold or silver ornate relics treasured by original American cultures. From idols to jewelry, mortuary masks to ceremonial ornaments, these were the first precious metal spoils looted by the Spaniards during their incursions into the continent. Though a few intricate and lavish pieces were brought back to Spain, most were crudely melted down — some theorizing they used the native's methods of casting — and swiftly shipped to the King.

The "Tumbaga Wreck" is from perhaps the oldest shipwreck treasure yet unearthed in the New World. Before the salvaging of the wreck, in the early 1990's, little to no study had been done regarding these early, important pieces. Douglas R. Armstrong was hired by Marex, the salvaging company, to conserve about 200 bars retrieved. Armstrong promptly realized how important the discovery was and took the opportunity to do a thorough study of this unprecedented group of bars. An extensive analysis of the stamps and purity of the pieces made it possible to better understand these archaic Numismatic items from the first European settlers to dare conquer the Americas.

Read more here

 

THE COLLECTION OF LUCIUS S. RUDER

Stack's Bowers Galleries is proud to present another superior selection from the Collection of Lucius S. Ruder in their August 2024 Global Showcase Auction. Lucius S. Ruder was born in Hamilton, Ohio, on September 18, 1901. A quiet, intellectual, punctilious businessman with deep ancestral roots in Butler County, Ohio, he was a director and part owner of the Cincinnati Sheet Metal and Roofing Company. Mr. Ruder was also active in banking circles acting as a director of The First National Bank of Hamilton, Ohio, and the Bank of Clearwater in Clearwater, Florida, where he established a home in the years following his volunteer service as a Lieutenant Colonel in the Air Force in World War II.

Paralleling his interests in history and economics, Mr. Ruder's numismatic activities began with the purchase of an extensive coin collection from the estate of Dr. Philip Holmes, a prominent Chicago surgeon and lifelong collector who had amassed the bulk of his collection in the 1920s. Mr. Ruder easily doubled the size and quality of this collection over the years unobtrusively drawing on multiple sources and broadening his interests to include Washington medals, tokens, and foreign coins.

Read more here

NOONAN'S OFFERS UNIQUE EDWARD VII GOLD RUPEE

The only known genuine Indian gold rupee coin bearing the uncrowned portrait of Edward VII is among the rare and unique Indian coins that will be offered by Noonans Mayfair on Tuesday and Wednesday, October 1 & 2, 2024. Estimated to fetch £15,000-20,000, the coin is from Part II of the Puddester Collection which is expected to fetch in the region of £750,000.

Peter Preston-Morley, Special Projects Director (Numismatics) at Noonans explained: We are very pleased to be offering the second part of the Puddester Collection which focuses on the Uniform Coinage of India 1835-1947, starting with East India Company rule from 1835, and then issues of the Government of India from 1858 until independence in 1947.

He continues: The Puddester collection is vast, and this is the second of nine auctions that Noonans will be staging over the next few years. Part One fetched a hammer price of £1,581,800 when it was sold in February 2023. Mr Puddester, who lives in Canada and started collecting in the 1970s, hopes that this and the succeeding auctions will encourage a new generation of enthusiasts to build their own collections within India and further afield.

Read more here

WAYNE'S NUMISMATIC DIARY: AUGUST 11, 2024, PART I

The big week finally arrived - the American Numismatic Association summer convention, a.k.a the World's Fair of Money®. A little game I play is to see who's the first old numismatic friend I encounter at the show. Often this happens when checking into my hotel, or even before leaving the airport. This year it took until I entered the bourse floor where my good old friend Pat McBride from Pittsburgh was set up in costume as Ben Franklin. I was in costume as a Taylor Swift concertgoer.

Read more here

THE MARITIME SILK ROAD

Read more here

MEDIEVAL COIN BROOCH FOUND IN FIELD

A silver coin minted by a French bishop in the 13th Century and transformed into a gilded brooch has turned up in a field in north Norfolk.

The discovery was made by a metal detectorist in a rural area south of Cromer and it depicts Enguerrand of Crequi, Bishop of Cambrai from 1273 to 1293.

Coin expert Adrian Marsden said turning French coins into brooches was fashionable during this period because "no native coins were as large".

Read more here

NEW ENGLAND THREEPENCE DISCOVERY

The 1652 New England threepence has been recognized as the single rarest colonial coin by American collectors since before the Civil War. With only one specimen known, locked away in the Massachusetts Historical Society since 1905, the unique NE threepence was utterly non-collectible. A second specimen, once in the Yale Cabinet, was stolen decades ago and never recovered. None have been in a private collection since the death of William Sumner Appleton in 1903, but collectors will have the opportunity to acquire a newly discovered specimen in the November 2024 Stack's Bowers Galleries auction.

Recently authenticated by PCGS and graded EF-45, this new coin is clearly the finest extant example, sharper than the holed Massachusetts Historical Society coin. It was initially discovered in an antique cabinet among a handful of other U.S. colonial coins in the Netherlands in 2016, though not actually identified as a NE threepence until 2020.

Lots of coins get called important, said Stacks Bowers Galleries' Director of Numismatic Americana, John Kraljevich. It's hard to imagine anything more important than the discovery of a famous rarity, part of the first series of American coins ever made, that actually allows a collector to own a previously unobtainable type.

Read more here

2024 PARIS OLYMPIC MEDALS NOT PURE

People have been left disillusioned after finding out the truth about the gold medal.

Short of maybe a Nobel Prize, an Olympic gold medal is perhaps one of the most instantly recognised and prestigious awards you can win.

Gold is the natural choice for first place, given gold's status as a precious metal.

The last few days have seen the news and social media awash with pictures of beaming athletes flushed with pride as they wear the hallowed award around their neck.

Read more here

2024 PARIS OLYMPIC MEDALS DETERIORATE

Diver Yasmin Harper, who claimed Britain's first medal of the Paris Olympics, has admitted that her bronze is already becoming discoloured.

Harper won bronze in the women's 3m synchronised springboard alongside Scarlett Mew Jensen. She competed again on Friday in the women's 3m springboard final, although without adding another medal to her collection.

Harper was then asked about the quality of the medals after a member of the USA skateboard team criticised the quality of them after his bronze started to deteriorate.

Read more here

2028 LOS ANGELES OLYMPICS HANDOVER MEDAL

The United States Mint announced today that Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass will present Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo with the official LA28 Handover Medallion designed and struck by the Mint to honor the closing ceremonies of the 2024 Paris Summer Olympic Games on August 11, as part of a tradition that honors the past while looking to the future.

A historic tradition during the closing ceremonies, the mayors of the host cities of the closing and upcoming Olympic Games join the International Olympic Committee Officials on stage, and the flag of the games is lowered and passed from mayor to mayor as a symbolic highlight.

Read more here

NEW ENGLAND'S GODFATHER OF COUNTERFEITING

The year was 1789 when an old man shoveled dirt onto two hefty barrels of silver, hidden away in a cave on the roaring banks of the Swift River in Massachusetts. He needed to bury his treasure, because he had procured it by means that were considered illegal and, at one point, mystical. This old man was Glazier Wheeler, once a blacksmith and engraver, but the town of Dana knew him as the alchemist. Wheeler spent his life practicing the art of converting base metals into silver through chemical reactions. By the late 1780s, his barrels were the culmination of a lifetime spent manipulating the silver content of coins. Wheeler's buried treasure engraved his name in the criminal history of New England as a godfather of counterfeiting.

Wheeler had a monomaniacal obsession with silver. He began his career as a respected metalworker in Newbury, New Hampshire, and developed a preoccupation with the belief that cheap metals, such as pewter and brass, could be transmuted into silver—in other words, alchemy. Alchemy had been around since the medieval era, and in the 1600s, the Puritan elite of Boston had been proudly obsessed with the process of alchemy as a spiritual exercise. But by the 1700s, it was becoming more scientific—alchemists were becoming chemists.

Read more here

POLICEMAN COUNTERFEITED 2 EURO COINS

A Macedonian policeman, arrested in Kosovo, is suspected of having produced around 2 million counterfeit coins of the 2-euro stamp, the European Union Agency for Cooperation in Criminal Justice (Eurojust) has said. Thousands of coins that were forged by his group ended up in Kosovo.

The 34-year-old policeman, instead of chasing counterfeiters and criminals, turned into a money counterfeiter. The person arrested, on August 4, in Pristina, is from Resnja, North Macedonia. He worked in the Macedonian Police department for fighting serious crimes and organized crime.

Read more here

LOOSE CHANGE: AUGUST 11, 2024

New Video of San Jose Artifacts

New artifacts have been found on the legendary Spanish galleon San Jose, Colombia's government announced Thursday, after the first robotic exploration of the three-century-old shipwreck.

Dubbed the "holy grail" of shipwrecks, the San Jose was owned by the Spanish crown when it was sunk by the British navy near Cartagena in 1708.

It said a robot surveyed the wreck, whose exact location has been kept secret since its discovery in 2015, between May 23 and June 1, covering an area "equivalent to more than 40 professional soccer fields."

The images reported had shown, among other things, cast iron cannons, porcelain pieces, pottery and objects apparently made of gold.

The ship had been heading back from the New World to the court of King Philip V of Spain, laden with treasures such as chests of emeralds and some 200 tons of gold coins.

To read the complete article, see:
New artifacts found in "holy grail" of shipwrecks that sank 3 centuries ago with billions of dollars in treasure (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/san-jose-shipwreck-colombia-new-artifacts-found-billions-treasure/)

Read more here