The Numismatic Bibliomania Society

PREV ARTICLE       NEXT ARTICLE       FULL ISSUE       PREV FULL ISSUE      

V29 2026 INDEX       E-SYLUM ARCHIVE

The E-Sylum: Volume 29, Number 46, 2026, Article 16

TREASURE TALK WITH BOB EVANS, EPISODE 17

In January 2025, our good friend Bob Evans began publishing a series of blog articles on the Finest Known website detailing his experience as co-discoverer and curator of the treasures recovered from the wreck of the S.S. Central America. Subject of the book "Ship of Gold", many exhibits, countless interviews and articles, books and auction catalogs feature the legendary haul of gold coins, bars, nuggets, gold dust and more from the 1857 shipwreck. Here's another excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor

  Treasure Talk with Bob Evans, Part 17

I first became aware of the S.S. Central America and its treasure in 1983. Project founder Tommy Thompson shared with me the research he had begun, a file containing Xerox copies of microfilm of newspapers from 1857, much of it barely legible.

New York Times masthead September 23, 1857

Along with the stack of papers there were two rolled-up scrolls of poster-size white paper with a spreadsheet chart he called the "Data Correlation Matrix," a name that described its function, and so was more in tune with his engineering mind than just calling it a "spreadsheet." He liked to name things.

Thompson asked me, an underemployed 29-year-old geologist (also his neighbor,) to take over "The Matrix" and to put more information on it. This spreadsheet had vertical "columns" that represented individual survivor or witness accounts of the sinking and its aftermath. The accounts were entered into horizontal "rows" that represented three-hour time slots. Eventually, The Matrix was transcribed into a standard computerized spreadsheet, so the data could be shared with Dr. Larry Stone, an expert search theory mathematician.

I scoured the 1857 newspapers of cities connected to the SSCA story, starting with New York and the eastern seaboard, but expanding to San Francisco, as well as to the hometowns of certain passengers. I was looking to continue what had been started, a gleaning of the historical record for "critical path data," another of Thompson's terms that was also functionally accurate. Critical path data was anything that related to the physics of the final days of the SSCA, the two days leading up to the sinking, and the day following, when survivors were rescued by vessels who came upon the scene. Celestial coordinates were prime targets for the research. These were readings taken by mariners that gave the latitude, longitude and time for different moments during the saga. But other parts of the accounts mattered as well, with descriptions of the storm, the direction and strength of the wind, and the progressively deteriorating condition of the ship

I read the various accounts in detail, trying to find every bit of SSCA history that might reveal critical path data. Anyone who has attempted this kind of research in earnest knows that smallest details in the already small and fuzzy print can reveal important information. So, while my focus was on critical path data, my scrutiny of the fine print, word by hard-to-decipher word, drew me into the character of the age, and the characters that inhabited it. There were certain accounts that contained no information for The Matrix, but still framed the social and business context of the people who were on board.

See the complete article for the story of the ship's captain, Navy Commander William Lewis Herndon and his earlier expedition to Peru. -Editor

Commander William Lewis Herndon, USN Herndon's Exploration of the Valley of the Amazon
Herndon and his report to Congress

The California Gold Rush was a great human melting pot. Of course, most of the crew and passengers of the SSCA were Americans, from the northern and southern states, as well as some who already considered themselves Californians. There were also some Europeans, perhaps headed home, or maybe contemplating a new life in a fresh Land of Opportunity. Among others, there were prominent South Americans, with connections in Peru and elsewhere, their points of origin listed with their names, in newspaper charts of the saved and the lost.

It was logical that Peruvians were on board. Spain had engaged in maritime commerce with its South American colonies or former colonies for over three centuries. For much of that time, the influx of "Spanish" silver and gold was a cornerstone of the entire European economy.

The route from the South American mines to Spain ran to the Pacific coast, then by ship to Panama City, then over the isthmus to Portobelo, (near Colón,) the same part of the narrow isthmus later used by the Panama Railroad and the Canal. All of Panama had been a part of Nueva Granada, now Colombia, and it remained so until it seceded from Colombia (with U.S. backing) in 1903, and the Canal Zone was established.

Spanish colonial treasure shipments were not regularly scheduled. A treasure fleet would gather annually at Portobelo, along with sufficient firepower to fend off the English pirates. If more cover was necessary, they could assemble at Cartagena, a walled city with its heavily armed harbor on the main Caribbean coast of Colombia. The Spanish system of treasure fleets persisted for centuries.

By the time of the California Gold Rush, this pipeline of treasure had dwindled, and the former Spanish colonies were now independent nations. But they shared a common language, and many still traded with the former motherland. South American businessmen could take advantage of regularly scheduled steamships from Panama to New York. New York had regularly scheduled steamships to Spain and other parts of Europe.

Ocean-crossing steamships with regular schedules were a recent innovation. When the railroad was finished across Panama in 1855, the steamship route between New York and Aspinwall (now a part of Colón) settled into a standard pattern. On the fifth and twentieth of every month, a steamship would leave New York headed to the Caribbean coast of Panama. A corresponding steamer departed San Francisco on the same schedule destined for Panama City. The idea was to arrive on opposite coasts of Panama on the same day, and to make the transfer across the narrow land bridge by rail in a single day.

On the Atlantic leg of this arrangement, two steamships alternated in a sort of maritime dance, with one in Panama, filling with New-York-bound passengers, mail and gold, and the other in New York embarking the next group of hundreds of passengers, mail and business communications headed to California.

Steamship service from New York to various European ports was also very regular, more so than passage from Panama to those same ports. Gold destined for Europe instead of New York often shipped directly from the isthmus, to avoid a second charge for freight and insurance. That gold waited in Panama for a steamer with the right Old-World destination. But Europe-bound travelers could trim days off their journey by taking the Atlantic portion of the California to New York route. Plus, in the days of rampant tropical diseases, it was better to wait in New York than in Panama.

We could see this international character reflected in the hometowns or home countries appended to the names of the saved and the lost.

A "new" treasure:

In 1988, our project discovered the Central America and its commercial gold. The published list told us there should be more than two tons of gold in this shipment. At the end of the 1989 season we had recovered over one ton, bringing it ashore in Norfolk on October the 5th. (See Treasure Talk Episode 1.) The following summer, as the 1990 season progressed, it became apparent that the exposed treasure we had found, resting on the vestiges of the steamship's timbers in the stern, did not add up to two tons. We had developed 3-D visual technology that greatly speeded up our operations, and it also aided our ability to interpret and understand what we were seeing a great deal more than we could with flat imagery.

The Garden of Gold was spectacular, an exposed pile of degraded boxes and bags of gold, sitting close to the ship's rudder, on the portside of the stern. Corals and starfish and others had colonized this precious jumble, as if it was just another hard substrate.

SS Central America Garden of Gold

But the deposit stopped a little to the portside of the shipwreck's centerline, yielding abruptly to a scattered pile of coal and debris, with no gold. The starboard side of the shipwreck's stern was buried in sediment, a meter or more of that fluffy pteropod ooze I described in Treasure Talk Episode 5, Part 1. Considering the sharp truncation of the treasure deposit, and examining the 3-D images, I developed a theory that I proposed to test, over on the buried starboard side.

Our remotely operated vehicle (ROV) Nemo was outfitted with thrusters. These propellors could be used to navigate the ROV, but a thruster could also be mounted on the small backhoe that constituted the left arm of Nemo, so we could direct a strong current toward the seafloor we were working in front of our cameras and tools. We used this thruster to blow away sediment, exposing treasure and other features.

I wanted to use the prop-wash of the thruster to explore a little, to blow and see what we could expose. The images suggested that the SSCA had opened like an enormous book as it degraded, with the keel marking the hinge of the book's binding.

As the shipwreck collapsed over decades, the starboard side acted a little like a snow fence. Currents around the shipwreck drive the fluffy, shelly sediment along the bottom for a long time before it settles. The prevailing average current brought sediment across the collapsing starboard side, and deposited a thick cushion of ooze, like a big drift of snow. The thick drift didn't reach the collapsed portside, where the timbers were swept clean, and we found the treasure exposed and teeming with life.

I wondered if there was gold buried under the sediment on the starboard side, treasure that had separated from the portside deposit when the shipwreck splayed open. We were still finding and recovering some gold from the exposed portside deposit, so there was a little skepticism about my plan among my colleagues in the control room. But I strongly felt that a couple hours exploring the counterpart starboard area would be worth it. We had recovered the core of the "Garden," and results were diminishing.

Mike landed Nemo over a little to the starboard side of the line of the keel, aft of the thick blanket of sediment that covered where we thought we would find the stern. The thruster started blowing.

An enormous cloud resulted, as Nemo blew and blew. After a minute or two we couldn't see a thing. Still, Mike continued to direct the thrusters down at the dirt, feeling his way back and forth in a pattern, like hosing a fire through the smoke. After many minutes, he paused and we waited for the cloud to clear. It took close to an hour.

SS Central America corner of a gold ingot While the fog was dissipating, boredom was setting in, and my crewmates started to grumble. "What are we doing?" "Oh yeah… That's right… It's something Bob wanted to see." I could feel the impatience growing. They were accustomed to picking up gold, not cloud-gazing. Then I suggested that we zoom the cameras in on a tiny, bright point of light that was becoming clearer and brighter. An assay chip! The corner of a gold ingot!

The cameras zoomed out and the control room erupted with excitement. A huge pile of gold bars was exposed in the bottom of the pit we had just dug. Indeed, it was cause for celebration. We had found the top of another pile, the missing ton of gold.

the missing ton of SS Central America gold

Examining the extent and boundaries of this pile, we encountered another mystery. We were facing forward in ship orientation. Just in front of where Nemo landed, at the far stern of the deposit, we found a big pile of coins, but they didn't look like the piles of gold we were used to.

the mystery SS Central America silver

These were not double eagles, which had seen in great abundance. There was plenty of rust, as expected. But there was none of that golden shine, peeking through spots where the rust fell off. The coins were gray, and we quickly realized they must be silver. Our video camera could focus in on the features of individual coins and bars, so we zoomed in, trying to read the words on the grayish disks and figure out what they were.

SS Central America Chile silver coin closeup RAZON
"RAZON." What the heck does "razon" mean? The answer was revealed when we recovered a few specimens.
SS Central America Chile silver 50 centavos obverse SS Central America Chile silver 50 centavos reverse
1855 Chile silver 50 centavos
SS Central America Chile silver peso obverse SS Central America Chile silver peso reverse
1854 Chile silver peso

Aha! Coins from Chile! A South American connection!

There was a large pile of these coins, both 50 centavos and pesos from Chile. Remnants of a canvas bag clung to some of the coins, and it had branded others with a textile pattern shown in the toning.

Barry Schatz was Tommy's friend from their teenage years, a high school classmate from Defiance, a small county seat in far northwest Ohio. Barry was a skilled writer, so Thompson recruited him to become our company wordsmith and PR guy, writing the investor letters, interacting with the press.

For reasons I never understood, (maybe it was a girl he met,) Barry from Defiance, Ohio became fluent in Spanish and Portuguese. He sounded like a native speaker, with very little American accent, and he used to fake a Latino origin. If he flubbed his Spanish slightly in conversation, he would apologize and explain that he was Brazilian. He majored in Latin-American Studies at the University of Florida, and he hated Ohio weather.

Barry was ashore when word of the Chilean coins reached the home office. We received a message from him explaining that "Por la razon o la fuerza" translated as "By reason or by force" and that it was the Chilean national motto.

When I brought word of this translation into the control room, the guys laughed. With an American perspective on the brutal dictatorship of Augusto Pinochet, someone chuckled, "I guess things haven't changed much in Chile!" (Note: In 1990, things in Chile were in fact changing, as a democratically elected government was installed.) But a question remained. Why were there so many Chilean silver coins found amidst the commercial shipment's degraded boxes of gold ingots and coins? The answer was found in the grim chart of the lost, hundreds of names listed in the New York Herald on September 22, 1857.

SS Central America passenger record Pasqual Esquerra

Spanish names were frequently miscast or downright butchered by the typesetters of the day. This gentleman's name is variously rendered in print. I have seen "Parqual" and "Escuerdo" as examples. I have averaged the misspellings, applied some logic, and I have settled on "Pasqual Esquerra." From the Herald's list and others, we learn that he was a merchant in Valparaiso, who hailed from Spain. These bags of Chilean silver were his.

Why were they found with the commercial shipment? There could be two explanations. The bags of silver constituted quite a lot of weight, well over a hundred pounds. Señor Esquerra probably consigned it to Purser William Hull when he came aboard at Aspinwall. The Purser stored it with the other heavy, precious freight, the commercial shipment from California, which was loaded at the same time.

This interpretation is supported by the position of the Chilean coins, all the way in the stern of the deposit. Pasqual Esquerra purchased his ticket at Aspinwall on September 2, the day before the SSCA welcomed the New York bound passengers and gold shipment from California. The Chilean silver may have been the first treasure that was loaded, tucked away in the back of the gold room.

An alternative possibility is that these bags of silver became intermingled as the shipwreck degraded and collapsed. Esquerra could have stored his silver in his First-Class cabin, which may have been in the stern, directly above the gold room in the hold. When the decks collapsed it could have tumbled down to where we found it.

As with any new discovery, I found this one fascinating. After the dive when we first recovered it, I had a close look as I catalogued and stored this exotic silver in my lab. The coins were all affected by the 133 years in ocean water and they showed varying degrees of corrosion, not like the gleaming gold I had usually handled. Not surprising. These "seawater-affected" silver pesos and half pesos from Chile, dated 1853 to 1856, authenticate themselves as part of the SSCA treasure, and part of its story.

The Chilean silver was a complete surprise. When we began the S.S. Central America Project, we were looking for the greatest lost treasure in United States history. We were seeking California gold. We found it, but we also chanced into a large amount of South American silver.

It has been said that history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes. Sometimes the rhymes are not perfect, but they are subtle and ironic. Captain Herndon's story is such a case. In 1851, he was exploring the Andes and the Amazon on behalf of the United States, gathering data to see if there was a more efficient way to get South American silver to the world than shipping it over the mountains to the Pacific. This hypothetical new route proved impractical as a commercial enterprise, but his studies revealed the upper Amazon to the world. I'm sure this was not on his mind, but in 1857 on his final voyage, his ship carried silver that had been packed out of the Andes on the backs of llamas.

Bob Evans adds:

"This was a fun story to write. I have been thinking about this South American connection for decades (literally.) I distinctly remember musing about this subject over drinks (with Barry Schatz, mentioned in the article) in the early 90s. The American steamships servicing the Panama Route were of international utility and importance.

"But since these coins are "low-ball" specimens, seawater-affected silver coins from a shipwreck yielding tons of gold, I had not written about them at length until now. It's a great sidebar to the larger history."

Thank you - this is important and interesting numismatic history. -Editor

To read the complete article, see:
Treasure Talk 17: The South American Connection (https://finestknown.com/treasure-talk-17-the-south-american-connection/)

For the complete series, see:
Category Archives: Treasure Talk with Bob Evans (https://finestknown.com/treasure-talk-with-bob-evans/)

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
TREASURE TALK WITH BOB EVANS, EPISODE 16 (https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n44a13.html)

Kolbe-Fanning E-Sylum ad 2020-05-17

E-Sylum Northeast ad02 buying



Wayne Homren, Editor

Google
 
NBS (coinbooks.org) Web

The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.

To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address: whomren@gmail.com

To subscribe go to: Subscribe

PREV ARTICLE       NEXT ARTICLE       FULL ISSUE       PREV FULL ISSUE      

V29 2026 INDEX       E-SYLUM ARCHIVE

Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.

NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
coin