Doug Ward submitted these notes on lapel pins in general, and a discovery relating to the ANA pin Nick Graver asked about. Thanks!
-Editor
I did some digging into lapel pins. Seemingly, screw back pins were not commonly made until
the early 1900s. The earliest example I found seems to date to 1881 with another to 1892, so
it's conceivable Nick's pins date to the 1890s, although doubtful. Those early pins were made
by a company well known to numismatists, now and particularly in the early 1900s – Whitehead
& Hoag. Founded in 1881, they were early innovators in all-things pins. They were also the
premier maker of medals for early numismatics prior to 1959, including many for the ANA and
ANS. And they had significant ties to the US Mint at Philadelphia. They struck the Heath Medal,
the ANA's first, as well as numerous others. They were much better known to the early
numismatic community than any other pin makers would have been.
Whitehead & Hoag was determined to incorporate their logo onto most medals and pins, and
would charge more if it was excluded. For screw back pins, their logo was consistently located
on the back of the screw nut. Unfortunately, the nuts on the back of Nick Graver's pins were
removed decades ago, before he acquired them. This is probably why they became artifacts
rather than being sold or distributed and why they remained together as a group. The only
inscription on the back of the pins is the word "STERLING." That inscription also appears on the
edge of the Heath Medal, together with "WHITEHEAD – HOAG." Again, in my limited searching,
sterling silver was not commonly used to make screw back lapel pins and I found none similarly
labeled. Sterling silver was commonly used to make numismatic medals. Early pins were more
commonly made of brass, gilt brass and 10 or 14 carat gold.
Another prominent maker of lapel pins was Bastian Bros. Corp. of Rochester, NY, founded in
1895. They also made medals, but in letters to the ANS that ability was only introduced in 1919.
They were making and advertising lapel pins in the early 1900s. However, the earliest of their
screw back pins I was able to find date to the 1920s or 30s. Bastian Bros. was less consistent
with their logo placement, with some appearing on the pin back and others on the nut. Bastian
Bros. bought Whitehead & Hoag in 1959 and promptly destroyed its thorough manufacturing
records. They're still in business and I've asked them for possible information.
As David Fanning mentioned, the question of when Nick's pins were made remains unknown
and will until more information comes to light. Perhaps there is further information waiting to
be found in The Numismatist. I would think more of these pins exist than just the nine Nick's
had. They were made purposely and likely by an ANA member for an ANA event. Hopefully,
someone recognizes them or has one with a nut that will shed more light on their origin.
Also, I'm curious what David thinks the loop and wavy device below it represents, as part of the
ANA's lamp? The consensus is it's not a magnifying loop. Perhaps it is the lip of a vessel pouring
oil into the lamp? That would be consistent with the original seal's description. I believe the first appearance of the seal's design with the loop device and looped handle is in the January
1907 issue of The Numismatist. Nick's pins likely appeared sometime after that.
Hold the presses: I found a reference to Nick's pin in The Numismatist. It's described in the
August 1943 issue, page 641, in regard to the Chicago ANA convention:
"There are three buttons (new) also available, which may be worn on the lapel at any time: the
bronze and gold, 5/8 inch in diameter at 50 and 85 cents respectively, bearing the Association
seal, and a smaller silver button, 3/16 inch, at 70 cents, with the central portion of the seal and
the initials ANA. These are especially attractive, and may be had by members regardless of the
convention."
(Emphasis mine). Great discovery!
-Editor
Nick's silver pins are actually a little bigger than 3/8 inch in diameter or 11mm. There's no
image in The Numismatist article. That solves the mystery. Although, if anyone has one we
might yet find out who the manufacturer was. My money is on Whitehead & Hoag!
'81 screw back pin made by Whitehead & Hoag,
possibly in 1881. Courtesy of Worthpoint.
1892 dated screw back pin made by Whitehead & Hoag,
probably in 1892. Courtesy of Ebay.
American Legion screw back pin made by Bastian Bros. Co.,
probably made in the 1920's. Courtesy of Pinterest.
To read the earlier E-Sylum articles, see:
THE EARLY ANA PIN AND THE FIRST ANA SEAL
(https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n44a08.html)
NOTES FROM E-SYLUM READERS: NOVEMBER 8, 2026 : More on That Magnifying Glass
(https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n45a15.html)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|