Stack's Bowers will be holding their next Showcase Auction Rarities Night on November 17, 2026. Select items are discussed below.
-Editor
Unique and Intriguing 1912 Pattern Quarter Dollar Electrotrial By James Earle Fraser, of Buffalo Nickel Fame
Judd-C1912-3 1912 Pattern Quarter Dollar. Uniface Obverse Electrotrial. Design by James Earle Fraser. Judd-C1912-3, Pollock-5175. Rarity-8+. White Metal. Plain Edge. Genuine (PCGS). Liberty head left, similar in some respects to that by Charles E. Barber seen on the regular issue Liberty Head nickel of 1883 to 1913, but less refined. Thirteen stars encircle the periphery, and the date 1912 is below. Several adjustment marks or similar as-made features on seen on the blank reverse. Both sides with uniform pewter gray color, and essentially as made.
This obverse electrotrial is privately made, by James Earle Fraser, who is best known among today's collectors as designer of the Buffalo nickel, 1913 to 1938. As reported when we (as Bowers and Ruddy) offered this piece in our July 1981 sale:
No pattern coins made from this design. Researcher William S. Nawrocki claims to have found an obscure reference in the Fraser files, of this as the design for a silver dollar. No plasters of this design in the Lepczyk sale. It is believed unique, and this is the plate coin for the type in both the Judd (10th edition) and Pollock (1994) references on pattern and related coinage, pp. 319 and 442, respectively, and is also plated on the uspatterns.com website. An intriguing piece for the advanced collector of Fraser's extensive and much-admired work.
Provenance: From the Charles "Cheech" Litman Collection. Earlier ex James Earle and Laura Gardin Fraser estate; Fred Weinberg, Numismatics Ltd.; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) William R. Sieck Collection sale, July 1981, lot 2424; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) Michael Steig Collection sale, September 1982, lot 1813; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) Rare Coin Review, No. 44, 1982, p. 9; Dave Berg Rare Coin Investments, Ltd. The plate coin for the type in both the Judd (10th edition) and Pollock (1994) references on pattern and related coinage, pp. 319 and 442, respectively, and is also plated on the uspatterns.com website.
To read the complete item description, see:
Unique and Intriguing 1912 Pattern Quarter Dollar Electrotrial By James Earle Fraser, of Buffalo Nickel Fame
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFKAV/1912-pattern-quarter-dollar-uniface-obverse-electrotrial-design-by-james-earle-fraser-judd-c1912-3-pollock-5175-rarity-8-white-me)
Condition Census 1795 Draped Bust Dollar
BB-51 Off-Center Bust Variety 1795 Draped Bust Silver Dollar. BB-51, B-14. Rarity-1. Off-Center Bust. MS-64+ (PCGS). A truly memorable example that ranks high in the Condition Census for the Off-Center Bust variety of the popular first year 1795 Draped Bust dollar. Both sides display warm pearl gray patina with splashes of iridescent rose-russet, pinkish-apricot and, to a lesser extent, cobalt blue toning. The surfaces are also awash in full frosty mint luster. The obverse exhibits a concentration of adjustment marks from the border at the letters LIB in LIBERTY into Liberty's hair. Fainter adjustment marks are found along the obverse border from 12 to 3 o'clock, although the reverse is free of these. Adjustment marks are as made and were commonly used by early U.S. Mint employees to bring overweight silver and gold planchets down to the statutory level. The presence of these features has resulted in somewhat soft striking detail at stars 11 to 12 and the letters LIB in LIBERTY, but otherwise we note impressively sharp definition throughout much of the design. Liberty's portrait and the eagle are particularly well executed with even most of the intricate design elements crisp. A beautiful and exceptionally well preserved example that will delight both high grade type collectors and advanced early dollar enthusiasts.
Two different die combinations were used for the 1795 Draped Bust dollar. The die pair believed to have been struck first is the so-called Off-Center Bust variety, BB-51, which features Liberty appearing too far to the left from the center, a position used only on this die pair. This positioning was corrected to a more aesthetically pleasing centered location on the second variety, the BB-52 pair. The precise number struck and timing of each variety is unclear. Mint records from the time are not as thorough as scholars would like and much of what can be determined is conjecture. The commonly cited mintage figure of 42,738 is believed to be only a portion of the overall total for the 1795 Draped Bust dollar. Writing in his excellent 2022 reference Eagle Poised on a Bank of Clouds Harry E. Salyards estimates that 83,178 coins were produced of both BB-51 and BB-52, and that while the first deliveries almost certainly took place in late September or early October, the later deliveries likely extended into 1796.
BB-51 is the more plentiful of the two die marriages of this issue, and Salyards suggests that 725 to 1,200 coins are extant in all grades. With the typical survivor grading VF, however, even EF and AU coins are scarce in an absolute sense, and rare relative to the demand for them in today's numismatic hobby. Mint State examples are rare by any measure. This is among our most significant offerings for both the issue and variety of all time, and it is sure to see spirited competition when bidding opens.
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family. Earlier from our (Bowers and Ruddy's) Newport Collection sale, January 1975, lot 375; our (Bowers and Merena's) Four Landmark Collections sale, March 1989, lot 1943; our (Bowers and Merena's) Collections of R.H. Gore, Jr. & Dennis Irving Long sale, January 1990, lot 345; Ira & Larry Goldberg's sale of February 2002, lot 3204; Heritage's sale of the Jack Lee Collection, III, November 2005 Dallas, TX Signature Auction, lot 2187; our sale of the Larry H. Miller Collection, December 2020 Auction, lot 1091.
To read the complete item description, see:
Condition Census 1795 Draped Bust Dollar
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFKVM/1795-draped-bust-silver-dollar-bb-51-b-14-rarity-1-off-center-bust-ms-64-pcgs)
Rare Mint State 1872-CC Liberty Seated Dollar
Ex Bareford Numismatic Provenance to 1950
1872-CC Liberty Seated Silver Dollar. OC-1. Rarity-3+. MS-61 (PCGS). As one of the few Uncirculated survivors of this elusive Carson City Mint issue, this coin stands tall among our extensive Liberty Seated dollar offerings through the years. Predominantly bright silver gray in appearance, both sides also reveal blushes of vivid cobalt blue and reddish-gold iridescence at the borders. The strike is well executed with bold to sharp detail over most design elements. Glossy in texture also lightly hairlined to confirm a long-ago cleaning, although the in-hand appearance is attractive with no sizeable marks to distract the unaided eye.
The Carson City Mint produced only 3,150 silver dollars in 1872. Repeating a standard scenario for early gold and silver issues from this coinage facility, the 1872-CC dollars were routinely released into local and regional commerce. Probably some were eventually shipped to China, where there was a great appetite for silver metal. Writing in his 2020 reference The Confident Carson City Coin Collector, CC-Mint expert Rusty Goe estimates that 250 to 300 exist today in all grades. A similar estimate by Dick Osburn and Brian Cushing (2018) suggest just 250 surviving pieces in total. The latter acknowledge a small hoard of about 100 examples having been distributed in 2015 through 2017, though in general market appearances for straight-graded EF and AU examples tend to be few and far between. For Mint State survivors they are even fewer, not surprising since Rusty Goe asserts that only 17 to 20 coins are extant at this level. Advanced specialists in Liberty Seated dollars and Carson City Mint coinage would be wise to take full advantage of this significant opportunity.
Provenance: From Numismatic Gallery's sale of February 1950, lot 163; our (Stack's) sale of the Harold L. Bareford Collection, October 1981, lot 430.
To read the complete item description, see:
Rare Mint State 1872-CC Liberty Seated Dollar
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFL1L/1872-cc-liberty-seated-silver-dollar-oc-1-rarity-3-ms-61-pcgs)
Exquisite Superb Deep Cameo Proof 1895 Silver Dollar
The "King of the Morgan Dollars" 1895 Morgan Silver Dollar. JD-3. Rarity-4. Proof-67 Deep Cameo (PCGS). This extremely beautiful 1895 Morgan dollar should be seen to be fully appreciated. The obverse is untoned and presents sharp contrast between satiny devices and deeply mirrored fields. Deep Cameo contrast is also noted for the reverse, where there is also delicate pale silver and gold iridescent toning toward the left border. The detail is razor sharp throughout, smooth and the virtually pristine surfaces will please even the most discerning Morgan dollar enthusiast.
The alleged sole Proof-only issue in the popular Morgan silver dollar series, the Philadelphia Mint 1895 has long enjoyed legendary status. Early generations of collectors were puzzled by an entry in Mint records that showed a circulation strike delivery of 12,000 coins for this year, and many theories arose to explain why the only 1895-dated examples found were believed to be survivors of the year's 880-piece Proof issue. Some said the circulation strikes were never made at all and the 12,000-piece figure represented a bookkeeping error. Others suggest that the 12,000-coin mintage reported for 1895 represents an adjustment to the Mint's ledgers to account for a final delivery of 1894-dated silver dollars. Modern numismatic scholarship has not only challenged these traditional theories, but overturned them, in the process going a long way toward finally solving the mystery of the 1895 Philadelphia Mint Morgan dollar issue.
In an article titled "King of Morgan Dollars Revisited" (2006, 2018), Roger W. Burdette provides conclusive evidence from available government documents that, indeed, the Philadelphia Mint did produce 12,000 circulation strike Morgan dollars from 1895-dated dies. This conclusion is picked up and expanded upon by John W. Dannreuther in the 2025 volume in his United States Proof Coins reference series:
The explanation lies in the retirement of Chief Coiner William S. Steele on May 31 and his planchets-on-hand problem. All 1894 proof and working dies were destroyed per the 1873 coinage act (and subsequent "Section 3550 Revised Statutes") at the beginning of 1895 (on January 2, 1895 per the Mint die use and destruction document). When the order was issued that no circulation strikes were to be struck in Philadelphia, the coiner had a problem. Coiner Steele still had 13,000 unstruck dollar planchets on hand. To balance his books before he left his position, proof dies were prepared and the coins were struck with proof dies - there were no working dies... - thus, proof-only dies struck the on-hand planchets. One can assume he did not disobey the order not to strike circulation strike dollars, as these were technically "Proofs." Only 12,000 coins were of deliverable quality of the 13,000 presumedly struck and they went through the normal channels prescribed by the 1873 coinage act.
Indeed, six of the circulation strikes were provided to the Assay Commission (along with four of the Proof 1895 dollars). Since there are upward of 300 circulated 1895 Philadelphia Mint Morgan dollars extant, and neither the Mint nor contemporary collectors would have deliberately disposed of that many Proofs by placing them into circulation, it is likely that somewhere between half a bag and two full 1,000-coin bags of circulation strike 1895 Philadelphia Mint dollars were released into commerce through normal channels. The balance of the 12,000-piece circulation strike mintage is presumed to have been destroyed as part of the 270,232,722 silver dollars melted under provision of the Pittman Silver Purchase Act of 1918. Dannreuther also takes up the challenge as to what to call these circulation strike 1895 Morgan dollars struck from Proof dies - a situation that he believes is unique in American numismatics. Since the 25 trade dollars struck in 1874 from polished working dies (JD-2, No Period) have been classified as "Semi-Proofs" by Dannreuther, and certified as Specimens by PCGS, the author whimsically proposes the term "semi-circulation strikes" for the circulation strike 1895 silver dollars struck from Proof dies.
Of the four die marriages confirmed for the 1895 Morgan dollar, JD-1 and JD-2 account for the vast majority of survivors. They are believed to have struck the 790 Proofs delivered for distribution in the year's Proof sets, as well as most of the "semi-circulation strikes" that were released into commercial channels and account for the majority of circulated survivors. JD-3 (as here) and JD-4 are significantly scarcer and, according to Dannreuther, "may constitute the 90 coins delivered in September with the 790 Proofs for sets mostly comprised of the first two varieties [JD-1 and JD-2]."
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family. Earlier from our sale of the Blue Moon Collection, Part I, March 2017 Baltimore Auction, lot 2617.
To read the complete item description, see:
Exquisite Superb Deep Cameo Proof 1895 Silver Dollar
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFL5J/1895-morgan-silver-dollar-jd-3-rarity-4-proof-67-deep-cameo-pcgs)
Landmark Rarity 1885 Trade Dollar
Only Five Examples Known The Olsen-French Specimen
1885 Trade Dollar. JD-1, JK-1. Rarity-7+. Proof-63+ (PCGS). CAC. Both sides of this legendary rarity in the trade dollar series are dusted with iridescent antique silver toning. A few blushes of slightly warmer sandy-rose tinting are evident, mostly around the obverse periphery and over the lower right reverse. That side of the coin is fully struck with razor sharp detail from the rim to the center, and every one of the eagle's feathers is crisply delineated. The obverse is fully defined overall with a touch of softness confined to stars 5 and 6, which lack radial lines. The top of Liberty's head and the tip of the coronet are also a bit lightly struck, but we stress that most Proof 1885 trade dollars are softly struck to one degree or another along the upper obverse border. This coin is more sharply struck than the Eliasberg specimen, which is soft from stars 5 to 10. Carefully preserved surfaces approach Choice Proof quality and offer plenty of visual appeal.
The 1885 trade dollar is one of the greatest of all American numismatic classics, with a ranking of 15 in the popular and influential book 100 Greatest U.S. Coins (5th Edition, 2019) by Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth. The 1885 trade dollar is rarer than the 1787 Brasher doubloon (seven known), is about three times rarer than the 1804 dollar (16 known), is tied with the 1913 Liberty Head nickel (five known), and is nearly on a par with the 1822 half eagle (three known). It is significant to note that neither the Smithsonian Institution nor the American Numismatic Society, possessors of two of the finest cabinets of American coins ever assembled, have either an 1884 or an 1885 trade dollar. Nor does the American Numismatic Association have one. The same can be said for virtually every other collection in existence, public or private, for apart from the piece offered here, just four coins are believed to exist.
Some of the following historical information on the 1885 trade dollar is excerpted and updated from Q. David Bowers' 1997 cataloging of the Eliasberg specimen, incorporating the latest scholarship on this issue.
History of the 1885 Trade Dollar In certain ways the story of the 1885 trade dollar parallels that of the 1884, although with several differences. For starters, the 1885 is twice as rare, and considering that aspect, has appeared on the market less often than the mintage of five coins would suggest. Most of America's truly great collections lacked an example, and today, as noted, the great museums have no 1885 trade dollars either.
The 1885 trade dollar is not mentioned in the Annual Report of the Director of the Mint for that year. Additionally, while the "Die Record Book," a notebook kept in the Die Department of the Philadelphia Mint from 1880 to 1886 by A.W. Downing (with a few notations by A.W. Straub; both men had the same first two initials), mentions an obverse and reverse die made for the Proof 1884 trade dollar in January of that year, no related notation is given for the 1885 trade dollar. These are significant and potentially revealing omissions, although they are by no means conclusive.
Indeed, numismatic scholars are confident that the 1885 trade dollars are products of the United States Mint, and were made in the year indicated. All five coins were certainly struck at the Philadelphia Mint from Proof dies, presumably during a single press run. The obverse and reverse dies for this issue were made from regular Mint master dies and prepared in the normal Proof manner. Apart from the date, a Proof 1885 trade dollar is identical in all aspects to one dated 1884, 1883, or any other earlier date of the Type II/II hub style.
We can even narrow down the exact striking period of these coins to the roughly six month period between January 2, 1885, when both the obverse and reverse dies of the Proof 1884 trade dollar were destroyed (as mandated by the Mint Act of 1873), and June 1885, when Archibald Loudon Snowden turned in his resignation as superintendent of the Philadelphia Mint. Snowden enjoyed a long, if interrupted, career at the Mint, first joining its staff in 1857 as a Register under his uncle, Mint Director James Ross Snowden. A. Loudon Snowden's various tenures covered the period of U.S. Mint history when many of the most famous restrikes, patterns and fantasy pieces were clandestinely struck for distribution to contemporary collectors. It is easy to assume that, before his departure in June 1885, Snowden had a hand in the production and/or survival of the five Proof 1885 trade dollars. Conversely, his successor as superintendent of the Philadelphia Mint, Daniel Fox, has no known association with the production or distribution of numismatic rarities and appears to have closely followed the rules that forbade selling patterns, restrikes and similar coins to collectors.
While numismatic scholars are confident of their answers to the questions, "When were the 1885 trade dollars made?" and "Where were the 1885 trade dollars made?", why they were made is less clear and still a topic of debate. Traditional numismatic wisdom has it that these coins were struck clandestinely by or, at the very least, at the direction of A. Loudon Snowden for personal gain. Proof for this theory comes from the lack of official documentation regarding the 1885 trade dollar, as related above. Yet it is not necessarily unusual for such mintages to have been omitted from the records, and other instances occur throughout numismatics.
Those who ascribe to the clandestine striking theory also point to the fact that the 1885 trade dollars were not generally known to numismatists until early in the 20th century. This also means very little, however, as numerous other 19th century rarities, including many patterns, were not known until after the turn of the century, nor were the 1873-CC No Arrows dime, 1854-S quarter eagle, and certain other coins produced during the 19th century. Augustus G. Heaton, who was one of the most careful students of American coins, was not aware of the existence of the 1870-S Liberty Seated silver dollar when he wrote his Mint Marks book in 1893, and Mint records are silent on that coin's production. New discoveries are always being made and will continue to be made. We note as a more modern example the 1978 discovery of the unique 1870-S half dime, an issue that is also not mentioned in Mint records.
That the Mint neither publicized the 1884 and 1885 trade dollars at the time of striking nor made them available on open sale to collectors is not necessarily unusual either. Many highly acclaimed rarities of the era including the 1877 pattern half dollars, the 1872 pattern Amazonian silver coins, the 1879 pattern Schoolgirl dollar, the 1882 pattern Shield Earring dollar, and the Coiled Hair four-dollar gold Stellas of 1879 and 1880 - to give a very short list - were obtained only through dealers who enjoyed special connections at the Mint. We are not stating that this was an excellent practice, for it was not. Yet even so, Mint officials and contemporary dealers can be credited with preserving for posterity coins that might not have survived otherwise.
It is highly unlikely that anyone within the Philadelphia Mint in 1884 or 1885 considered these trade dollars to be a significant source of secret profit. First, trade dollars were not popular with numismatists at the time. Second, if they had been made for a profit - as were, for example, restrikes of the 1856 Flying Eagle cent and the 1804 Class III silver dollar - they would have been marketed long before the early 20th century.
The Philadelphia Mint had been producing Proof trade dollars for collectors from the start of the series in 1873, and exclusively from 1878 onward. In early 1884, Superintendent Snowden received orders from the Treasury Department to cease production, sale and other distribution of trade dollars. The trade dollar was not officially discontinued until 1887, however, so it is possible that Snowden had his staff once again, as they had done in January 1884, make all of the necessary preparations for the striking of Proof 1885 trade dollars for sale to collectors as part of the year's Proof sets. What could have followed is a repeat of what happened with the 1884 trade dollars: Superintendent Snowden acquired five examples from the initial batch of Proof 1885 trade dollars delivered to the medal clerk. Until the 1930s, it was legal for Mint employees to obtain examples of new coinage in exchange for the equivalent amount of coin or bullion, which is almost certainly how Snowden acquired the 10 Proof 1884 trade dollars, and could also have been how he acquired the five Proofs of 1885. Shortly thereafter, however, Snowden would have been instructed that trade dollars were not to be included in the 1885 Proof sets; no additional coins were struck after that declaration, and any additional specimens that were still with the medal clerk would have been destroyed through melting.
While the foregoing scenario makes sense in theory, the exact status of the Proof 1885 trade dollars remains a mystery. They may have been produced clandestinely after all or, like their 1884 counterparts, they could be legitimately produced and obtained survivors from a Proof mintage that was cancelled early in the year, and after Mint employees had already taken the first steps for a large coinage. In the end it matters little, for the extreme rarity of this issue and the desirability of owning an example have been recognized since the early 20th century.
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family. Earlier ex Philadelphia Mint Superintendent A. Loudon Snowden, 1885; William H. Woodin, 1910 (probably); unknown intermediaries; B. Max Mehl's sale of the Fred Olsen Collection, November 1944, lot 1767; George Sealy Ewalt; our (Stack's) sale of the George Sealy Ewalt Collection, November 1965, lot 43; Leo A. Young; RARCOA's session of Auction '80, August 1980, lot 1626; Julian Leidman; Mike Follett; private collection; RARCOA's session of Auction '84, July 1984, lot 1810; John N. Rowe, III; L.R. French, Jr.; our (Stack's) sale of the L.R. French, Jr. Collection, January 1989, lot 202; Charles Barasch (International Coins & Currency, Inc.), circa 1992; E. Horatio Morgan Collection; our sale of the E. Horatio Morgan Collection, March 2020 Auction, lot 3216; Rare Coin Wholesalers (Steven & Michael Contursi).
To read the complete item description, see:
Landmark Rarity 1885 Trade Dollar
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFL9M/1885-trade-dollar-jd-1-jk-1-rarity-7-proof-63-pcgs-cac)
Historic 1848 CAL. Quarter Eagle
Our Nation's First Commemorative Coin 1848 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle. CAL. MS-61 (PCGS). A sparkling, vivid and handsome Mint State example, an attractive coin with subtly reflective fields supporting frosty motifs. Warm orange-gold in color with distinctive pinkish-rose highlights. Nicely struck in virtually all areas, though there is some weakness within the eagle's right leg plumage on the reverse, a sticking point with most quarter eagles of the era and hardly detracting given the overall quality of this piece.
In 1848 some 230 or so ounces of gold bullion from the recently discovered California gold fields was sent to Secretary of War William L. Marcy by Colonel R.B. Mason, acting military governor of California. Marcy turned the bullion over to the Mint, where it was used to strike 1,389 quarter eagles. In order to denote the origin of the gold used for this special limited mintage, the letters CAL. were punched into the upper reverse field above the eagle's head on all specimens struck. This distinguishing feature marks the 1848 CAL. quarter eagle as our nation's first commemorative issue, produced 44 years prior to the 1892 Columbian Exposition half dollar.
Given the popularity of the California Gold Rush era with numismatists and other collectors, the 1848 CAL. has long enjoyed strong demand. Indeed, the acquisition of an 1848 CAL. quarter eagle is a defining moment in the formation of any collection. Survivors are scarce, and appearances on the open market are rare, so much so that even the offering of a lower grade example represents an important opportunity. In PCGS MS-61, the offered coin is one of the finer certified and one of the nicest to appear in our sales in the last decade. Representing a fleeting opportunity for advanced specialists in Liberty Head quarter eagles and the numismatics of the California Gold Rush era, the present coin is sure to see spirited bidding at auction and fetch a strong price. Ranked #70 in the fifth edition (2019) of the influential reference 100 Greatest U.S. Coins by Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth.
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family.
To read the complete item description, see:
Historic 1848 CAL. Quarter Eagle
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFLBJ/1848-liberty-head-quarter-eagle-cal-ms-61-pcgs)
Handsome and Fully Original Sandblast Proof 1911 Double Eagle
1911 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle. JD-1. Rarity-5. Proof-65+ (PCGS). CAC. A fully original piece that displays the characteristic finish of this Sandblast Proof issue, both sides exhibit a coarse grain matte-like texture comprised of myriad sparkling facets. The color is a deep mustard-yellow with a tinge of rose, also characteristic of the issue, and the devices are fully defined from a razor sharp strike. Free of distracting "shiny spots" or other blemishes, and in fact overall smooth, this solidly graded Gem has some legitimate claim to an even higher grade.
Of the 1911 Proof double eagle only 100 were made. The Mint called these Sandblast Proofs at the time, but collectors often refer to them as "Matte Proofs." They were fashioned by taking a 1911 double eagle carefully struck on a hydraulic medal press and blasting it with a stream of tiny sand particles. This process was popularized at the Paris Mint in the 1890s and attracted the attention of artists and medalists in America, inspiring the Mint to use it for certain products such as Assay Commission medals.
As desired as Sandblast Proofs are by today's discerning numismatists, in their era they were not widely sought by collectors. Either not all of the 100 pieces struck were distributed, or most were later spent. John W. Dannreuther (2018) estimates that no more than 75 of the 1911 date survive today. Proof gold double eagles had little resale value and both B. Max Mehl and Henry Chapman stated that as they could only be sold for $21 or so, they often turned them in to the banks! Incredible to contemplate today. (Mehl once told Dave Bowers that he was in the dining car of a train, had left his wallet in the sleeping car, so spent a Proof Barber half dollar he had in his pocket).
In his May 1915 sale of the B.W. Smith Collection Mehl offered lot 13: "1911 Sandblast Proof. Very scarce, as but few Proofs were struck." It realized $20.60.
Beginning in a very significant way in the 1970s, the long-overlooked Sandblast Proofs achieved great market demand, which has continued ever since. We anticipate a great deal of excitement as this wonderful Gem crosses the auction block.
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family.
To read the complete item description, see:
Handsome and Fully Original Sandblast Proof 1911 Double Eagle
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFLZ7/1911-saint-gaudens-double-eagle-jd-1-rarity-5-proof-65-pcgs-cac)
Exquisite 1855 Wass, Molitor & Co. $50
Classic California Gold Rush Era Rarity 1855 Wass, Molitor & Co. $50. K-9. Rarity-5. AU-58 (PCGS). Truly memorable quality for this visually striking, eagerly sought, yet extremely challenging California Gold Rush issue. Survivors of Wass, Molitor & Co.'s $50 issue are usually heavily marked, at least moderately worn, and all too often outright impaired due to surface damage, repairs, and the like. Remarkably, none of these or any other significant detractions are seen here. Thoroughly PQ for the type, this piece carries evidence of minimal commercial use that takes the form of trivial high point wear to the design motifs and a few generally minor marks. Overall detail is sharp and allows full appreciation of this classic motif. The only mark that is worthy of individually attention - and then again only for provenance purposes - is a dull nick on Liberty's chin. The ubiquitous hairlines are seen on both sides, but they are light, minimally distracting, and represent a combination of light commercial and minimal numismatic handling. Considerable frosty luster and faint semi-reflective tendences persist, and they are joined by handsome color in light, even olive-gold. Extremely limited PCGS certification totals at both the Choice AU and Mint State grade levels solidifies the awesome condition rarity of this highly significant coin.
The story of Wass, Molitor & Company has its beginnings in the Austro-Hungarian Empire and the 1848-1849 war for Hungarian independence. Born in Hungary, Count Samuel C. Wass and Agoston P. Molitor both studied metallurgy in Germany before returning to their native country to pursue their careers in the Hungarian mining regions. There they remained until the winds of revolution that had been swirling around Europe swept into Hungary, culminating in a declaration of independence from the Austro-Hungarian Empire on April 18, 1848. Quickly Poland allied with the Hungarian revolutionaries and war against Austria and the Hapsburg emperor spread throughout the region. The war was finally suppressed in October of 1849, and many of the pro-Hungarian independence revolutionaries were forced into exile, including both Wass and Molitor. Seeing opportunity in North America, many Hungarian expatriates arrived in the United States just as the California Gold Rush was gathering momentum.
Arriving in California from the Old World, these immigrants found a booming economy struggling to cope with explosive growth. Within two years of the discovery of gold, the population in Northern California had quadrupled and continued to grow every day. Unfortunately, the money supply did not grow at the same rate and coinage of any sort was scarce. Transporting freshly mined gold to the mints back East was a long and arduous process and repeated petitions for a branch mint made to Congress back in Washington were met with opposition and would be held up for several years. While other parts of the country would address such monetary crises with currency, in the West paper was met with almost universal distrust. Indeed this was codified into Article IV section 34 of the 1849 California Constitution which forbade any bank to "make, issue, or put in circulation, any bill, check, ticket, certificate, promissory note, or other paper, or the paper of any bank, to circulate as money." Gold dust proved useful as a stop-gap measure but could be easily adulterated and its purity could not be consistently assured. Many local jewelers and assayers attempted to fill the need for coins but these efforts met with varying degrees of success.
Samuel Wass arrived in San Francisco in October 1850 and set immediately to work in the California gold fields. He produced a detailed geological report of the region which was published in the Alta California on January 13, 1851. Wass prefaced his report with the following explanation as to his reasoning behind his journey to the West:
Gentlemen-As a native of a mining country in Europe I have felt a great deal of interest in all that I have heard and read about this country. My curiosity was highly excited during my sojourn in the States, having received so many accounts of the extraordinary formations and riches of nature in California. I made up my mind to visit the place in the company with two friends… Wass quickly established a reputation as a highly regarded expert in metallurgy and the latest mining technology from Europe. Sometime in early 1851, Molitor arrived to California and soon joined his fellow expatriate. On October 14, 1851, the pair announced the formation of Wass, Molitor & Co. as an assay office located in San Francisco on Montgomery Street below Bush Street. Success came quickly to the firm and they relocated to the fireproof building formerly occupied by banker and Civil War general Henry M. Naglee, on the corner of Montgomery and Merchant streets. There, they set up an extensive smelting operation and assay laboratory that was widely praised in the local newspapers for its modernity. At least one newspaper noted that the firm did not endeavor to produce their own coins but rather used whatever was on hand to pay depositors. This may have been the impetus for the assayers to contemplate entering the coining business. In January 1852, Wass, Molitor & Co. announced that they were prepared to begin producing what they referred to as "small coin" in $5 and $10 denominations. The purity levels fell below federal standard, so to compensate, the coins were made slightly heavier. Their coins soon fetched a premium in circulation and were eagerly accepted in trade. The amount of these coins that were struck is not known, but may have been sufficient that no further coining operations were required for the next two years.
In the meantime, Congress finally granted approval for a branch mint to be established in San Francisco which commenced operations in 1854. The difficulty of acquiring the necessary parting acids for refining raw gold meant that it would be some time before the San Francisco Mint would be able to strike enough coins to relieve the region's monetary shortages. After an especially lengthy layoff at the Mint, in March 1855 a group of prominent merchants and bankers petitioned Wass, Molitor & Co. to resume coining operations. The firm responded in the Alta California that it was prepared to do so within a week. Shortly thereafter, Wass, Molitor & Co. resumed striking coins and produced $10, $20, and round $50 gold pieces. These, too, proved to be popular and circulated widely until the San Francisco Mint was able to produce the much-needed federal coins in a more consistent manner.
The design of the $50 piece is more functional than artistic. The bust on the obverse is small, seemingly more befitting a $20 coin. The reverse with its simple wreath surrounding the denomination resembles the contemporary fractional gold pieces. The May 16, 1855, Alta California reported that "Wass, Molitor & Co. have commenced issuing their fifty and twenty dollar pieces, at the rate of $38,000 per day. The coin is above the U.S. standard and is confidently received in trade throughout the State." The round shape also seems to have helped acceptance of the coins since they were easier to handle than their octagonal counterparts from the United States Assay Office of Gold. Despite their brief tenure in circulation at the tail end of the private gold issuing period, the $50 coins were readily absorbed into trade. By late 1855 Wass, Molitor & Co.'s coins were no longer required. Sometime in late 1855 or early 1856, Wass, Molitor & Co. dissolved and reorganized as Wass, Usznay & Co. Around this time, Wass left the region but eventually returned to continue the assay business with his son. Agoston Molitor left for London in 1856 and did not return to the United States.
Provenance: Property from an Alabama Family.
To read the complete item description, see:
Exquisite 1855 Wass, Molitor & Co. $50
(https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1XFMRQ/1855-wass-molitor-co-50-k-9-rarity-5-au-58-pcgs)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|