Stack's Bowers will be holding their next Showcase Auction November 16-25, 2026.. Select items are discussed below.
-Editor
Extremely Rare High-Relief Small Module Franklin
One of Five Recorded by Margolis 1777 B. Franklin Américain Portrait Medallion. Fur Cap without Spectacles. By Jean-Baptiste Nini. Margolis-11, Baiardi-Sibille 94, Greenslet GM-5, Storelli-LXII, Villers-Unlisted. Terracotta. 121.0 mm, approximately 9.4 mm at the edge. 264.0 grams. Obverse with incuse signature and date, NINI / F 1777 on truncation, left of coat of arms. B FRANKLIN AMERICAIN around, separated by five stops, with raised plain border. Small pellet in border at 12 o'clock, corresponding to a small fleur de lys impressed in the reverse inward from 10 o'clock. Made with a suspension hole from the top edge through to the back, as typical.
Oblique edges finished in a fairly pronounced but thin bevel around the reverse rim. Handsome light orange-brown terracotta is uniform in tone across the entire face. Sharply defined with a uniformly smooth surface texture typical of Nini originals. A small obverse edge chip is noted just past 2 o'clock affecting only the outer border, while the reverse is free of any such impairment. Rare, and nicer than most seen of these earlier high-relief types.
Small-diameter medallions in higher relief like this are believed to predate the lower-relief designs that saw wider distribution. There are multiple variants, yet all are very rare and command significant premiums over the more widely distributed Margolis-17 type, in low relief. In Margolis' detailed study, he located only five of this variety, including this, discovered in a secondary find of his holdings (along with the M-17 in the sale), explaining why it was not included in the primary offering of his Nini medallions in our Spring 2024 sale. Others were noted at the Musee des Beaux-Arts, Blois, France; the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University and in another private collection, the latter example curiously missing its reverse fleur de lys. A direct comparison with an example of Margolis-10, this same type but without the obverse pellet at 12 o'clock and fleur de lys, reveals that they were made with precisely the same mold. If this is true of all Margolis-10 and 11 medallions, then they are numbered in exactly the sequence of production - all bearing the pellet, an addition to the mold, were made after all those without it.
Provenance: From the Richard Margolis Collection. Earlier from our (Stack's) Americana Sale of January 2009, lot 5657.
To read the complete item description, see:
Extremely Rare High-Relief Small Module Franklin
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XJYW3/1777-b-franklin-amricain-portrait-medallion-fur-cap-without-spectacles-by-jean-baptiste-nini-margolis-11-baiardi-sibille-94-green)
1824 Lafayette Visit Medalet. Musante GW-112, Baker-198A, Fuld-LA.1824.12. Silver. VF Details--Bent (PCGS). 14.0 mm. The loop is almost always missing from tokens of this type, as here. Handsome olive-gray patina overall, both sides with universally bold detail at the assigned grade level. The vintage and purpose of these medalets are undisputed. They were struck to mark the occasion of the Marquis de Lafayette's return to the United States for an American tour in 1824. He arrived on August 15 and across the following 14 months, he visited each of the States of the Union where he was met with all manner of fanfare, from the casual donning of thematic gloves, badges, belts, combs, chains, socks, silks and anything else one might imagine, to more formal engagements such as visits to Mount Vernon. Though a French National, he was arguably the second greatest celebrity in the United States, with only George Washington ahead of him.
The matter of who made these medalets presents quite the opposite situation. For most of the last 199 years, these medalets have been attributed to Charles Cushing Wright, though a proposal in 2008 that they were made by a Joseph Lewis seems to have stuck quickly. This is not a proper attribution, however, and we discussed this in some depth in our offering of the Sydney F. Martin Collection specimen in our Winter 2022 sale, lot 2128.
Despite the lingering questions, these medalets have long been prized for their unique historic significance marking Lafayette's American tour. They are quite rare today. Our online archives include about a dozen different examples sold over the last 15 years or so, while Heritage seems to have sold only a couple. Even the ANS Collection seems to be missing the type.
Provenance: From Presidential Coin and Antique Co., Inc.'s Auction Eighty-One, June 2011, lot 226.
To read the complete item description, see:
1824 Lafayette Visit Medalet. Musante GW-112, Baker-198A, Fuld-LA.1824.12. Silver. VF Details--Bent (PCGS).
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XJZ32/1824-lafayette-visit-medalet-musante-gw-112-baker-198a-fuld-la182412-silver-vf-details-bent-pcgs)
Lovely Oak Tree Twopence
Ex Richard Picker 1662 Oak Tree Twopence. Noe-33, Salmon 1-B, W-240. Rarity-5. Large 2. EF-40 (PCGS). 10.5 grains. Cataloged as Noe-34 in our (Stack's) October 1984 Picker Collection sale, although the reverse crack through the tops of the digits 166 in the date and to the left is not present, and your current cataloger (JLA) believes this is more accurately attributed as Noe-33. Perfectly struck and centered with all details on the planchet and boldly to sharply rendered. Some honest even wear, but no post-production blemishes of note. Richly toned and original with glints of antique gold and crimson-red to dominant steel gray. An impressive numismatic provenance further enhances the desirability of this choice Large 2 Oak Tree twopence.
Provenance: From the Emerald Coast Collection. Earlier from our (Stack's) sale of Selections from the Richard Picker Collection of Colonial & Early American Coins, October 1984, lot 19.
To read the complete item description, see:
Lovely Oak Tree Twopence
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XJZLW/1662-oak-tree-twopence-noe-33-salmon-1-b-w-240-rarity-5-large-2-ef-40-pcgs)
Impressive Original American Plantations Token
Undated (1688) American Plantations Token, or 1/24 Part Real. Original. Newman 2-B, W-1135. Rarity-5+. 7 Harp Strings. MS-64 (NGC). From our November 2020 offering of the E Pluribus Unum Collection, where it was described as:
A good deal of silvery luster persists across attractive medium gray surfaces, tinted with a bit of gold. Hints of green are seen on both sides. Sharp and fairly even in appearance, though the rims have begun to crumble a bit and tinpest has attacked the crown above the Hibernian shield. A circular pit on the horse's forequarters is noted as an identifier, but this piece is largely free of the tinpest corrosion that plagues these pieces. Good sharpness and eye appeal, a better than usual example of this historic early tin coinage. This stands as the single finest original American Plantation token ever certified by NGC. PCGS has never graded one finer than MS-63.
Provenance: From the Winslet Collection. Earlier from our sale of the E Pluribus Unum Collection, Part II, November 2020 Auction, lot 4038.
To read the complete item description, see:
Impressive Original American Plantations Token
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XK2UM/undated-1688-american-plantations-token-or-124-part-real-original-newman-2-b-w-1135-rarity-5-7-harp-strings-ms-64-ngc)
Lovely Mint State (1722) Rosa Americana Twopence
From the Nelson, Boyd, and Ford Collections Undated (1722) Rosa Americana Twopence. Martin 2.1-B.1, W-1322. Rarity-3. Motto in Ribbon. MS-63 (NGC). A beautiful and original example, with abundant golden surface mellowed in areas to chestnut brown. Glossy and free of any significant marks or flaws, just the occasional natural planchet pit and a little spot over the last letter A in AMERICANA. The reverse is lightly double struck, but detail on both sides is exceptionally strong. The look of this coin is simply superb, and it's difficult to imagine an example with better aesthetics at this grade level. The provenance is also about as impressive as one could ever hope for on a Rosa Americana twopence, extending back over a century to the collection of the man who wrote the first long-used reference on the series.
Provenance: From the Winslet Collection. Earlier ex Philip Nelson; F.C.C. Boyd, December 1913; Boyd estate; John J. Ford, Jr.; our (Stack's) sale of the John J. Ford, Jr. Collection, Part IX, May 2005, lot 86.
To read the complete item description, see:
Lovely Mint State (1722) Rosa Americana Twopence
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XK2VV/undated-1722-rosa-americana-twopence-martin-21-b1-w-1322-rarity-3-motto-in-ribbon-ms-63-ngc)
Important Mint State Long Worm 1783 Chalmers Shilling
The Only Chalmers Shilling Ever Certified as Mint State by PCGS 1783 John Chalmers Shilling. W-1790. Rarity-4. Birds, Long Worm. MS-62 (NGC). A superb example of this classic American type, struck in Annapolis when it served as the home of the Continental Congress and, thus, served as the U.S. capital at the time. Striking variations impact the quality of Chalmers shillings as much as pure grade considerations, and this piece ranks with the finest Long Worn shillings known on both fronts. Both sides show frosty luster and lovely originality, with medium silver gray surfaces toned in lightly gold shades across both sides. The obverse is ideally centered, with the thick denticles surrounding the entire circumference. The entire length of the denticles are visible in the southeast quadrant of that side, while they are truncated at the northwest quadrant, where the planchet is trivially out of round. The usual axial misalignment is milder here than often seen, though the right side of the obverse is more deeply struck than the left. The depth of that impression shows the full rounded relief of the birds, the snake, and the legends; it also shows that the snake and birds are essentially free of internal detail. The reverse is aligned to roughly 1 o'clock, with ANNAPOLIS around the top above the handshake. A substantial unstruck area is seen outside the denticles at the base of that side. The legends are complete and bold despite the absence of the denticles across the top of that side. A thin planchet striation, as often seen on these, crosses the reverse, extending from the comma after CHALMERS to below the letters CH of that word. A pair of more subtle striations are seen at the central reverse as well. No significant post-striking flaws are seen: no digs, no scratches, no evidence of poor handling. The aesthetic appeal is immense, which is no less a testament to this coin's quality because it also has a high technical grade. This issue doesn't often survive choice or beautiful. This one breaks that pattern.
This coin, last sold by us 15 years ago, remains the only certified Mint State Long Worm we have ever handled. We've sold just three others certified as AU, one each graded 55, 53, and 50, and we've sold nothing better than AU-50 since 2017. Further, it's the only Chalmers shilling of any variety that PCGS has ever graded as Mint State, making this a prime target for connoisseurs of Confederation-era rarities. This piece was certified as PCGS/CAC MS-62 when we last offered it in 2011, and it remains the featured plate at PCGS CoinFacts
John Chalmers was a well regarded silversmith in Annapolis when he made the decision to coin his own small change coins out of melted down cut pistareens, which then made up a substantial proportion of the circulating medium in the Chesapeake region. Pistareens were first imported into the region in huge numbers in 1755, when General Edward Braddock ordered £4,000 to £5,000 worth of the lower fineness 2 reales made at Spain's mainland mints. Braddock was in Williamsburg, Virginia when he asked for them and Alexandria, Virginia when he received them. The coins, whose central cross made them easy to cut into halves (worth 10 cents) and quarters (5 cents), quickly spread throughout the region. Braddock first saw their utility while stationed in Gibraltar in 1753 and 1754. By 1784, when Jefferson wrote his Notes on Coinage, he described them - with his usual perspective that places Virginia as the center of the world - as a coin "perfectly familiar to us all." Not coincidentally, Jefferson wrote his Notes on Coinage while he was a Congressional delegate in Annapolis between March and May of 1784. At that time, the Chalmers workshop and mint was in sight of the State House, just two blocks up Cornhill Street from Chalmers' front door. Jefferson and his fellow delegates undoubtedly encountered these Chalmers coins in the temporary capital of the United States. When Washington resigned his commission in the State House chambers on December 22, 1783, he may well have had a Chalmers shilling or two in his pocket.
With its distinctive designs, accomplished by engraved Thomas Sparrow, the Chalmers shillings have always been a standout in an advanced cabinet of early American coins. This superlative survivor is perhaps the Chalmers non pareil, fit for a world class collection.
Provenance: From the Winslet Collection. Earlier, acquired privately from Don Taxay in the 1970s; Howard Collection; our Chicago ANA Auction of August 2011, lot 7170, as PCGS/CAC MS-62, where it realized $63,250. Featured at PCGS CoinFacts.
To read the complete item description, see:
Important Mint State Long Worm 1783 Chalmers Shilling
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XK2Z7/1783-john-chalmers-shilling-w-1790-rarity-4-birds-long-worm-ms-62-ngc)
The Exceptional Boyd-Ford Theatre at New York Token
Undated (ca. 1797) Theatre at New York Token. W-9080. Rarity-6. MS-65 RB (NGC). A superb example of this popular late 18th century token rarity, one struck in England but depicting the Park Theatre in New York City as it was in 1797. We last offered this piece in our 2004 Ford II sale, where it was described as:
A really lovely example of this popular Conder token. The obverse shows about 50% of the original mint red around the theatre building and the periphery while the reverse has traces of mint color in the protected areas. Elsewhere, the obverse is a light brown while the reverse is darker in the center. Nice and sharp, with the brickwork inside the arches on the theatre building showing clearly, the eagle on the pediment bold and the gunports of the vessels in the distance on the reverse quite clear. Struck from a fairly early state of the reverse, the die quite clearly buckled on the right and sinking, but FLOURISH still fully legible and the surface not raised very high. Since that time, this piece has remained atop the NGC Census and tied for finest on the PCGS Population Report. The Syd Martin Proof-64+ BN (PCGS) is the only example we've sold in the last seven years. This appears to be the first auction appearance for an example in this lofty grade.
The Theatre at New York token has been popular in American circles for a long time. The American Journal of Numismatics, April 1868, noted, "This rare and interesting token represents the Park Theatre, destroyed by fire May 25, 1820, but afterwards rebuilt in a style somewhat different from that of the building exhibited on the coin."
The cornerstone was laid on May 5, 1795, on Chatham Row, New York City. At first called the New Theatre, the facility officially opened on Monday, January 29, 1798. Featured was Shakespeare's As You Like It, preceded by an address by Mr. Hodgkinson and a prelude by Mr. Milne, and followed by "Purse, or American Tar," a musical entertainment. Up to about 2,300 people could be seated. In 1806 the building was sold to John Jacob Astor and John K. Beekman for $50,000. They were the owners at the time of the fire.
This token was probably issued in 1798, when passion in England for collecting Conder tokens was fading rapidly. The dies were executed by Benjamin Jacob, a Birmingham engraver, auctioneer, and ironmonger. Coining was accomplished at a factory operated by Peter Skidmore, in partnership with his father John, at 15 Coppice Row, Clerkenwell, London from 1797 to 1809. The penny size is unusual in the context of Conder-style tokens and was part of a series of Skidmore issues of this format, illustrating various buildings. About 20 of these are known, most in fairly high grades as they were not intended to circulate. This one is unquestionably several steps above a typical survivor.
Provenance: From the Winslet Collection. Earlier ex F.C.C. Boyd collection; Boyd estate; John J. Ford, Jr.; our (Stack's) sale of the John J. Ford, Jr. Collection, Part II, May 2004, lot 327.
To read the complete item description, see:
The Exceptional Boyd-Ford Theatre at New York Token
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XK4BK/undated-ca-1797-theatre-at-new-york-token-w-9080-rarity-6-ms-65-rb-ngc)
Beautiful Gem (1795) Liberty and Security Penny
Undated (1795) Washington Liberty and Security Penny. Musante GW-45, Baker-30, W-11050. Copper. ASYLUM Edge. MS-66 BN (NGC). A superlative example of this important early American type, alone atop the NGC Census and unsurpassed at PCGS or in our experience as well. Rich light brown surfaces glow with luster, gently faded down from mint color. Some traces of red persist, especially at the peripheries, but the whole look of this coin is one that was allowed to simply mellow from bright red to its fixed and beautiful brown shade. The strike is superb, with full detail on even the often-soft central reverse. The fields and devices are essentially immaculate, with only a little mark below the epaulet worth noting. This piece is choice to the point of being nearly flawless. The edge lettering is bold, applied after striking (as typical) and thus leaving some impact on the rims. This was chosen for inclusion in the Partrick Collection and the Winslet Collection for good reason: it's almost impossible to imagine a better one.
This type, unlike so many of the Washington portrait pieces of this era, actually saw American pockets. Examples have been found, often very well worn, by metal detectorists in the United States. This adds an important layer of desirability that some related issues cannot claim.
Provenance: From the Winslet Collection. Earlier ex Robert Vlack; Donald G. Partrick; Heritage's sale of the Donald G. Partrick Collection, March 2021, lot 15432.
To read the complete item description, see:
Beautiful Gem (1795) Liberty and Security Penny
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XK4CJ/undated-1795-washington-liberty-and-security-penny-musante-gw-45-baker-30-w-11050-copper-asylum-edge-ms-66-bn-ngc)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|